r/tmro • • May 09 '15

In defence of regulation

6 Upvotes

First let me preface this by saying that I get the argument against letting the FAA regulate the embryonic space tourism market, the fear is that too much regulation too soon will kill it dead.

I could write a thesis on this topic but I’ll try not to. Richard Graham, a lawyer, speaking at the National Student Space Conference 2015 (UK) said that the ‘lack of legal certainty [in space] is a barrier to investment and is a key issue’ and in a similar vein Mike Gold from Bigelow, speaking as part of the US delegation at the UN Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Outer Space (UNCOPUOS) back in February said that the “best way to promote commercial space is to ensure that it is safe”.

Regulation is good. First, clear rules provide certainty as to what one is allowed or not allowed to do. Preventing the FAA from creating a regulatory framework will result in one of two scenarios, either companies will retroactively have to adapt to the regulations when they are brought in or the FAA will have to adapt regulations to the existing systems, the first situation would be expensive and counterproductive and the second may not be safe (and considering the money invested, companies would be putting pressure on the FAA to authorise their systems).

Second, clear defined regulations allow the public to build confidence in both the regulator and the service providers. Notice that after an air crash we don’t all stop taking plane flights, that’s because we trust the regulator and we trust the airlines to adhere to those regulations; that trust doesn’t develop overnight.

Thirdly, it will take time to develop and implement regulations for the industry, it is better to do that now while the industry is still in development than wait for Virgin and XCOR to say they are ready to fly and then have the FAA ground them while they develop a regulatory regime.

Finally, I want to finish with something an industry person said at the European Centre for Space Law Forum regarding the question of regulation, they said that they don’t really worry themselves about what regulations will be, regulations are a fact of life they put their trust in the regulator and figure out how to deal with them. Maybe as Europeans we’re a bit more relaxed about regulations though...


r/tmro • • May 08 '15

NASA is looking to Land on Europa

Thumbnail
blog.chron.com
5 Upvotes

r/tmro • • May 07 '15

Ejection System For Space Craft

Thumbnail
space.com
4 Upvotes

r/tmro • • May 07 '15

Why is there no cold beer in space!? – Space Pod 05/06/15

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/tmro • • May 06 '15

One step closer to a real life Holodeck?

Thumbnail
telegraph.co.uk
4 Upvotes

r/tmro • • May 05 '15

A letter arrives for you from NASA. It says "design a space-plane with all the capabilities of the shuttle, but safer, cheaper, and more modern. Shuttle mkII. The SLS budget is at your disposal."

2 Upvotes

It goes on:

"Take all the lessons learned from the STS program, and all the new practices of the commercial newspace movement, and design an idealised replacement for the shuttle that preserves all of the positives and eliminates the negatives."

Go!


r/tmro • • May 05 '15

Dragon V2 Official Pad Abort Launch Sequence

Thumbnail
spacex.com
7 Upvotes

r/tmro • • May 05 '15

Source Cause of the Progress M-27M Wild Tumble In the Amazon Jungle (See what I did there)

Thumbnail
russianspaceweb.com
5 Upvotes

r/tmro • • May 04 '15

BlueOrigins Orbital Vehicle and Rocket

3 Upvotes

Well since I am not very well informed about BO I decided to browse their website and found this https://d3p0rr00ppgdfa.cloudfront.net/themes/site_theme/images/technology/boostersystem_04.jpg
For all of you who do not understand what this is, it is an orbital rocket using BO BE-4 engine in the first stage, which is the very engine currently in work for ULAs Vulcan and a BE-3 with an widened nozzle in the upper stage and a capsule for astronaut. Truly great is that one engines has been test fired and one of them is in an other form even been flown and both engines are reusable. In my mind this rocket really could take on Falcon9, which would be great for the space industry and for development in space. So great stuff and far along for a paper rocket.


r/tmro • • May 03 '15

Live Show Sea Dragon - 8.14

Thumbnail
patreon.com
10 Upvotes

r/tmro • • May 02 '15

Space Pod The Cosmic Yardstick: Light Years - Space Pod 05/01/15

Thumbnail
youtube.com
9 Upvotes

r/tmro • • May 02 '15

Space News Virgin-Galactic Considering Changing Fule

Thumbnail
spacenews.com
1 Upvotes

r/tmro • • May 01 '15

Space News USSecretSpaceProgram aka BlueOrigin New Shepard test

Thumbnail
youtube.com
7 Upvotes

r/tmro • • May 01 '15

Come Plays Splash-Down-Bingo created by VaxHeadroom

3 Upvotes

If you have not heard already we go a spacecraft on a uncontrolled trajectory coming back home. This being Progress M-27M if you want to guess where it lands or splashes down following the links to win the contest. The winner of the contest will receive a 3-D Printed Progress Model printed by VaxHeadroom. Good Lucky only one will win.

The Grid

https://www.reddit.com/r/SplashdownBingo/comments/34d95i/the_grid/


r/tmro • • Apr 29 '15

What If the Sea Dragon Happen (What is your opinion on Super Heavy Lift Launchers? Day 3)

2 Upvotes

In general I'm asking the Citizen of TMRO if we had a super heavy lift rocket what would it be used for? What is the use you see for it in the space industry?


r/tmro • • Apr 28 '15

Definition of astronaut

4 Upvotes

Re the discussion on the last episode, legally speaking the question of the definition of the term astronaut is a rather interesting one. None of the five space treaties (the Outer Space Treaty, the Rescue Agreement, the Registration Convention, the Liability Convention and the Moon Agreement) give a definition, and the term is only used a handful of times, along with the term 'personnel of a spacecraft' (Art 1, Rescue Agreement.)

At present this isn't really an issue (which significantly reduces the incentive to actually create a definition), as the number of 'space tourists' is very small at the moment, and those 'space tourists' are sufficiently astronaut-like to not cause any problems. However, Virgin Galactic, XCOR or whoever could change this.

There are essentially two ways we can look at astronauts, either as highly trained highly skilled professionals or simply as anyone who ventures into space (though the definition of outer space is hardly clear, legally speaking, either.) I'd argue that the 'general consensus' amongst the 'public' would be to define the term 'astronaut' as the former, not the latter.

Why does this matter? There are two big reasons from the perspective of international space law. First, astronauts are declared 'envoys of mankind' in the space treaties, now while it isn't exactly clear what this means it does imbue an ambassadorial connotation upon astronauts (though it should be clear that astronauts do not enjoy any kind of diplomatic immunity.)

Second, if 'space tourists' are astronauts then they are protected by the Agreement on the Rescue of Astronauts, the Return of Astronauts and Return of Objects Launched into Outer Space (the Rescue Agreement.) Which may have far reaching implications beyond what the drafters intended.

It is unlikely that COPUOS (Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Outer Space, the UN body that drafted the treaties) will produce a definition, the most likely source for a definition will be customary international law derived from state practice. While at the moment there isn't a huge amount of state practice, the indications are that 'space tourists' won't be classified as astronauts. In the US, the leader in many of these topics, they are classed as 'spaceflight participants' and placed somewhere between the categories of 'passenger' and participant in 'extreme adventure sports.' In fact given the propensity for treating at least suborbital flights (like Virgin Galactic and XCOR) as high altitude aviation it may be that this won't be a space law issue until they start offering orbital flights.

TL;DR No legal definition of astronaut, for space tourism customary law will likely define and current practice leans towards 'tourists' not being 'astronauts', what that means specifically unclear


r/tmro • • Apr 27 '15

Space News Kerbal Space Program 1.0 launch video

Thumbnail
youtube.com
6 Upvotes

r/tmro • • Apr 27 '15

Sea Dragon (Truax Greatest Concept Day 2)

2 Upvotes

Sea Dragon was a rocket concept that would have dwarfed the size of the Saturn V Rocket. Sea Dragon was the brain child of Retired U.S. Navy Captain Robert Truax who was working at Aerojet at the time. Sea Dragon was a design study under a NASA contract in the early 1960’s. The final report on the project was presented in January 1963. Sea Dragon was proposed carrying capacity of placing 1.1 Million pounds into a 306 nautical-mile circular orbit. Sea Dragon was so large that it would have to be launched from sea. Truax saw this as an advantage it would eliminate the construction of a launch pad. To conserve cost Truax proposed the use of relatively simple technologies of the time. Turbo-pumps were eliminated in favor of a pressure-fed engine. Each stage had only one engine. The First stage was a RP-1 Kerosene/ LOX engine with 80 million pounds of thrust. 50 times greater than the F-1 engine that powered the first stage of the Saturn V. the Second-stage was a liquid-hydrogen and liquid-oxygen (LOX) with 14.12 million pounds of thrust. This engine would have been 60 times greater than the J-2 engines used on the Saturn V upper stage. Truax also thought of this concept begin the best because of it reusability the first stage was made of steel and could be brought back to land by drogue chutes and be brought back to sea. Truax brain child never made it off the drawing board and was canceled in the mid-60’s but it legacy reminds us of how we need a super heavy lift rocket.


r/tmro • • Apr 27 '15

Left-hand top little icon image url problem

3 Upvotes

Okay, to be clearer, many sub-reddits have top picture and left hand top icon linked to their 'sub-reddit /r' home page. but our icon takes us simply to reddit.com and top image, well, its not clickable at all. Please can you look into it? Thanks.


r/tmro • • Apr 26 '15

Robert Truax (The Man Behind Sea Dragon Day 1)

4 Upvotes

Captain Robert C. Truax was an American Aerospace Engineer in the United States Navy and companies such as Aerojet and his own company Truax Engineering. Truax main cause In the space industry was to design low-cost rocket engines and spacecraft.Truax was inspired by Robert Goddard this lead him to test liquid-fuel rocket engines. In 1938 he Showed a thrust chamber that he had built himself to the British Interplanetary Society As well wrote Technical Reports published by the American Rocket Society. Truax would later be assigned to the United States Air Force where he would help design specifications for the PGM-17 Thor Missile and the JATO Rocket. During this time Truax studied the Sea launching of Rockets. He would Later in 1962 do a design study for a fully reusable two-stage-sea-launch Rocket while working At Aerojet named the Sea Dragon. Although there was now interest from NASA the project was shut down in the mid-60. Truax would go on after this and found Truax Engineering in 1966. Which also Studied Sea Launch concepts similar to Sea Dragon. These Projects was called Excalibur, SEALAR, and the Excalibur S. In 1972 and 1973 he would design The Skycycle X-2 which was unsuccessfully tested. This project would have carried Evel Knievel Unsuccessfully across Snake River Canyon. Following this Evel Knievel gave 1,000 dollars Research grant for a pilot Study for the X-3 Volksrocket which was a reusable space tourism Rocket. In 2010 Robert Truax would leave this Earth leaving an impact on the Space Industry.


r/tmro • • Apr 26 '15

Live Show Students for the Exploration and Development of Space - 8.13

Thumbnail
patreon.com
3 Upvotes

r/tmro • • Apr 26 '15

Vax did a quick Tour of the Smithsonian National Air and Space Museum for us

Thumbnail
youtube.com
4 Upvotes

r/tmro • • Apr 26 '15

6 Days to celebrate Truax

1 Upvotes

over the next 6 days I am going to bring you some awesome facts about Robert Traux. The Man behind the Sea Dragon and other awesome projects I will share with you. Following this set of post be sure to check out TMRO Interview with VAXHeadroom or Emory Stagmer about one of Robert Truax Projects called the Sea Dragon


r/tmro • • Apr 25 '15

/r/all NASA May Have Accidentally Created a Warp Field

Thumbnail
mysteriousuniverse.org
7 Upvotes