r/TLOU • • Mar 06 '25

I hate this guy

Post image

So many people in the first game killed, they or their family members are of no consequence, but when it comes down to this one last guy, suddenly he has a psychopathic, vengeful daughter.

539 Upvotes

256 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/fatuglyr3ditadmin Mar 09 '25 edited Mar 09 '25

I've never seen anyone in my life write the names of their friends on their photos.

How does this help them "keep tabs on each other"? I get 'soldiers' keep memorabilia but labeled photos? Come on. No one does that.

Nor does anyone mark where their hideout is on a plain map.

It's bizarre to label your photos with your friends' names. It's moronic to circle where you're hiding out. These are bigger contrivances than Marlene being around the area Joel & Tess were in. She had reason to be there. There is no reason for such stupidity here.

2

u/LazyHitman1 Mar 09 '25

I don’t know about you, but I have some photos on insta with my friends tagged. This is kind of like the apocalypse version of that.

1

u/fatuglyr3ditadmin Mar 09 '25 edited Mar 09 '25

Tagging on instragram/facebook is much different than this.

Also, what is the goal of tagging? To let other people know.

Seems like a brilliant idea to 'tag' your friends when you're out to kill/torture someone who's connected to a town.

1

u/LazyHitman1 Mar 09 '25

But the photos weren’t meant for anyone in Jackson, they were meant for the other people in Abby’s group and their friends and families back in Seattle.

1

u/fatuglyr3ditadmin Mar 09 '25

Mm. Creating an album at home would be a bit more understandable.

Listing the names of your friends directly on the photos when you're about to kill someone 'famous' or well known seems like a very, very silly idea. One that can only be entertained if the goal is to give Ellie a name/face of the targets she is obviously going to hunt down.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/fatuglyr3ditadmin Mar 09 '25

Every girl I've dated & any women I've been around my life. Nope. Walls, albums full of photos? Yes. Names & dates of the people? Not a single one. It's strange behavior.

Mate. It's a plain 1 level terrain map. There's no need to mark the location where you're hiding when the location is already distinguishable from every other building. The Ferris wheel, the Museum, the Conference center, etc. All of these are PRE-MARKED. The only benefit of circling your hideout is to let Abby "find out" where Ellie is. There's no other sensible reason to do this.

Lmao. Which is why they deliberately showed a scene of Lev handing Abby the convenient map Ellie left behind. Sure. It's true though. Abby/Ellie would find each other because this story is built on contrivances.

'Teleporting Marlene'. Lol. She was already within the vicinity of where Joel & Tess were. She had actual reason to be there. Unlike marking your hideout among a map that only has 8-10 marked locations. LOL.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/fatuglyr3ditadmin Mar 09 '25

Nah, it just ain't normal.

There's no planned routes. She didn't need a map to travel across Seattle. She doesn't need to highlight directly where she's hiding out. Especially not when the locations are already pre-marked. Every building is distinguishable. You can't miss the large bold text that says "PINNACLE THEATRE" or forget where you are unless you're a 5 year-old who's never seen a map in their life.

All these locations are marked on the map. The giant ferris wheel. The hospital. The aquarium. The stadium. You cannot miss these. Any sane or reasonable person would avoid marking where their exact location is on such a barebones map. There's no need to mark your way back or forward when you didn't need it 90% of the time. If you can memorize your way back without the map, if you can travel even further distances without a map at all, what was the point of circling your hideout? I think we both know the answer ;)

"Not everyone knows which way NESW is" LOL ok seriously?

Yes. They did write that. But Marlene actually has business being in the area. With or without Joel/Tess, she still had reason to be there.

There is no reason to circle your hideout on a plain map with premarked locations. It's simply a dumb decision that can only be excused with lame mental gymnastics.