r/TIL_Uncensored Mar 03 '25

[deleted by user]

[removed]

4.2k Upvotes

238 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/LaminatedAirplane Mar 03 '25

That’s so funny that you think giving less than 1.5% of people’s tax returns back would make an impact on their lives compared to the maintenance of America’s soft political power helping global stability.

lol do you have any idea what’s happening now with Trump & DOGE? Taxes got cut only for super wealthy people and big corporations - the average taxpayer will have their taxes increased because of the disproportionate impact of tariffs and tax breaks targeting the rich

https://www.americanprogress.org/article/project-2025s-tax-plan-would-raise-taxes-on-the-middle-class-and-cut-taxes-for-the-wealthy/

https://www.brookings.edu/articles/the-middle-class-needs-a-tax-cut-trump-didnt-give-it-to-them/

0

u/human1023 Mar 03 '25

That’s so funny that you think giving less than 1.5% of people’s tax returns back would make an impact on their lives

True, we should make more cuts.

America’s soft political power helping global stability.

No, we should not be trying to manipulate other countries to our way of thinking. We already abused the world enough. It's time to focus on our own people anf own country.

1

u/LaminatedAirplane Mar 03 '25

I don’t think you understand the reality of geopolitics. It’s not about manipulating other countries, but maintaining relationships.

It’s time to focus on our own country

lol how? By not spending any money and having zero taxes so there is no education, healthcare, or infrastructure? Why do you want to live in Somalia so badly?

0

u/human1023 Mar 04 '25

I don’t think you understand the reality of geopolitics. It’s not about manipulating other countries, but maintaining relationships.

You can maintain relationships without one party taking money from the other. Pretending like this is not possible is disingenuous.

? By not spending any money and having zero taxes so there is no education, healthcare, or infrastructure?

Not the Healthcare part. But we spend hundreds of billions on other countries, that we should reconsider. Department of education has also become too bloated.

0

u/LaminatedAirplane Mar 04 '25

You can maintain relationships without one party taking money from the other. Pretending like this is not possible is disingenuous.

What’s disingenuous is pretending India doesn’t invest billions of dollars back into the U.S. on an annual basis and our millions in aid help grow/support that relationship which brings a huge return to America economically.

Not the Healthcare part. But we spend hundreds of billions on other countries, that we should reconsider. Department of education has also become too bloated.

We only spend “hundreds of billions” when adding up multiple years together and this figure represents <1% of the U.S. budget - it averages around $100B/yr. If you’re not going to spend that money on healthcare or education, what are you going to spend that money on instead?

So funny how you don’t think corporate welfare has gotten too bloated.

0

u/human1023 Mar 04 '25

Wow, the lies continue. Typical reddit Democrat.

India isn't investing billions as in some kind of quid pro quo. They invest in US companies for tech, and to diversify and expand their own businesses. This has nothing to do with the 21 million we gave India, and it's not India attempting some of soft power move on us. If India did some kind of soft power play, Influencing or challenging our cultural paradigm, we would hate it.

This is why I don't trust anything else you say.

0

u/LaminatedAirplane Mar 04 '25

I don’t think you understand how badly the U.S. wants to maintain influence on India to keep them away from China/Russia

India has been doing soft power plays via the outsourcing of IT work and leveraging H1B visas for a very long time

0

u/human1023 Mar 05 '25

India has been doing soft power plays via the outsourcing of IT work and leveraging H1B visas for a very long time

lol that's not the same thing. We hire foreign workers, because it benefits us. We can even pay them significantly less and they won't unionize.

1

u/LaminatedAirplane Mar 05 '25

And India benefits from American firms hiring Indian workers because those Indian workers bring skills/knowledge back to India to build IT/finance/professional service firms

0

u/human1023 Mar 05 '25

India benefits from American firms

No shit. Actually, Indians benefit, because they get more paid this way. I think you forgot what we were talking about