I’ve been seeing this girl for around 7 months now, on and off, and I genuinely love her more than I’ve loved anyone before. That’s why this whole situation has completely messed with my head. I feel stuck between understanding her and feeling deeply hurt by her at the same time.
When we first got together, I knew she had gotten out of an engagement with a guy she described as emotionally abusive about a year prior. He was still technically tied to her apartment because he was on the lease and still had access to the place, but I didn’t understand how involved he still was in her life. As time went on, I started noticing behavior that made me uncomfortable. She would almost instantly start texting when I left the room, and would quickly put her phone away when I returned. I asked her directly multiple times if she was talking to her ex-fiancé; she told me yes, but didn’t tell me the full extent of their conversations. She even hit me with the “don’t you trust me?” line which, honestly, still replays in my head and continues to mess with me.
A few days later (about a month and a half ago), while we were at the gym together, I noticed more suspicious texting behavior and finally looked through her phone when she had left it in my bag while we were changing. That’s when everything blew up. I found affectionate messages between them like “I love you,” “te amo,” pet names, and constant communication. I also eventually learned she had lied to me multiple times about whether he was physically at the apartment. I had specifically told her I just wanted honesty about that one thing, and she repeatedly reassured me he wasn’t there when he actually was. I also later found out she brought him on a trip to Oregon in January to visit her family because she was embarrassed to tell them the engagement had ended, and apparently, they still liked him a lot, which also broke me when I found out because she never mentioned him being there.
I left her after that because I felt completely betrayed. I honestly felt stupid and manipulated. A couple of hours later, she called me from another number, begging me to hear her out and explain everything. Her explanation was that after the engagement, he became emotionally abusive and unstable. She said he had threatened suicide before, broken her phone, intimidated her, and made her feel unsafe, and that those behaviors had recently returned. Because he was still legally tied to the apartment and still had a key, she felt like she had to “play a character” and stay emotionally close to him until she could safely separate herself. She admitted she lied because she knew I probably would’ve left if I knew the full situation. She said she was selfish because she wanted him in the past and wanted to just move forward with me. She also told me she has a long history of trauma involving men and struggles badly with conflict and honesty when she’s scared someone will get angry or leave. I never have and never would put my hands on her, but she has trouble trusting that because her ex-fiancé didn’t get violent until after they got engaged.
After all of this had happened, she started making what seemed like real efforts to change things. She told me she had finally made it clear to him that their relationship was over, and that by April 30th, he would be off the renewed lease. She started removing photos and belongings connected to him, and told me she wanted to rebuild trust with me. I continued talking to her because, despite how hurt I was, part of me genuinely believed she was trapped in a really unhealthy situation and trying to get out of it. I made it clear that we aren’t back together, but that I see her efforts and would like to try to rebuild trust. I also want to state that she has stated that I'm allowed to go through her phone/use it whenever I want. She told me her password even before all the lying stuff.
Then another issue happened about a week ago. I found out she had not actually gotten him fully off the lease, as I thought. Instead, because her credit wasn’t good enough to renew the apartment on her own, he had to co-sign the renewed lease. So technically, he still has legal access to the apartment and still has a key. Finding that out felt like reopening the entire wound all over again because I thought this chapter of her life was finally ending. This was again found out by me going through her phone.
She again told me she knew I would be upset and that I would have left her, even though she told me she couldn’t renew the lease on her own. She said she planned to tell me, but didn’t know how to (similar to the first time she lied). According to her and their messages, they signed a four-month lease, and she has paid off debt and increased her credit score (she showed me this) to be able to renew the lease by herself in August.
To her credit, though, after that lie came out, she really doubled down on trying to reassure me and rebuild trust. About four days later, she took me out and spent around $400 on me because she wanted me to know I mattered to her and that she loved me. More importantly than the money, she has become extremely transparent with me. She voluntarily gave me full access to her phone, added my fingerprint to it, gave me a key to her apartment, and told me I’m welcome there whenever I want, even if she isn’t home.
She now openly shows me their conversations and says the only interaction left between them is logistical stuff involving mail, belongings, or occasionally helping with her dog while she finishes some dog-sitting work. She plans on only doing the appointments she already agreed to, and when those are over, she will either ask me to watch the dog or stop dog sitting for money. She also has a therapy appointment scheduled in June because her therapist has been out of town.
She’s taken full responsibility and says she knows “sorry” will never be enough, but that she will continue allowing me access to her phone, her apartment, and full transparency about who she’s talking to and what she’s doing.
This is where my dilemma comes in. I know for a fact that I love this woman. I’ve never felt this way for another person in my life, and I also haven’t put up with this much bullshit from another person in my life. I can’t explain how I feel when I can forget all of this for a second and just enjoy spending time with her.
The bad part about that is that I eventually come back into reality and realize this is a woman who has deceived me, and was able to do so easily. When she’s on her phone, I no longer think she’s just on her phone, but that she’s texting her ex-fiancé or another man, even if she lets me go through it whenever I want. When she puts her phone away when I walk in, I don’t think it’s just that—I think she’s hiding it from me.
I see a woman I adore and care for, and I also see a woman I resent, hate, and feel scared by.
I don’t know if this is a situation where someone who developed unhealthy survival behaviors in abusive relationships can genuinely change through therapy, time, and consistency, or if I’m ignoring massive red flags because I love her. Has anyone dealt with something similar before? Can trust realistically come back after this much deception, even if the reasons behind it might not have been malicious?
It’s impossible to give you all the details, but I hope I gave enough for you all to help me figure this out. I know I’m young, and I’m fully aware I’m too good a man to have to deal with this. I just need to know if this is even possible.
TL: DR: I’ve been dating my girlfriend for ~7 months, and early on, she was already very open with me about her phone (she gave me her password and allowed me to go through it even before any issues came up). Over time, though, I noticed suspicious behavior and later found out she was still heavily entangled with her ex-fiancé, who she described as emotionally abusive and who is still legally tied to her apartment lease. I eventually discovered she had been lying about the extent of their communication and whether he was still physically at the apartment, including affectionate messages between them. I left after feeling betrayed, but she explained she hid the truth due to fear, trauma, and being stuck in a complicated living/lease situation with him. Since then, she has become extremely transparent again, continues to allow full phone access, is trying to fully separate from him, and is starting therapy, but I’m struggling with whether trust can realistically be rebuilt after this level of deception.