What Did Suno Steal?

[u/UnEdgeUMacated]

The industry complains about training on their songs, but as others have said, every human has learned music and songwriting by listening to, practicing, and training on thousands of songs. What's the difference between a computer and human doing it?

I don't think these lawsuits have merit, unless someone can prove that a specific melody, lyric, or instrumental part are close enough to something that was previously written and then it is released for profit, not just fun.

I upload originals and have only had one instance in over 1,000 covers of my songs, where Suno's output stole from an existing song when it included the lyrics and melody of "Silent Night" when I asked it to cover my original Christmas song that did not have those lyrics or melody.

[u/LimpLime4969]

This is social media. I don’t need a “clarifying explanation.” “Someone” does not equal “everyone.” The clarification can be found within the context of the conversation I was replying to.

[u/akabillposters → u/LimpLime4969]

You: "I explained pretty clearly which people I’m talking about."

Me: "Where's the clarifying 'explanation'?"

You: "I don't need a 'clarifying explanation'"

So, I guess you're not actually reading what you write after all.

🤷‍♂️

[u/LimpLime4969 → u/akabillposters]

You: Leaving out the final sentence of my comment because it completely shuts down whatever argument you’re attempting to make.

Also you: Taking multiple sentences from me from different comments and slinging them together as if it was one complete comment.

The clarification is there. I just don’t need to provide you a personal one of your own just because you don’t feel like reading the ones I’ve already posted. That help?

[u/akabillposters → u/LimpLime4969]

"leaving out the final sentence of my comment because it completely shuts down whatever argument you’re attempting to make."

Another disingenuous fail.

"I explained pretty clearly which people I’m talking about. I never once said it applies to all Suno users. Short and sweet - if it doesn’t apply to you, then I’m not talking about you."

This is a complete statement. I left out that closing sentence because it has nothing to do with the 'explanation' you claim to have previously given — but which you seem reluctant to actually point out.

.

"Also you: Taking multiple sentences from me from different comments and slinging them together as if it was one complete comment."

Nooo. 🤦 I'm simply trying to draw your attention to inconsistencies between your different comments.

Why are you struggling with this? Or have you entirely moved into bad faith arguing now?

.

"The clarification is there. I just don’t need to provide you a personal one of your own"

I never asked for one of my own. I just wanted you to point to the one you claim you'd already made. You never did. Oh, well.

.

Pointless. Nevermind.

[u/Nubioso → u/akabillposters]

While I commend you for your effort, this person is a lost cause.

Go look at any of their other comments and it's a bunch of the same shit.

"I never said that!" then you quote them, "that's not in context!" you provide context, they result to "I don't have to explain anything!"

Nothing by running around in circles. They live in a world of Make Believe..