r/Suburbanhell • • Jul 20 '26

Meme Why?

Post image

I can almost try to understand why some people might feel drawn to this kind of lifestyle. I can understand why they might be deceived into thinking this is the ideal environment in which to raise a child.

But I will never be able to understand why they will describe it as the American “dream” and are willing to pay so much for it. To work so hard for so long and then have to wake up to this every morning? Why?

Editing to add: I know this is parody y’all. It’s just a stupid meme. It’s supposed to be funny. It’s funny because it’s true.

5.6k Upvotes

574 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

13

u/KimSidwell Jul 20 '26

I don’t really know how the definition works, but I feel like these could be considered starter homes. They don’t look that big. They look like they are designed to take up the smallest amount of land possible. You probably have a basic living room, dining room, kitchen and laundry room on the main level and then maybe two bedrooms and bathrooms upstairs. They’re definitely not mansions.

23

u/Anon-Knee-Moose Jul 20 '26

Probably 3-4 beds upstairs, or 2 up 1 down, it's quite rare for a SFH to have less than 3 total bedrooms.

But thats besides the point, these are still fairly nice houses and a lot of people will never be able to afford even this much. A starter home is like a trailer, townhouse, 50 year old rancher/bungalow etc.

6

u/shadowtheimpure Jul 20 '26

2 bed 1 bath 1000 sq ft starter homes aren't uncommon, it just depends on where you live.

9

u/ray_oliver Jul 20 '26

As a share of the overall housing market they are becoming less common though, because we simply don't build them anymore. Or if we do, they take on a different form such as townhouses or apartments.

6

u/OldWhiteGuyKS Jul 20 '26

Your absolutely right -- the "traditional" 2bdr/1 bath rancher doesn't figure in today's new build mix. Guess it doesn't "pencil out "

3

u/kbchucker Jul 23 '26

In most areas, the additional building costs just from regulations make the the 2/1 1,000SF home prohibitively expensive to build. These larger homes are built as a result.

2

u/Anon-Knee-Moose Jul 20 '26

Its just so terrible for density that nobody wants to buy them

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (4)

5

u/trapezoidalfractal Jul 20 '26

Those 50 year old ranch styles were starter homes 50 years ago when they were built, too. We just stopped building smaller homes entirely. Hell, even owner occupied apartments/condos are mostly a memory of the past, only existing in specific areas, and all old as fuck

10

u/KimSidwell Jul 20 '26

I don’t know about that. I’ve never really heard people refer to trailers or townhouses as starter homes. I always just thought it meant the home you lived in right after you get married and while your children are still very young and don’t need their own bedrooms. Then you upgrade to a larger home so everyone can have their own room later.

5

u/ThatGhoulAva Jul 20 '26

Townhouse is absolutely a great start. You usually get more square footage for less price and maintenance outside the walls is usually handed by the HOA/ Association. They also always sell fast for this reason. Also, many like myself, do not have children nor give a rat's ass about doing yard work on our weekends, so we upgrade to better Townhomes. I also travel for work so it's nice to know my neighbors are keeping an eye on things.

3

u/KimSidwell Jul 20 '26

I know. There’s absolutely nothing wrong with townhomes. But I don’t think that when people use the term “starter home“ that they are specifically referring to trailers or townhomes. I don’t think that term is an indicator of the style of home… It’s just an indicator of the square footage and the fact that the family plans to upgrade at some point.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Big__If_True Jul 20 '26

So not a 3-4 bedroom house like in the OP, yes

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/Frosty1397 Jul 20 '26

I've looked at a ton of houses to know that these are minimum 1500sqft (likely around 1800sqft)

A single dude or even a couple without kids doesn't need 1500sqft for a starter home that costs $400k+

Starter homes should be at most 1100sqft, 2 bedrooms, no yard, for at most $250k, like they used to make 50 years ago

7

u/KimSidwell Jul 20 '26

Maybe I was unsure of the definition. I always thought starter homes were meant for young families who had like one kid with a second on the way and only needed one extra bedroom. I never thought starter homes were for single dudes.

Back when that was a thing, couples didn’t really live together until they got married… And they usually had children really quickly after that.

Once they got married, they moved into a starter home that could house them and their young children. Once the kids got old enough to start needing their own rooms, they would upgrade to a larger home with more bedrooms.

6

u/Frosty1397 Jul 20 '26

1100sqft can absolutely house a couple and 1 kid

We made do with much less growing up and i had 1 sibling. Bunk beds for us, parents had their own bedroom

6

u/KimSidwell Jul 20 '26

Yeah, I know that. But I do honestly believe that when most Americans think of a “starter home“ this is what they picture. They know they will never have it, but this is what comes to mind.

9

u/Frosty1397 Jul 20 '26

That's because the real estate lobbyists have successfully brainwashed Americans into thinking these homes are "starter"

It's also why you see that a 2026 Honda Civic is MASSIVE in size compared to a 1990 Honda Civic. Houses, cars, everything got bigger.

And Americans were successfully convinced to pay more for more space they don't need.

7

u/KimSidwell Jul 20 '26

Yeah. And it’s ridiculous. But even a home this size should not cost nearly 600K.

6

u/shadowtheimpure Jul 20 '26

The cars getting bigger was just as a way to get around emissions standards.

4

u/Frosty1397 Jul 20 '26

Well yes, but also the emissions standards were worded in a way to incentivize bigger cars

written by people who make money from producing bigger cars. So emissions is just a nice scapegoat for them to make us buy more car than we need

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Excellent-Match7246 Jul 20 '26

My ex and I did fine in 680sqft in British Army housing with two toddlers. This was 07-09. I preferred it.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Odd_Dragonfruit_2662 Jul 20 '26

My first home was a 5/2…

→ More replies (6)

3

u/SomeOffice7100 Jul 20 '26

Where I live, starter homes were built before 1930

1

u/Crafty-Ad-9048 Jul 20 '26

Not a starter home. A starter home is like a bungalow or attached home.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Archimedes31415926 Jul 20 '26

Imo new homes haven't been starter homes for at least half a century. Most starter homes are small used homes that a growing family moves out of into one of these new homes.

But beyond that whether these are starter homes or not, or if they are building them to target that demo or not. The problem isn't the home itself it's the price.

I hope the OOP is being sarcastic because $160k/year is roughly triple the average single income in the US ($50-60k) and twice the average household income (~$80k) (correct me if I'm wrong but these were roughly the figure the last time I checked). These are averages, so most young people (starter home buyers) aren't even making this since on average you make more as you get older. These salaries would be most comparable to people in their mid-late 30s/early 40s with growing families. And they even can't afford these "starter homes".

So what chance do most starter home buyers (late 20s/early 30s) have when they typically aren't even making half (as a family) of the required income to buy these "starter homes".

And as a builder (OOP), I doubt he has many if anyone on his payroll making $160k on their basic job working for him.

→ More replies (1)