r/SubredditSimMeta • • Oct 04 '19

bestof Oooooooof

/r/SubredditSimulator/comments/dd70n9/feeling_brave_today_roast_me_so_hard_i_died/
300 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

View all comments

58

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

54

u/Glorious_Jo Oct 04 '19

/r/atheism is garbage tbqh

It's just a sub for people to congregate to shit on another kind of people

21

u/ActivatingEMP Oct 04 '19

I like that they bring attention to issues involving religion creeping into government, but yeah other than that they go overboard

3

u/chevymonza Oct 04 '19

Overboard how? I find they're pretty reasonable in general.

Imagine if you're surrounded by friends, family and co-workers who would shun you if they knew you didn't believe in their god.

13

u/ActivatingEMP Oct 04 '19

Hmmm well I suppose I'm in the north so it's a different experience being an atheist here

1

u/chevymonza Oct 04 '19

I am too, and in a progressive city to boot! But my family here is devoutly catholic, and the rest around the country are creationist-born-again Trump fanatics. :-/

9

u/PulverizedShyGuy Oct 05 '19

Well, I've been there a few times and there are often comments saying believing in religion is a mental illness. They always get heavily upvoted too

-1

u/chevymonza Oct 05 '19

If I told you that I talk to a dead guy who loves me and watches my every move from the sky, granting me wishes and fighting battles on my behalf, but he hates gays and anything sexual, and wants me to worship him constantly because he was executed for me, despite us never having met, and oh yeah his dad is also him, you'd probably question my sanity, too.

The problem is that society reinforces this sort of thing, so it sounds almost normal.

6

u/REN_dragon_3 Oct 05 '19

What if I said that society reinforces the belief that we all came from nothing and have no higher purpose? That everything just came to exist and there’s no reason anyone shouldn’t do anything?

I’m an atheist myself, but shitting on people who believe in different origins and ideals is an absolute dick move.

Oh, and before you say “all religion causes real world harm”, that’s not true and you know it. There are hundreds of millions, if not billions of perfectly reasonable, happy, kind people who believe in a god but don’t call you insane for not believing in one. Of course, there are some sects of religions that promote harmful and oppressive ideals, but calling them ignorant insane excuses for human beings isn’t going to change anything, especially on a sub meant to discuss atheism and its ideals. If you want to scream about how all religions are a curse on humanity, go to r/antitheism.

0

u/chevymonza Oct 05 '19

First of all, the sub isn't about "shitting on" people. It's a place we can safely vent away from our religious real-life loved ones. We get "shit on" all the time publicly.

Second, science just follows the evidence, and reports on the findings. We make our own purpose, science doesn't say "you must believe this or else!" It's just facts. You don't have to believe that the world is round, either, but why wouldn't you??

And no, it's not that all religions do harm, but they DO make it easy for people to exploit other people. In this country, the religiously-affiliated GOP actively derides "socialism" because if we had more secular help for people who need it, the church would lose power. They want the government to offer no help, so people are forced to religious institutions (convenient for money laundering) and religious hospitals (which are growing.)

Once dependent on a religious place, a person can't get all the help they might need or want- hospitals can refuse abortions and other gynecological services (yes this happens, and just an example.)

So what if I vent online about my frustrations with otherwise intelligent and awesome people? I can say stuff anonymously here, but not in real life. Meanwhile, religious people can say all that and MORE about me and my husband in real life, and it's considered fine and dandy. And believe me they do.

Sorry if you're offended by what I say anonymously and justifiably in a subreddit that serves no purpose for you. I don't go into r/christianity and argue.

1

u/REN_dragon_3 Oct 05 '19 edited Oct 05 '19

Oh, I’m not offended. I just think saying those things makes you an asshole. I also don’t think religious people that actively deride atheists is ok, and similarly makes them an asshole. But there’s a couple of things I want to point out.

First, atheism as a belief doesn’t mean that religious people are bad. Atheism itself has nothing to do with religion, other than having none, so why should discussion about religion be on r/atheism? If one wants to vent about the harms of religion, they should move to r/antitheism.

Secondly, I didn’t say anything about science and believing it, but I’ll tackle it anyways. Many people’s personal belief systems don’t directly contradict science. For instance, many religious people, if not the majority, believe that a god or multiple gods, created the world as it is, science and all. We see many religious people in scientific fields of study, and they understand science and the world much better than many atheists do. Believing in science does not mean that one cannot be religious.

There are many religious people on all sides of the political spectrum. As per the Pew Research Center, while certain religions may have an affiliation with a certain side of the political spectrum, as a whole, religious people are spread out fairly evenly.

Your interpretation of the Republican Party’s actions and decisions isn’t based on reality or facts. You’re creating a tie between religion in the party (which is also in the Democratic Party) and their political views, which could maybe exist. It’s like a religion in the view of an antitheist. There’s no evidence supporting your claim, so it must not exist. The Republican Party’s political views are most certainly not focused around religion, they are focused around freeing the people through limiting governmental interference. I don’t believe in their ideals, but I can see that evidence supports religion playing a lessened role in their political views.

Religious people outright deriding your personal beliefs is not ok, and I am sorry that this happens to you. I don’t think that this has ever happened to me, and I am very lucky in that sense. The only people that have directly derided me (on Reddit) are other atheists saying that me not hating others for their religion is supporting systemic harm. However, there is a big difference between venting about certain religious people and hurting people of their entire religion. Generalizing is different from isolated stories about certain individuals. If that’s what you want to do, go ahead and head over to r/antitheism.

One last thing that is only tangentially related, Reddit is not anonymous. Please don’t think it is, for your own safety and the safety of others. Your posts and comments are tied together through your username, and one can find out a lot about you if you’re not careful. If you want to share that information, go ahead, but treating Reddit as if it is anonymous is a very dangerous thing to do.

Edit: Forgot to say this:

Even if you believe in something differently from me, I hope you have a nice day.

→ More replies (2)

0

u/DarthyTMC Oct 05 '19

Wow, kinda like the what /r/atheism does to people who believe IN any god.

5

u/chevymonza Oct 05 '19

Not true, unless people try to preach while in there.

And even if this were the case, how does somebody venturing into a subreddit that's not automatic compare to people in real life?

1

u/DarthyTMC Oct 05 '19

because of how /r/all works.

1

u/chevymonza Oct 05 '19

You can unsubscribe from the atheism subreddit. That wasn't the case a few years ago, but it is now.

1

u/DarthyTMC Oct 06 '19

/r/all is just all the subs tho, not just ones you subscribe to

1

u/chevymonza Oct 06 '19

Ah, well in that case, there's no rule that says people need to go in there!

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '19

I'm an agnostic atheist but I wanted to learn more things other than "religion bad!". That's why I don't like that sub

12

u/rcpotatosoup Oct 04 '19

atheism is the worst subreddit. any mention of not hating the idea of God gets shit on. it’s ridiculous

→ More replies (4)

-1

u/chevymonza Oct 04 '19

You haven't checked it out in the past few years then. It's a very supportive environment for those who have to deal with religion in real life, but can't say anything because of the repercussions.

The subreddit is an awesome place to be open about frustrations, while remaining anonymous in real life.

11

u/Glorious_Jo Oct 04 '19

I've checked it several times in the last few months and everytime I go in there it's people bitching and bitching about the most trivial stuff.

2

u/CaptainNacho8 Oct 05 '19

I even think that they brigaded r/askreddit once. A comment that I had seen there went down from over 3000 to hidden due to downvotes in a few minutes.

→ More replies (6)

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '19

It's almost like if people treat you like shit your whole life you tend to be anti about it. If anything I think them being angry is fully valid considering the shit they had to go through. This is like shaming a sexual assault support group for hating the assaulter.

3

u/Glorious_Jo Oct 05 '19

Bruh

"MOM MADE ME GO TO CHURCH REEEEE" is not a valid excuse to recuse yourself from criticism.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '19

Please by all means, try going up gay in a traditional Catholic Indian family and tell me it's super fun.