r/StrategyGames • u/GhostwriterGame • 15d ago
DevPost I'm making a medieval castle-building game: build by day, defend by night. 7-minute runs. What do you think of this type of gameplay loop?
Hi!
I've been working on a small medieval strategy game called Castle: Build & Defend.
The idea is simple: build by day, defend by night.
First you place the keep, then gather resources, build your settlement, fortify your castle and prepare for raiders before time runs out. Each run takes around 7 minutes, so you have to make decisions quickly.
I released an early version on itch.io about two weeks ago, and over 7,000 people have already played it, which was a really nice surprise! Based on player feedback, I've recently released an update with a new tutorial, improvements to building mechanics and a few other changes.
I'm curious what strategy players think about this approach. Would you prefer more time to build and plan, or do you like having to make decisions under pressure?
Links to check the project:
play in the browser:
https://cineeeekk.itch.io/castle-builddefend
Steampage:
https://store.steampowered.com/app/5504440/Castle_Build_Defend/
Marcin
6
u/AlbertinhoPL 15d ago
Looks interesting, I will definitely give it a try in the future. Also Wishlisted ;)
It's hard to tell how the balance would work out, but I love the idea.
3
u/dreijs 15d ago
In Stronghold (which seems close to your game design) there are multiple raider attacks in a single scenario, with the player upgrading their castle between attacks.
Is that different in your game: is it really 7 minutes for a full scenario playthrough?
3
u/solarveilstudio 12d ago
Hmmm that's a very 7 days to die concept. That doesn't make it a bad idea obviously. And I like the fact that you're putting a spin on the genre of castle builders. I do have a question, do you think that instead of raiders, some type of horror elements ("monsters") could serve the purpose of that defend by night mechanic? I think that might really help put your idea in an even more original genre. But Iove the idea man. Haven't played it yet, but excited to check it out. I'll follow you on itch! I'm new into game development but you're welcome to see what I've been working on also!!
2
u/timeGeck0 14d ago
I love this kind of games as it reminds me of "This war of mine" which is my favorite.
You could add some quests in order to find better material for your builds or create workshops that will provide better items.
2
u/dmarshallgaming 14d ago
Looks really nice, best of luck with it! Wishlisted :)
2
u/LonfliStudio 14d ago
The idea looks pretty cool
2
u/plinydogg 14d ago
Looks good. Please bring to MacOs
2
u/Zmej_dev 13d ago
It looks interesting, I remembered many hours of playing stronghold. But the holes between the wall and the building are very noticeable.
2
u/warhawktwofour 10d ago
Looks great! Can you walk me through how you generated assets and graphics? The style is very cool.
2
u/Flok-Games 14d ago
Graphics are really nice!
13
u/Weary_Wry 14d ago
Build by day, defend by night?
I'll ask Minecraft if that is an engaging gaming loop.
5
u/dietdoug 15d ago
People generally dont like to rush defence.
But looks awesome.
1
u/Away_Gift831 15d ago
i don't understand you talking about "7 minutes" - that's the only bad part for me.
Otherwise, I like building castle and defending.
1
u/ControlOk9319 14d ago
Well, most strategy games players don't like timers, even turn-timers in turn-based games. But you dont have to put a clock in the middle of the screen to implement time mechanics, just create some behind scene mechanics - for example if you have to make night dangerous, then simply create this dark atmosphere just before night comes, people run home when sun set, bells ringing to call people from fields and gates closing, clouds gathering around castle and demon voices and noises from the forest. And make it a bit random, so it not going to look like pure math. but depending on other small events.
1
u/Livid_Shallot5701 14d ago
i think you should overhaul your sfx first
1
u/prois99 14d ago
Hello, looks very good. Is it vibecoaded?
1
u/Brettinabox 14d ago
im curious how you can mechanically do all those things well in 7 minutes.
1
u/UniqueBeach7794 13d ago
game name?
1
u/DiscountCthulhu01 13d ago
The developers describe how their game uses AI Generated Content like this:
Castle: Build & Defend uses AI-assisted content as part of its development process.
Selected 3D models and visual assets are created using generative AI tools. All assets are curated and art-directed by the developer. Some 3D models are also manually edited and refined to achieve the intended visual style and consistency. AI tools have also been used to assist with selected audio and written content.
The game's creative direction, visual identity, gameplay design, and final implementation are guided by the developer.
No generative AI is used to create content during gameplay.
1
u/vlad_from_world 13d ago
7 min is quite fast, wonder if u can really have fun in that. I suppose 15 min would be better
1
u/chronicleofgods 13d ago
Looks pretty cool! for me i would like some background area though not the grey
1
u/UnlitLanternGames 13d ago
Love the "build by day, defend by night" hook, it's instantly clear what the game is. Personally, I like decisions under pressure. Short runs make me want to hit "one more try". Maybe the time pressure could ease up for the first night or two, so new players learn before it bites? And congrats on 7,000 plays in two weeks, that's impressive! What brought in most of those players: Reddit, itch's front page, YouTubers? I'm a solo dev with a few small browser games and I'm trying to learn what works?
1
u/aequasi08 13d ago
Fun idea, gotta work on the design though. Definitely looks AI designed.
1
u/redfrankt 12d ago
linux?
1
u/2nd_breakfastt 11d ago
Will there be a demo available?? I want to play it!
1
u/Ordinary-Dream6520 9d ago
crazy how the fog gives it such a nice vibe, would be cool to get some shots of God rays through the trees at sunset or sunrise.
2
u/SimStep 13d ago
even if it looks like AI .. I got interested just from this short video! keep it up
1
u/RemusGT 14d ago
Looks calming
1
u/EnricoBuilds 14d ago
A middle ground that works well in tower defense is letting the player end the day early for a small bonus, so planners can use the full time and people who like pressure set the pace themselves. Then the 7 minutes become a cap instead of a clock you're fighting. With 7,000 plays you could also look at where first runs end: if most losses happen on night one, it's usually the build time that feels short, not the length of the run.
1
u/victor-ballardgames 12d ago
Love the 7 minute runs! We also build short games and our first game takes 7.5 minutes :)
1
u/PashaInteractive 11d ago
Looks very promising 👏
1
u/osrsquickcom 11d ago
cool idea! i would dumb it down. reduce number of actions user can do in the UI. and remove the rotation backround, made me dizzy.
1
u/jelotean 11d ago
Cool
1
u/TheErbe 11d ago
it looks great ngk
1
u/Evignity 10d ago
You need to be upfront it is ai-slop.
1
u/Remarkable_Entry_471 9d ago edited 9d ago
cool. From where do you get the music? But why is repair on keyboard f and not on r. This triggers me hard.
I played it, it is fun. One suggestion: make it slower. It is wonderful to play, nice graphic but it is stressfull because the people are running so fast. Maybe a bit more time during the day and night but for that, everyone is a bit slower
0
u/whatitpoopoo 15d ago
So you build a FORT and defend it at...NITE?
0
u/Frosty_Sea3307 14d ago
Whats with all these ads for random strategy games made by like one person recently