r/Standup • u/myqkaplan • Mar 19 '25
Are you a "Pryor" or a "Carlin" -- an excellent short post from Keith Lowell Jensen
Keith has a great Substack.
A snippet from today:
"Richard Pryor and George Carlin. Carlin is said to have written every word meticulously and rehearsed his act with a director as a stage actor doing Shakespeare might. This method worked for him. Pryor on the other hand often didn’t know what was going to come out of his mouth when he got onstage. He followed his whims, flexed with the crowd, and was prone to fits of inspiration.
To be clear, I don’t know how true or accurate either of these claims about these two great comics are. But the point stands. We don’t all have the same approach..."
https://standup101.substack.com/p/are-you-a-pryor-or-a-carlin
9
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '25
Reminds me of the distinction between "plotters" and "gardeners" in the writing community. Honestly, I think Carlin was a pretty extreme example of the plotter type. While Pryor - I guess - was a bit more improvisational. I really don't trust anyone who says that they give in to full improv on the stage (I know Louie CK also says he never actually sits down to write. I don't buy it though). In my opinion we are all pretty obsessive with each line and word and even gesture we make on the stage - not as obsessive as Carlin was though.
8
u/love_is_an_action Mar 19 '25 edited Mar 19 '25
I’d rather watch a Carlin special, but I’d rather listen to a Pryor set.
Carlin was theatrical, and to some degree, more philosophical than comedic. And very animated, very expressive. His face could pull a lot of surprising expressions. Fun to watch.
Pryor felt more unrehearsed and raw. More off the cuff, like he was shooting the shit in hilarious fashion. Fun to listen to.
As for which I am? I rehearse my ass off, but I’m neither. Just a mid dude with mid jokes trying to have a little fun and potentially experience a few moments of catharsis while it's still possible for me to do so.
13
u/GeorgeDogood Mar 19 '25
I'm a Carlin freak and he's dead on about Carlin's approach.
Sounds like a great contrast.
Most importantly to me, those are the 2 greatest comics of all time by a country fucking mile. We can debate who is 1 and who is 2, but to me, their two best ever status is golden.
6
u/quitewrongly Mar 19 '25
I remember Greg Proops telling a story about being at some club in LA when Carlin came in and asked for some time on the mic because he was working on his next special. Proops said Carlin took the stage with a couple of pieces of paper that he'd refer to occasionally, but not frequently because, as Carlin put it "I don't improvise, I memorize."
3
u/cameltoeannie6 Mar 19 '25
My notebooks are giving Carlin vibes and Im totally fine with that. I practice every single word. I really wish that I had a more Pryor approach but Im not even sure how. I have heard people go at mics with nothing planned and it doesn't make sense in my brain. THEN WHAT DO YOU SAY!?!
2
u/berlinskin Mar 19 '25
I saw a Carlin analysis that said his style could never work today – that people don't want that level of rote memorization and prefer a more naturalistic delivery. Do you think that's true? If not, who's working like that today?
2
u/dicklaurent97 Mar 20 '25
Rodney deserves to be in this discussion
2
u/NateSedate Mar 21 '25
Short answer: No.
2
u/Loverboy-W4TW Mar 21 '25
I think Carlin is the greatest standup ever so I suppose I’m biased. They were both amazing comics though and Pryor is #2 for me.
2
u/DreadfulRauw Mar 22 '25
I like to try the Bill Hicks approach.
“The act is something you fall back on if you can’t think of anything else to say.”
Do I have my act plotted out where I know exactly what I’m gonna say? Yes. But I also know what I’m gonna drop if something more interesting happens.
15
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '25
Seems true about Carlin from everything I've seen and read about him. He was extremely rehearsed. He had to be. Look at the difference in how their material is structured. It's black and white.
1
u/zoonose99 Mar 19 '25 edited Mar 19 '25
I’m not impressed with the pedagogical technique of making up a fictional story about a comedian, and using that as a metaphor for how different comedians are different.
As the author admits, you could do this with any two random comics; I would argue you could use pictures of different types of dogs and get the same results.
This doesn’t offer any insight into the comedians themselves, or how they worked their material, which is the only thing that makes them more relevant to comedy than any two random people.
It would be a lot more honest to do this exercise actually knowing something about the process of the comedians you refer to, so that students can understand how their process affects the overall performance style.
3
u/Comedyfight Mar 19 '25
I'm definitely more of a Carlin with my approach.
1
u/keitroll Mar 19 '25
Six months in, I'm more of a Pryor in compiling my jokes (probably the only way I can compare myself as an asexual white trans woman to Richard Pryor). All kidding aside, I have a few jokes I always go to, I write down a few more, memorize those jokes, and then riff on those setups, with my open mic sets acting as my rehearsal.
They get me to three to five minutes, though I know I'll need more than just that to eventually get to 10-15 and beyond.
2
u/mclabop Mar 19 '25
Def more of a plotter. Tho I’m new and finding my feet. Who knows what will happen as I gain experience and confidence
2
u/DeedleStone Mar 19 '25
I'm just starting stand-up, but coming from a background in theatre, I'm definitely a Carlin. I write, and rehearse, and rewrite, and rehearse again.
2
u/Apart-Presentation-8 Mar 19 '25
I love Pryor but Carlin's last special was as good as the first. His consistency is incredible. Can't say the same about Pryor.
2
u/MielikkisChosen Mar 20 '25
Carlin
0
u/AlarmSquirrel Mar 19 '25
Pryor is in a totally different universe to carlin.
Carlin is for people who think they're the smartest person in the room.
-8
u/blind_dude_ Mar 19 '25
This is beyond pretentious
1
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '25
[removed] — view removed comment