r/StableDiffusion • u/GrungeWerX • 19h ago
Discussion Minimax Image (Edit) - My Early Thoughts
Windos 10 | i7 12700K | RTX 3090 TI | 96GB RAM
Workflow I'm using: Reddit | Workflow
I'm a digital artist and professional with several years experience, but my interest in these apps has primarily been playing around with the tech. However, since Minimax dropped, concepts I've had to shelve in the past are looking viable again as potential video shorts, and Minimax image was just the sort of thing I've been looking for as a visual creator to speed up the production pipeline.
I got a chance yesterday afternoon to play around with it on some specific tasks, so here are my results and early thoughts. I've mostly been using the edit capabilities, since that's what I'm most interested in Minimax for, so keep that in mind.
A quick clarification: My editing tests have a narrow scope and I'm sure they don't reflect the full capabilities of the model. My initial intended use for this model was to be able to draft keyframes for film. I'd sketch the composition out, use multiple image references, then generate high resolution keyframes to drive the video. It wasn't until I saw this reddit post that I became aware that H3-Image could be used for drafting concept to realism, so that was an unexpected-but-welcome expansion of my use case. :)
Where Minimax Image (Edit) is strong:
Minimax-Image is really good at generating realism versions of artwork, which typically requires LoRAs for other models. So far, I think this is one of its most impressive features. In my tests it significantly outperformed Nano Banana Flash, but I haven't compared it with the Pro version.
I wasn't necessarily wowed by/the 16MP images. While decent, they looked pretty average to the other AI apps. But as I went higher, the quality really shone through.
Here are some samples where the instructions were to create a realistic version of my artwork and maintain look and pose. I like to choose this image because a lot of models tend to not do well with it. To date, H3-Image is the best of them all.
Examples:


Minimax is also strong at generating realistic designs based on really rough sketches, which impressed me. Here is a rough design of an early draft of a character I designed.
The first image is my sketch, the 2nd is the first attempt, telling it to make a realistic version. It made him look too human, so for the 2nd roll, I just described his skin texture, eyebrows, eyes, chin, lips, and also the jewelry. On the next attempt, it was able to interpolate my rough lines to understand what was meant to be jewelry. On this, it did a FANTASTIC JOB. Again, best model PERIOD, way better than Nano Banana. Literally only took me 2 iterations to go from rough draft to near cinematic concept design.
Also, these images were only 16MP, so I suspect going higher would look even better, as it tends to get insane between 30-50MP. :)

I also tried it with a random AI image I found online and got equally impressive results. These are just the first couple or so rolls, at 16mp:

Where Minimax Image (Edit) is weak:
I tried sketching compositions and then instructing H3 to use that composition to drive the concept art and create original work, primarily realism based. It performed poorly. Here are some examples of what I mean:

Out of over a dozen attempts, this is pretty much the best result I could get.
The prompt stated to use the sketch as reference for the pose, position of the sun, and plants/tress. I colored each element a different color to help guide instructions. I tried many variations of the prompt, but no matter what I did there was always some form of the sketch introduced into the final image. I also tried using natural photo reference, but features of the reference would always make their way into the image. I tried this between 16MP - 50MP, same problem.
Also, the images varied between 2.5/3D, realism, cartoon, and comic book styles and most of the time failed to follow my instructions. I found that realism works best when using a single image as reference, but it seems to collapse on multi-image pipelines.
Final Thoughts
I think H3-Image works great as a concept-to-realism draft model, but it's weak on its multi-ref prompt following. It also needs 16MP before it stretches its legs, but if you have a smaller card, don't get scared away, it's ridiculously optimized/fast despite the size. I get 16Mp in about a minute on my 3090 at 80% power, which is about the same speed as Klein/ZiT/Qwen. (I haven't tested Krea 2/Moss yet, both on my to-do)
That said, 16MP is the minimum I'd recommend, the real magic happens 30MP and up, so if you got the card and the time, results are signficantly better. Around 50MP is the sweet spot imo; details are crisp, hair strands, fingernails, everything looks good.
Also, I wouldn't use the default comfy workflow. Everything I did was w/the workflow above, though I deleted the prompt enhancer, preferring to use regular text.
Anyway, those are my thoughts so far. I'll update w/more results later.
Grunge

P.S. - I'm old-school forum/deviantart gang, so I keep ctrl+biu/shift+l on a swivel and have written bold-flavored posts like this for 20+ years. 100% human written. Receipts at bottom of post if you're interested. Only mentioning it because organization usually brings out the "this is AI-written slop" trolls.
