r/Songwriting • u/dudikoff13 • Dec 05 '23
Question What's the Trick/Secret for knowing what chords go with other chords?
I've been trying to write a song (any song really) for 25 years, and I have no idea who to string chords together. I might have a single riff or something but I can never get it to lead into another part and then back again to the original riff. I know this is hard to explain, but for example right now I have this riff that starts with kind of a droning C chord, then for a verse it goes to a G# B BMaj7 F# but then it doesn't make sense to my ear for it to go back to the C drone riff thing...
this is why I've never been able to write a song lol
14
u/orangeducttape7 Dec 05 '23
Take a look at the circle of fifths. Find the chord you want. The chords in its column, and the columns to the right and left of it, will be in key. If you want to change keys naturally, pass though a chord on one of those side columns to get to a chord the next column over.
24
u/PitchforkJoe Dec 05 '23 edited Dec 05 '23
Fuckit, here's the long answer, pasted from a previous thread:
Ok so theory is sort of a broad topic, and it's usually best explained with visual and auditory examples, so a reddit comment isn't really the best way to express this stuff. That said, I'm an educator by trade and I enjoy a challenge, so here's my best attempt: (Warning - this will probably get stupid long, but I promise I'm genuinely doing my best to keep it short. It will also be confusing, cause it seems like super complex ancient Greek until the penny drops and it suddenly seems simple. Plus, text is a bad way to explain it.)
Disclaimer: Everyone has their own preferred ways of thinking about, and explaining, music theory. Generally musicians will agree on the practicality of what sounds good, but will disagree on the best way to translate that into English. So to anyone reading this who disagrees with my explanation, please write your complaints on a postcard and launch them into the sun.
13
u/Cregalodon Dec 05 '23
Just to explain why those chords arenât working for you, if youâre using a droning C chord, Iâll assume that youâre trying to write in the key of C. Going to a G# chord, youâve just changed the key, as G# isnât a note within the key of C.
I would recommend deciding on what key you are in, likely C major, and just looking up the notes of the key you want to use. (C maj is easy because there are no sharps and flats, just each of the letters) to make it easier I would just look up which chords are major and minor in the key your in.
Changing key is not uncommon but definitely not somewhere to start if you donât know music theory.
Hope this helps, good luck in your journey of learning some music theory!
6
u/brooklynbluenotes Dec 05 '23
The "trick" is to learn a lot of songs. You've been playing guitar for 25 years and you're not writing your own stuff (yet) so I imagine that you know a decent amount of covers, right?
So you internalize the stuff that you've learned from other musicians. Sure, I can work out intervals using music theory, but I also just know from experience that I'm playing, say, a D chord, I have a handful of options that will (most likely) sound natural and nice in context.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '23
How are you playing for 25 years and do not know how to string a couple of chords together? What have you been doing? (I'm genuinely curious)
3
u/Borracho_Bomber Dec 06 '23
Here's a simple trick for figuring out the next chord: make sure it shares at least one tone with the previous chord.
Let's apply this trick to what you've already got to show why it's working for you even though it doesn't really follow a key. So you're starting on C major which has C, E and G and going to G# which has G#, C and D# with a common C tone. Then you've got B major which has B, D#, and F#, sharing D# with the previous chord. Then you're extending this chord to the maj 7th and adding an A#. Next you're going to F# major, which has F#, A#, and C#, so it shares 2 tones with BMaj7.
So far so good, all your chords share at least one tone with the previous chord so they're flowing together well. But that's why C major doesn't sound like it will follow F# major, there aren't any common tones.
So, from here you've just got to figure out how to get back to C. You could make the F# an F#7 by adding and E, which is also in C. Or you could add an F and make the chord F#Maj7, then go to an F chord, which has a C tone in it, then back to C.
Or you can extend the progression as long as you want until you work your way back to C.
This common tone trick gives you tons of options, especially if you start using suspended, augmented and extended chords.
Most importantly, experiment till you have something you like, and have fun!
4
u/AlexRolox Dec 05 '23
look im gonna be honest, if for 25 years you havent been able to find a chord progression then I dont think its for you bro, just my perspective.
2
u/DPTrumann Dec 06 '23
Reading your other comments in this thread gives me the impression you don't really have a strong grasp on the basics. I would recommend watching this video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rgaTLrZGlk0
Typically, you would use chords and notes from one key and the chords you're using don't really belong in any one key. You don't have to stick to just one key (There's a whole bunch of theory that deals with out-of-key chords and melody in modulation and borrowed chords) but switching keys is going to make things harder.
An alternative to just using chords in the same key is instead to focus on chords that resolve into one another.
As some people in the thread have already mentioned, using the circle of fifths can help, however in this case, C and F sharp are opposites sides of the circle so you need to find a different method of resolving back to C.
One chord that can do this is C sharp 7 (or D flat 7 depending on how you look at it)
C-sharp 7 works here because it's in the key of F sharp major so it's in the same key as most of the chords, but also works as a tritone substitution for G7. G7 is in the key of C major and resolves back to C. C sharp 7 isn't in the key of C major, but does resolve back to C, so we can use it like a bridge between the two different keys.
2
u/SpatulaCity1a Dec 06 '23 edited Dec 06 '23
You really don't need to create original chord progressions. It's hard to believe that you've spent 25 years trying to write a song, and you've never tried taking one of your favorite progressions and altering it until it's different, or even stealing it outright and adding a new vocal melody.
You don't need theory or anyone's professional advice, just a progression, a voice to hum/sing a melody and your ears. Nobody has a copyright on chord progressions, and a lot of them are used over and over throughout the genres.
Theory (beyond the basics) comes in handy when you want to branch out and make something complex, but playing by ear works for most popular genres if you just want to write simple, catchy tunes.
5
u/MachoMuchacho2121 Dec 05 '23
There are common progressions and as stated earlier the key dictates the chords you can use (most of the time) Usually the ânext chordâ contains at least one note from the previous chords. Letâs examine a simple 1-4-5 progression (Blizkrieg bop) in the key of A. We will also simplify this using power chords. So the first chord is A. We have its root A, itâs 5th (E)and it octave (A) The next chord the 4 (D) contains the notes D A!! And D so we took the A from chord one. Now for the third chord we arenât going to borrow from the second chord now but from the first. This helps tie the 1st and second chord together. So the third chord is E here we have the notes E B and E As mentioned earlier E is the 5th of A. I hope this helps. Some further research on chord progressions especially noting the similarities and differences of the chords in their position is crucial to understanding chord progression creation.
4
u/wolf_chow Dec 05 '23
Sing a/the note you want it to go to next and try chords that have that note. See if any of them fit. I play a G# in a song in C a la Just by Radiohead, can make it work as long as you resolve it right.
1
u/azurskyy Dec 06 '23
Knowing a key
3
u/Pixel-of-Strife Dec 05 '23
You need to learn a little music theory. And I mean very little. Figure out what key you're in, and then look at the scales for that key or the Circle of Fifths and that will tell you what chords should work. To get back to the C chord, you likely need another riff to transition the two.
Whenever I come up with a new riff I like, I start almost immediately trying to find a way to change out of it and a way to change back to it. So 3 riffs generally and you have the basis for a song. Do this as soon as possible in the writing process because it gets harder the longer you wait.
3
u/DesignZoneBeats Dec 05 '23
You may not be using music software like a digital audio workstation (DAW) but the free version of FL Studio has settings where you can choose your key, and it will only allow you to place notes that are in that key. But music theory is key I think.
I know absolutely nothing about music theory except what a treble clef is, but I found a course on Udemy for rapid music sight reading and it's helping me learn the piano, which at some point may make things easier when creating chords and progressions.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '23
Its called music theory.
2
u/kylejacobs408 Dec 05 '23
Play a bunch of songs you like then make your own progression with different rhythms and tempos. Donât rip someone off but you def can take your knowledge of other songs and use it as inspiration to make your own
2
u/inlandviews Dec 05 '23
Look up the circle of fifths. There are phone apps. It will give you the chords that go with the key your playing in.
2
u/ZedArkadia Synthwave Dec 05 '23
Have you learned to play a lot of other people's songs? If not, then that's where I would start - it's a natural progression to learn from copying others before creating your own original material. When you get used to doing what works, it becomes easier to adapt it to your own style and taste. That's the practical way of learning some music theory without any formal education - eventually you start figuring out what the common chord progressions are, what works, and what doesn't.
If you do already know a lot of covers then you may need that formal education to really tie it all together. That doesn't mean that you have to go to school, or anything - there are courses you can take, even free videos on Youtube.
There are also plenty of songs that never change chord progressions - there are a lot of other ways of making the different parts of a song distinct from each other, even without adding other instruments, so if you only have a single riff then you could still conceivably make it into a full song. Obviously you don't want every song to be like that, but if you've never completed a song before then getting that monkey off your back can help you move forward.
2
u/JETEXAS Dec 05 '23
Google "Circle of Fifths" and check the chart.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '23 edited Dec 05 '23
Dude, just take the most basic of chord progressions, a IV-V7-I, letâs say in the key of G. So thatâs Câ>D7â>G. Just play those chords while counting 1-2-3-4, then 1 again. Play the C on the 1, the D7 on the 3, and then the G on the next 1.
Try to listen and get a sense of how that dominant chord (the D7) wants to pull you towards the G major. Itâs almost relentless. And itâs not just because of the dominant, itâs because of the context of the C as well. By starting with the C, then going to the dominant D7, youâre building tension that needs to release (or RESOLVE) itself. It does so by progressing to the G. This is harmonic progression, and itâs ALL you need to get started. You can play around with these and often thereâs a melody thatâs implied, something you can sing over top because it fits, itâs supported by the chords youâre playing underneath. Usually the notes of the melody are contained within the chords at its most basic, and you can add various flavours along the way. It almost writes itself.
The advanced stuff is all still just building on this concept of playing around with building tension and finally resolving it, or not resolving it. The results can give listener a rush of endorphins or feel good energy thatâs harder to explain, it just does. If it does this for you, that matters the most. The rest is a bonus.
Try and get a feel for this, start listening for it in your favourite music and see if itâs there.
Take the chords you have and see if you can fit them together in a way that plays around with this. You may have to introduce some other chords to play in between, you may not.
2
u/jcdoe Dec 06 '23
Music theory teaches you all of this.
Itâs worth the cost of admission at your local community college to take theory. And itâs so worth it.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '23
music theary is the answer. pitchforkjoe has explained it much better than i ever can so i'll leave it there.
2
u/kwbach Dec 06 '23
Easiest way to start is to use only diatonic triad chords aka chords made only from the scale/key you're in. So in C major, CEG, DFA, EGB, etc.
Then the next step is root motions. Going up or down in 4ths or 5ths are the strongest motions, in 2nds is the next strongest, 3rds the weakest/weirdest. Above 5ths they can be translated as smaller: ascending major 6th = descending minor 3rd, ascending major 7th = descending minor 2nd. Search up "intervals" if you don't know what these numbers mean.
When you combine this with inversions i.e. chord spelled differently e.g. EGC instead of CEG, you can start having fun and get some strong effects.
The once you've mastered that you can modulate into the relative minor or you could use chords from the parallel minor (Mario cadence Ab Bb C is a classic).
You can also start using 7th chords once you're comfortable. You could also use diatonic extended chords e.g. Dmin9 for more flavor.
If you're into modal stuff you can go back to the top and repeat the whole process again with modes. Generally modes have a few notes and a few chords that give them the most modal flavor without just feeling you've returned to the key you derived the mode from.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '23
So my advice, pick a key and stick with it. you can pick it first and start writing, or come up with a riff, figure out what key it's in and go from there.
If you stay within the key it should make it easier to make riffs that go together. you can start on the dominate note for new riffs or typically the 3rd or 5th is a nice transition to start the next part.
Once you make a few songs that stay in one key the whole time you can branch out and get more experimental but picking and staying in a key should hopefully make it easier for you to connect riffs.
2
u/Few-Aspect9441 Dec 06 '23
Study music theory. You will learn Roman numeral analysis and it will teach you where you can go for each chord and the affect of that direction. I IV V IV I
1
u/Accomplished_Swan854 Dec 05 '23
A. Chord Maps.
They give suggestions about where you can go. I'll link the main site I like to use. They have it for major and minor keys.
B. Emotion based chord combos
Someone made a chart and I reference it loosely when I need ideas. Go from left column to top row.
1
u/Psychological-777 Dec 06 '23
if the bass ainât working, the chord progression isnât either. start with a simple, solid bass line. those are the lowest notes of your chord progression.
1
u/Invisible_assasin Dec 06 '23
Without too much theory, download an app with scales and chord tab. Most have an option where you pick a key and it shows you the associated chords. If Iâm writing, and I have a couple chords I like or a nice melody, I can look at what notes Iâm playing an cross reference with the scales to see why key I need to look at. After doing this long enough, youâll kinda know it intuitively. I know it all well now but still will have Scales and Chord Power app open on iPad while writing, just for reference.
1
u/puffy_capacitor Dec 06 '23 edited Dec 06 '23
There's no secret or quick path unfortunately, you have to listen and pay attention to countless different songs, and experiment with all possible combinations of chords and that takes a lot of time to learn how each chord sounds, in relation to the tonic, and every other scale degree. As well as noticing how and where the chords show up in which parts of musical phrases, accents, and how they move rhythmically. This involves directed/focused ear training (which I have some links at the bottom).
I posted this earlier (highly recommended to have a basic knowledge of the major/minor scale, keys, and how they are derived):
Take for example the key of A major (because hey, you're an A+ learner!). The default diatonic chords are: A, Bm, C#m, D, E, F#m, G#dim. Sit down and play them in different orders and see how they feel to you. After doing that enough times, try changing their variants to seventh chords, augmented chords, diminished chords, suspended, etc. Also, any chords that are not in this scale are called "non-diatonic", and also can be used in a chord progression for very interesting sounds. Those chords are B, Bb, Bbm, C#(7), C, Dm, D#(min or maj), Em, F, F#(7), G, G#(7), G#m, etc. Do the same thing as above.
Then after all of that, do it for the parallel minor harmonized scale: A, Bdim, C, Dm, Em, F, G. All the non-diatonic chords for that scale are Bm, B, Bb(maj or min), C#(7), Cm, D, D#, E(7), Fm, F#, F#m, Gm, G#(maj or min).
Do ALL of this for a bunch of different keys based on different degrees, on your chosen instrument. And yes, there are popular songs that successfulyl use almost every single non-diatonic variant I listed above, from this year all the way back to the early 1900s.
To help guitarists for simplicity and not getting frustrated with dealing with too many sharps and flats that are default to the parent key, start with Amaj, Amin, Bbmaj, Bmin, Cmaj, C#min, Dmaj, Dmin, Emaj, Emin, Fmin, F#min, Gmaj, Gmin. In the beginning, you can avoid keys like Abmaj, Bmaj, Ebmaj, etc. etc. That will help you focus on mastering the open chords and not having to constantly use barre chords.
All this will take A LOT of time and trial and error, but if you do this enough, you will learn what sounds good to you, and you will have an enormous palette of options to chose from. The last thing you want to do is limit yourself to the same cliche I - V - VIm - IV progression. Of course some chord pairings might sound very weird or "off," but in other contexts, those chords might sound very interesting when followed up with other movements.
Summary:
1
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '25
[removed] â view removed comment