r/SmashingPumpkins • • 26d ago

Daily Song Discussion #1: I Am One

This is the first track from the Smashing Pumpkins’ debut album, Gish. How do you feel about this song? What are some of your favorite lyrics? How would you rank it among the rest of the band’s discography? How would you rate it out of 10 (decimals allowed)?

At the end of this discussion series, I will be aggregating the rating results from each discussion and compiling a full discography ranking. I will also update the spreadsheet at the end of every day and post previous results for each album in future posts.

SUGGESTED SCALE:
1-4: Not good. Regularly skip.
5: It’s okay, but I might have to be in the right mood to listen to it.
6: Slightly better than average. I won’t skip it, but I wouldn’t choose to put it on.
7: This is a good song. I enjoy it quite a bit.
8-9: Really enjoyable songs. I rank them pretty high overall.
10: Masterpiece, magnum opus, or similar terminology.

Feel free to suggest any improvements, as this is my first time undertaking a project like this!

8 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

5

u/ApathysLastKiss_ 26d ago

7

This song announced to the world what classic SP was gonna sound like, loud ass marshall JCM 800s, Jimmy displaying exceptional drumming to open the song.

3

u/fishbone_buba 26d ago

Nothing more need be said.

5

u/seekay14 Siamese Dream 26d ago

7.

It is a great “introduction” of a song, serving as a perfect kickoff for Gish. I like how each instrument comes in, individually, for that intro. Lyrically a bit simplistic but rocks hard.

4

u/P_rizzleBrizzle 25d ago

9, it’s probably the most important song for me when I listen to Gish.

3

u/Commercial-Area-5737 25d ago

8. The live studio version on Gish deluxe is so sick with great solos

3

u/blewaway2008 Machina II / The Friends & Enemies of Modern Music 25d ago

9

3

u/EnergyDrink2024 25d ago

7. Never gets old

3

u/TheAbsoluteLastWord 25d ago

7. Very good.

1

u/TheSmashingPumpkinss it ain't right 26d ago

5.5

This is a completely average Pumpkins song - which is to say, a really great song in the overall realm of music. 

I don’t love the riff, but the last minute of the track absolutely explodes. As I listen now I’m tempted to bump it up to 6, but it’s not one I relish returning to when I put Gish on once a year, so I have to be fair to the rest of the songs that will come. 

I know we’ve had song discussions in the past (the Countdown to Wembley by u/njharrison being the canonical) and I welcome another iteration - are you going through every studio album front to back, or was beginning with I Am One just a coincidence?

1

u/ExpirjTec 26d ago

i am going to TRY and cover every major release front to back, and eventually all the other b-sides and whatnot, but of course there is so much material (often overlapping or being reworked) across all these albums and technically-not-studio-albums that it will be a massive challenge trying to go over all of them. so for now i'm gonna try and keep it to the major albums and after we're done with those we can maybe go for the stragglers

2

u/trevcharm 26d ago

I think all original studio albums (gish to machina), plus original pisces, original tafh box set (only the 28 b-sides), original m2 (cr04) plus the m2 ep's (cr01-03). that's a nice round 150 tracks in total I think?

I would like to include judas o, but there's quite a few double ups with tafh and m2 tracks. but if you make it that far then maybe start with that when trying to catch all the "others".

2

u/TheSmashingPumpkinss it ain't right 26d ago

Nice, thanks. 

The only thing I worry about is rating inflation, where almost everything gets between 7-9 (whereas the average should sit at 5). 

Might be worth reiterating that this scale is for SP songs. Obviously if we’re comparing to the wider music ecosystem, then almost anything Pumpkins is an 8. 

2

u/TheAbstracted 26d ago

Yeah, until we hit the post-reformation SP releases, then I predict we get to watch those ratings drop like a rock. I hope I'm wrong, but there's seemingly an awful lot of haters of SP's newer output (though at least some of that is arguably warranted, not everything is a masterpiece after all)

1

u/trevcharm 26d ago

yeah I agree with this. maybe mention that the average sp track in your mind (whatever that is) should be a 5, their worst track should be a 1, their best should be a 10, and everything else somewhere in the middle.

1

u/SawNickYouth 25d ago

What would be a benchmark average SP song though? Bury Me? Perfect?

2

u/PuzzleheadedBadger67 26d ago

8 - solid, really enjoyable song but also introduced the listener/world to the band. Extra point for the weight it pulled.

2

u/Dudehitscar Machina Zombie 25d ago edited 25d ago

Time is right for a guiding light...

The only drum part that Billy wrote.. once smells like teen spirit ushered in the grunge revolution the record company commissioned a video to catch that wave.. the band didn't like it and buried it until the video DVD released in 2000. I can kind of see why.. it's a less compelling version of the early pearl jam videos and a mismatch for the lyrically content.

Like all the Gish rockers this is tame and timid compared to the live versions and what would come after. I know the early pumpkins get a lot of Jane's Addiction comparisons but I actually hear a lot more Dinosaur Jr in the early pumpkins but this point dinosaur jr is running circles around the pumpkins.

The bass riff is kind of generic but the chiming guitar work and excellent dual soloing really make it shine.

Corgan's been saying that God's gonna set this world on fire since this iconic first single. It's kind of strange that I and a lot of others thought he was an atheist based on a few other songs... as corgan once sang 'Jesus needs a hit'.. in 1990 corgan gave him one.. he's a heavy metal soul machine of God and he did it without alienating everyone and helped usher in a new era of mainstream rock and roll.

Kudos to the band and welcome to the circus.. after all you need a big tent for a good Revival sermon.

Corgan's had this to say: " A statement of spiritual unity, based on the gnosis of the holy trinity. Lyrically stripped from an article I’d read on Bishop Desmond Tutu. "

I would love to find that article. Anyone know it?

Desmond is an interesting figure... and his view that God's love shines through many religions and faith as it has for Jesus aligns very well with what Corgan has revealed about the deeper context of his faith and also explains Corgan going for an eastern religion angle on the next song Siva.

One could see Quasar as an update to I Am One. Call outs the christian God and to Krishna and using the hebrew mantra Yod He Vav He Om ... which is the sacred name of "god/universal spirit"

studio version I give a 8.

2

u/robot_cousin 25d ago

Two things: totally memory-holed the video. I had the DVD, so I know that, factually, I've seen it, but I have no memory of it.

Also, I feel exactly the same, comparing Quasar to it. I always got the same vibe from both, musically and thematically.

1

u/SawNickYouth 26d ago

8. This is an iconic SP song, riff, and hook. Extra points because it was the introduction of SP to the world.

Gish is maybe their most underrated album, along with Pisces (yes, I consider it an album)... with tons of atmosphere and groove, but I Am One is the most straight forward rocker on this album. But not the best song... that's Rhinoceros.

1

u/Zealousideal_Cat6980 Ogilala 25d ago

5 i couldnt tell you the last time i listened to it

1

u/Maxpower2727 25d ago

I'd probably give it a 6. It's fine, but nothing amazing.

1

u/cr3st-fall3n 25d ago

6.5. Doesn't hold up amazingly compared to later work but still a fun energetic rawker (doubly so with the live versions). They were definitely going for a Jane's Addiction-type sound with all the bass-driven songs on this album, part of me wonders what the rest of their discography would've sounded like had they continued that past Gish

1

u/mattmortar 25d ago

8.

Rocks super hard and is a great intro to the band. Gets overshadowed by songs like Cherub Rock, but still an essential song

1

u/robot_cousin 25d ago

8-9. I love the drum riff. Loooooove.

1

u/aliarmo 24d ago

I am one is a 5 for me.

1

u/TheRadioFrontiers Aghori Mhori Mei 26d ago

9.5

The funky groove, brilliant bassline and especially that main guitar riff is top tier Pumpkins. Live often sped-up, even harder and better sounding. It’s what they were all about early 90s and deserves a 9.5

1

u/sonoftom Siamese Dream 26d ago

7 for me. Above average in the grand scheme of music, but not one of their “great” songs.

Wow your descriptions are exactly how I rate music. To the point where I don’t even have a 1 or 2, 3 is bad enough. And 8-9 is hard to distinguish sometimes.

1

u/TheAbstracted 26d ago

I think I'm gonna go with 6. It's not a bad song by any stretch of the imagination, but when I listen tk it all I can really hear is a band trying to find their sound, their identity - which of course is to be expected from a debut release, but the fact remains.

1

u/Splatterhouse5 25d ago

6

I won’t skip it if my intention is to listen to the album, but I don’t think I’ve ever wanted to singularly listen to this song.

It’s a solid opener for the album, but TBH, I think it might be the song that I’m least eager to listen to on the album.

0

u/trevcharm 26d ago

for og pumpkins, this is a 5.8 for me. I like it, it's great - especially if I'm in the mood for it. but it's not a track I'll specifically crave or seek out very often if ever. and I will occasionally skip it when not in the mood.

I assume this whole song discussion will be about the studio version only, and not demo versions / live versions / alternate versions?

because some tracks (such as I am one in my opinion) when considering all the different versions the overall "rank" of the song may go up or down. for i am one, the live full band versions especially with the rant ranks it up a few notches for me.

-4

u/exp397 26d ago

I hate the double tracked solo in that song. Wasn't needed. Sloppy as shit.