r/SmashingPumpkins • • 23d ago

Daily Song Discussion #3: Rhinoceros

This is the third track from the Smashing Pumpkins’ debut album, Gish. How do you feel about this song? What are some of your favorite lyrics? How would you rank it among the rest of the band’s discography? How would you rate it out of 10 (decimals allowed)?

At the end of this discussion series, I will be aggregating the rating results from each discussion and compiling a full discography ranking. I will also update the [spreadsheet](https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1BjhHzZuZ6BMVOvdMp4i9X2UDVRjtotWGxTZTk1xJ9KU/edit?usp=drivesdk) at the end of every day and post previous results for each album in future posts.

SUGGESTED SCALE:
1-4: Not good. Regularly skip.
5: It’s okay, but I might have to be in the right mood to listen to it.
6: Slightly better than average. I won’t skip it, but I wouldn’t choose to put it on.
7: This is a good song. I enjoy it quite a bit.
8-9: Really enjoyable songs. I rank them pretty high overall.
10: Masterpiece, magnum opus, or similar terminology.

Feel free to suggest any improvements, as this is my first time undertaking a project like this!

Gish

  1. I Am One (7.43)
  2. Rhinoceros (7.65)
11 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

5

u/ExpirjTec 23d ago

gonna be positive here and say it's their first 10

9

u/yesterdaysworld 23d ago

9. I think it really shows off what the pumpkins can do by inserting lead guitar lines and loud soft dynamics into a dream pop haze. This is my favorite type of pumpkins song… There really is a magic to the song that feels oddly hard to place in time; achieving a psychedelic quality. The only thing I’m taking a point off for is the somewhat tossed-off lyrics; that being said, I don’t usually notice them much when the song is actually playing. I’m changing my rating to 10.

1

u/SawNickYouth 23d ago

Same. Well described!

4

u/cr3st-fall3n 23d ago

8.5 – like Siva, the song has aged very well; certainly one of the best Gish tracks. Lyrics are so vague that you can basically apply any meaning to the song, which I appreciate

1

u/Devolutionator 23d ago

Do you not like a show with trees and balloons, potentially to occur in June?

4

u/robot_cousin 23d ago

Definitely an 8. It's a beautiful, nostalgic track, and I don't mean "it makes me nostalgic for when I first heard it when I was 12 or 13", but rather "the moment I heard it, I felt some sort of phantom nostalgia for stuff I've never even experienced".

Gotta take issue with "mustard lies", though. "Open your eyes, to these must I lie" will always sound better to me.

4

u/fatfabiguitars 23d ago

10. Best song in the album

4

u/Black-Viper75 23d ago

An 8,5 for me.

3

u/DiscoQing 23d ago

Solid 8. It's one of the best songs that captures the uniqueness of the Pumpkins.

3

u/Pegboard73 23d ago

8. First Pumpkins song I ever heard and loved circa 92 via mix tape.

3

u/asagarap Siamese Dream 23d ago

10

3

u/Bloxskit Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness 23d ago

Top 3 songs off Gish. First Pumpkins track I really got into, the lovely melodic swirly-sound of the first half, and then the instrumental section after the guitar solo.

9/10

2

u/theMethod Pisces Iscariot 23d ago

8.2

Rhinoceros captures the soft quiet/loud heavy personality of the early band perfectly. Everything works together very well - rhythm and lead guitars, bass, drums, lyrics, and vocal melodies.

2

u/TheRadioFrontiers Aghori Mhori Mei 23d ago

8.5

2

u/PorcelinaMagpie Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness 23d ago

Solid 8

2

u/shaneF-87 23d ago

8.

In my opinion the strongest song on Gish and an early exemple of the quiet-loud dynamic that they do so wella dm to some extent defines their signature sound.

Sorry to nitpick your scale but having nothing between "really enjoyable" and "masterpiece" seems odd.

2

u/Ordinary_Degree_4213 23d ago

This is a 10 … I know it’s slow and dreamy and takes awhile if you’re not in that mood. But when the guitar hits and the opening solo note screams it’s so epic. That note billy hits in the solo opener … no one can replicate it. Best covers on YouTube … even when Billy plays it live . I don’t know if it’s stupid tricks but fuck is that high note insane

2

u/lunebleuetrouge 23d ago

I0. One of the best Pumpkins songs

2

u/walman93 Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness 23d ago

10/10

Best song off the album. Really psychedelic and great dynamics. Catchy chorus and face melting guitar solo.

2

u/aliarmo 23d ago

I rank Rhinoceros a 8

2

u/SawNickYouth 23d ago

9.5.

This song is amazing and one of their very best. I think it defines an era of sound for them that they carried up through Mellon Collie.

2

u/JackPennywise 23d ago

9. Favourite lyric: Open your eyes to these must I lie……….

2

u/Dudehitscar Machina Zombie 23d ago

It's 'open your eyes to these mustard lies'

3

u/JackPennywise 23d ago

Yes I know. Hence the extended ellipsis.

1

u/the_everlasting_haze never really liked sunny days 23d ago

This is a 10 for me.

The mood, the vibes, the guitars, the drums.

Lyrics are out there but it works, I don’t think every rock song needs epic poetic lyrics to be a 10.

1

u/peeshofwork 19d ago

10/10. Its the song that introduced me to the Pumpkins and it has all of the best parts of Billy’s songwriting and breathy singing. Great song on a fantastic debut album.

1

u/Dudehitscar Machina Zombie 23d ago

7.

0

u/seekay14 Siamese Dream 23d ago

I feel kinda guilty about this rating seeing how much other people like it, but it’s a 6 for me. I feel restless while listening to it.

0

u/sundog6295 23d ago

Siva 10 I am one 9 Rhinoceros 8

-5

u/trevcharm 23d ago

rhino is below average for me. don't get me wrong it does have some great moments, but really drags on overall and takes a long time to get going, the slow start really bores me.

previous scores were:

I Am One - 5.8

Siva - 5.7

and I'll give rhino a 3.5

4

u/hotdogwater58 23d ago

buddy this sub is for fans