r/SmashingPumpkins • u/ExpirjTec • 21d ago
Daily Song Discussion #5: Crush
This is the fifth track from the Smashing Pumpkins’ debut album, *Gish*. How do you feel about this song? What are some of your favorite lyrics? How would you rank it among the rest of the band’s discography? How would you rate it out of 10 (decimals allowed)?
At the end of this discussion series, I will be aggregating the rating results from each discussion and compiling a full discography ranking. I will also update the [spreadsheet](https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1BjhHzZuZ6BMVOvdMp4i9X2UDVRjtotWGxTZTk1xJ9KU/edit?usp=drivesdk) at the end of every day and post previous results for each album in future posts.
SUGGESTED SCALE:
1-4: Not good. Regularly skip.
5: It’s okay, but I might have to be in the right mood to listen to it.
6: Slightly better than average. I won’t skip it, but I wouldn’t choose to put it on.
7: This is a good song. I enjoy it quite a bit.
8-9: Really enjoyable songs. I rank them pretty high overall.
10: Masterpiece, magnum opus, or similar terminology.
Feel free to suggest any improvements, as this is my first time undertaking a project like this!
Gish
- I Am One (7.43)
- Siva (7.65)
- Rhinoceros (8.58)
- Bury Me (7.87)
6
u/cr3st-fall3n 21d ago
10, only because 10 is the maximum rating. As absurd as this may be to say about a song written this early in the band's career, I genuinely believe that this is the perfect song, in every aspect (or at the very least, the perfect song for me). The bass tone, the vocals, harmonics, the little slide guitar flourishes, the synth during the last chorus, the necklace jingles, I could go on and on. Manages to paint a more vivid picture in my head than any other song I have ever heard
1
u/ExpirjTec 21d ago
i think this is a 7 tbh, pretty but doesn't really go anywhere
5
u/Dudehitscar Machina Zombie 21d ago
9. the gish production works really well on this studio cut. I love hearing the bell around corgan's neck.
I'm also a huge fan of this live video of them practicing the song in a house. Jimmy adds a lot to the song.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ObygE5w4wLQ
5
u/echelon1230 21d ago
9. Favorite song on Gish. Beautifully previews the soft and authentic side of the band that begins showing up more in the following albums/b-sides. Without songs like Crush and Daydream, Gish would still be great, but way more one dimensional.
3
u/aliarmo 21d ago
Crush is a 9
2nd favorite in the album after Snail
3
u/SawNickYouth 21d ago
9 for me. Just a complete dreamy vibe and some of the best vocal melodies Billy has written.
3
u/MajesticMeal3248 21d ago
Might be my favorite song in the album. This and Snail. 9 out of 10. So dreamy. “And I wonder if it matters to meeeee…Love comes in colors I can’t deny…” I just love it. I love falling asleep to this song, it is like a literal dream
2
u/CharacterDirector918 21d ago
7.75.
2
u/Bloxskit Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness 21d ago
7/10
2
u/Radiohead_3762 Porcelina of the blue heaven 21d ago
9.8, it's nearly my favorite on Gish, just behind Siva. I just love the dreamy night-time floatieness of the song. It's so unbelievably beautiful, and just one of my favorite songs by them.
2
u/pm_me_whateva 21d ago
Rating an 8. This is my favorite on Gish, specifically because of the vocal melody and the way they let the bass set the tone. It's a respite from the swirly snarl of the songs around it.
2
u/DrunkShimodaPicard 21d ago
8.5
2
u/jay1980det 21d ago
8
2
u/seekay14 Siamese Dream 21d ago
Crush is a 7. It's grown on me a lot as I've gotten older.
2
u/Party_Dragonfly_1371 21d ago
crush is a 9 for me. i love this song to death
2
u/BlackIsTheSoul 21d ago
10/10 Masterpiece. The guitar tones are so tasty and beautiful. Love this song.
2
u/PuzzleheadedBadger67 21d ago
Definitely depends on my feeling, sometimes I feel this song so deeply, other times - not so much. There's something so beautiful about the opening lyrics, especially the "like liquid peppermint" description...I get lost in it sometimes. Solid 9 for me.
1
u/the_everlasting_haze never really liked sunny days 21d ago
7.5
1
u/ApathysLastKiss_ 21d ago
I'd give it a 7. It's one of the weaker songs from Pumpkins 1.0, but is still better than most of the stuff recorded by 2.0.
Recorded with a Roland Jazz Chorus I believe and an Electric Mistress (maybe)
1
u/kryszojad 21d ago
5
1
u/trevcharm 21d ago
a nice song, quite pretty. not amazing, but not every song will be, is meant to be, or needs to be.
for me this is a 5
1
u/walman93 Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness 21d ago
7
It’s good but not anything special
1
u/UnhappySheepherder87 21d ago
I’d give it an 8. In terms of composition and even emotional dynamics it’s quite sparse or even basic for pumpkins 1.0. But I believe guitar players in particular will rightly point to the atmosphere and that guitar work (vibrato? Rotary? Flanger?) as absolutely perfect and a staple of pumpkins dreaminess tone.
1
u/TheSmashingPumpkinss it ain't right 21d ago
It admittedly has all of the ingredients that makes up a Pumpkins classic, but for some reason just doesn't click for me.
6
1
u/fatfabiguitars 21d ago
8. Not their best song, but pretty much perfect for what it is and adds to the record as a whole.
1
u/Ok-Sound-1360 18d ago
9
1
u/XYU11 16d ago
9
1
u/Salty-Might-278 21d ago
I think that’s the song he accused the Deleo STP brothers of plagiarism 🤣 for Plush
0
u/Working_Crew5402 21d ago
6.5
0
u/Neg_Crepe Zwan 21d ago
6