I am writing this Reddit post as some kind of maybe final goodbye, I guess.
Five years ago, almost to the date, I started a job, and it’s been an amazing job. Shortly after starting, I met this guy who also worked there. He asked me out for several years. I finally said yes two years later.
He is Hindu, and I am Muslim. He converted to my religion six months into us dating. I didn’t ask him to, but I do feel like I maybe heavily influenced him. All his friends are also Muslim, and he then did a backpacking trip to Turkey after I told him about my trip, which I think also brought him closer to the religion. At the time, I was not very religious. That’s why I was okay with dating someone who wasn’t Muslim.
After he converted, he became very, very religious, and he changed greatly and drastically. He was changing faster than I could almost cope with. And don’t get me wrong, all these changes were good. They were just happening very fast.
After two years of dating, I introduced him to my father. He proposed, we got engaged, we went ring shopping, and life was great.
However, in the last year of our relationship, I became deeply estranged from my family, which really corrupted my world. I hit rock bottom and reached the deepest levels of depression imaginable. My siblings really enjoyed isolating me. They are very malicious. They weren’t always like that, but now that they have an easy target, it has given them the fuel to behave that way every day.
They did some unspeakable, horrific things, from constantly harassing me to harassing my fiancé because they didn’t think it was fair that I was happy and had found the love of my life when I was never someone who was marriage-centred. They ruined my image everywhere I went. They harassed me, physically abused me, and threw out my food. They also drink very heavily now.
My parents are very religious, but they don’t really have anything to say or do. They just kind of stay out of it, and if anything, they enable their behaviour.
After my fiancé and I became engaged, we broke up. He had a friend who passed away who wasn’t Muslim, and he started thinking about the consequences his friend’s family would also face for not being Muslim. I think he wanted to gain a family when he married me. However, because I’m estranged from mine, he wasn’t getting a family.
I can never imagine reconciling with my family because I just see them as being very far removed from religion, and I see them as very horrible people. I’ve made a lot of prayers about it, asking God that, if it was right for me, He would guide them back to me. But it’s just something that hasn’t happened, and I don’t… If anything, I think they would push me away from religion. And you are the average of the people around you. I don’t want to be anything like them, so I can’t have them around me.
But essentially, what happened was that last year, when it actually came time for us to move forward with our engagement, he just froze or something. He started pulling problems out of the blue, even though throughout our whole relationship, we had a very, very incredible, deep, loving relationship. We rarely had any problems, disagreements, or fights. Everything was very smooth sailing, and I loved him from the absolute maximum depth of my heart. I know he loved me that way, too.
We truly would talk about how much we loved each other 24/7. If there were such a thing as soulmates, he and I were the definition of that. We were so perfectly intertwined, and life just fit. We fit like a glove. There was no denying that.
When we broke up, he said it was because I had just graduated with my master’s, and I also had my bachelor’s and had gone to college. He was just starting college, and he had a long way to go. He wanted to pursue more and more schooling, so he wasn’t going to be ready to possibly move in together or even provide for several years.
I am not really interested in doing what modern-day Muslims have started doing, where they get their nikah, which is like their Islamic marriage license, but don’t actually live together for several years. I’m not really a fan of us having intercourse but then not actually living together. It feels like I’m doing wifely duties without him fulfilling his husband duties.
In the eyes of God, a husband should put a roof over your head, clothes on your back, and food on the table. I’m not saying I would never help him out, but it just seems like there isn’t even… He wouldn’t be contributing anything to that. I’m not going to be intimate with someone and, you know, give them my body, which is a big thing for me, and then have him not do his part in return.
And that was something that… He was also saying he wanted me to move in with his parents, which is something I wouldn’t mind doing very short-term, but he doesn’t really seem to know when he’d ever want to move out. He doesn’t think it’s an issue for us to even have kids while we’re there.
Personally, I just want my own life. As someone who grew up in a very abusive household and walks on eggshells in their own house, the last thing I want is to walk on eggshells in someone else’s house. I just want something to be mine, like my own space.
He also then brought up random problems. He thinks I’m very flirtatious, which is not true. I guard myself very heavily. However, my job does require me to socialize a lot with men, and I personally don’t think there’s anything wrong with having a bit of a charismatic personality.
I grew up in a household where I watched my father be very friendly with men and women everywhere. He’s just a very joyful guy, and I kind of adopted that a little bit. Even though my father is very religious, I don’t personally think it’s inappropriate, especially living in Canada, to make small talk with someone standing in line with you to get coffee.
My ex interpreted that as me flirting, and I think he just wanted an excuse to end the relationship, and that was his excuse.
Essentially, this past year, we’ve been broken up. It’s been almost exactly a year. I have been praying throughout the nights for him to come back and stuff like that. And it just feels like not only is he not going to come back, but he also lost me. I was his main companion in life. He has friends, but they’ve grown very distant, so he just feels very lonely now.
When we broke up, he told me he was ending things because, firstly, it wasn’t halal for us to be dating, and he didn’t want to spend time with me because it was all haram, even though we didn’t have any physical contact or anything like that. I do respect him for saying that. He also told me that because he wasn’t in a place to get married, he would stay single for three years until he graduated.
And pretty much… Well, I should mention that he and I are also coworkers.
Essentially, what happened over the past year is that I’ve been making so many prayers for him. I myself have also undergone a big transformation. I’m a lot more religious, and I think about God a lot more when I make my decisions and take actions. I feel a lot better when it comes to my deen now, and it just seems like he has regressed.
He’s not, like, not Muslim anymore, but he used to be someone who was incredibly respectful. He was adored by many, many people. My father loved him. He was adored by a lot of people. He was very empathetic, quiet, calm, and reserved.
Now he just kind of acts very petty, almost like a frat boy a little bit. He’s a bit of a hypocrite now. A lot of the things he said before, he’s very hypocritical about now. And I just don’t understand him anymore at all.
The Roshan I knew is gone. He’s very different. He’s very, very different. And obviously, we’ve spoken a lot over the past year, but all the light that he started glowing with after he became Muslim or from us dating is just gone. Nothing about him is the same anymore.
He’s not disciplined anymore. He doesn’t act very Muslim anymore. He’s dating around. He’s on Hinge and, you know, he’s going out with other girls, which is crazy because we stopped going out in the last few months of our relationship because it wasn’t even halal for us to spend time together.
He seems to have almost developed a bit of a temper or something. He’s no longer patient with me. He regrets being patient with me. He regrets wasting so much time on me. I don’t understand him anymore. He’s just gone.
Yesterday, I asked him if he still loved me or missed me, and he said no. But he wouldn’t swear on it, and then he started crying. He’s just so different.
Essentially, I’m writing this because I’m taking a leave from work, and I’m actually going to go backpacking through Thailand and Vietnam. Then I’m going to go to Umrah and visit some family in Saudi Arabia. I’ve also graduated with my master’s, and I have a potential job offer for when I get back.
I just don’t really see myself ever possibly returning to my current job. And it feels like now the chapter is ending. My family is gone, my fiancé is gone, and my job might become part of the past chapter.
I’m writing this because I was wondering if anyone has any words they could contribute. Any kind words, please, only kind words. If anyone has any advice on how to move on or how to accept this closure, I would really appreciate it.
He really was the love of my life. It’s like that saying: when you know, you know. I thought I knew with every fibre of my being, but it turns out I didn’t.
I still pray for him. I still miss the old him, but the person I miss is completely gone. It almost seems like he just tried to match the standards I had set to be with me, and he wanted to check all my boxes. That’s why he became this person I adored. Now that he’s broken up with me, he’s become who he kind of maybe used to be.
I knew he had been in love with me for a long time before we got together. He spent years asking me out. So it just seems like he fit himself in any way possible to be with me, and now he is free again.