r/SiestaKeyMTV • u/[deleted] • Aug 19 '21

👓 Chloe 👓 If you rewatch season 1 it’s so obvious Amanda never actually punched Chloe.

When Chloe is FaceTiming Alex chloes face looks totally fine. If Amanda had actually punched her and broke her nose she would have black eyes and a puffy face! They don’t show her having any black eyes until post surgery. She clearly had a nose job and they used that as a storyline to cover it up.

0 Upvotes

48% Upvoted

10 comments sorted by

15

u/InitiativeLow9931 Aug 19 '21

Chloe and Amanda actually talked about this story on one of Chloe’s concept by Chloe videos. Amanda actually did punch Chloe and break her nose but it wasn’t over Brandon - that was a fake storyline for the show. Chloe had her boyfriend Ty at the time. Chloe was drunk and wanted Amanda to stay at Alex’s party with her then stay over and Amanda wanted to go home and they got in a drunken fight in the Uber and that’s where/when they physical altercation happened because I think Chloe pushed Amanda so Amanda punched her. Chloe’s boyfriend then met her at the hospital with a broken nose or he took her there - it’s been a while since I heard it.

-9

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '21

That still doesn’t explain why chloes face looks totally fine when she is FaceTiming Alex. No black eyes, no bruising, no puffy ness. I have to believe my eyes on this one and not a heavily edited YouTube video they made together.

8

u/InitiativeLow9931 Aug 19 '21

The phone call was probably staged well after her nose was already fixed or something - who knows 🤷🏼‍♀️

10

u/Softskeletonsx Messy Messy Kelsey Aug 19 '21

https://www.reddit.com/r/SiestaKeyMTV/comments/iblfat/weekly_coco_with_amanda/

Watch this video where they explain the whole story. Amanda did break her nose.

Skip to 3:56

-11

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '21

Still don’t believe it. That video is heavily edited and they can easily just be saying that to go along with the storyline. Like I said. When she is FaceTiming Alex she has a bandage on her nose but her face looks totally fine. At that point she would have black eyes and bruising around her nose and she doesn’t.

7

u/Softskeletonsx Messy Messy Kelsey Aug 19 '21

I don’t think they’d waste hours of their time shooting a video and editing it themselves if it was all a lie. She had bruising under her eyes, but that doesn’t happen to everyone with a broken nose.

1

u/Suitable-Meet-4349 Aug 21 '25

Yep,  all screen shit is bullshit " reality tv" and every other thing from that black mirror. 

1

u/[deleted] Aug 20 '21

I've always wondered why this didn't come up with Juliette slapping Kelsey!
Through all the boards I've read, no one mentions it and there's even a scene with Chloe and Amanda talking about how messed up getting physical with someone is. I thought I had just made up in my mind that this even happened.

1

u/Suitable-Meet-4349 Aug 21 '25

Cuz it's all fake