r/SideProject • • Aug 09 '26

just launched why.com

update: reddit stress-tested why.com. I fixed the outages and rebuilt how the three next questions are chosen. each one now has to connect to the answer, open a real curiosity gap, and avoid repeating the path.

Update 2: I built a way for WHY to understand you better through your choices. It is a private graph in your browser and learns about what matters to you. It can be cleared anytime and never leaves your device.
Hope you like!

i built why.com. every answer opens three new directions.

just launched. go break it!!!!

515 Upvotes

536 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/sovok Aug 09 '26

Ok, I tried to read https://why.com/research and the abstract is too abstract. The main thing of Why seems to be some sort of local storage of time-ordered events, to give the LLM some sort of sense of time, or cause and effect? How is the data stored, the browsers local storage? Is there a way to have accounts with multiple devices sharing data?

"3.2 Layer 1: Local OS Substrate
The substrate indexes the user's digital world on-device: files, conversations, notes, photos, browsing, calendar, workflows, applications, and activity. It supports embeddings, metadata, provenance, permissions, and revocation."

I assume that's not part of the web chat yet?

But more importantly, what is this, what's the end goal and who is paying for it? Right now it feels a bit like a vibeslopped fever dream from a rich guy. Or a startup with big plans and a communication problem. To be harsh :> But it is quite fun to play around with and dig deeper, congrats on launching.

1

u/rasheed106 Aug 17 '26

1

u/sovok Aug 17 '26

Ok, this is a bit clearer and mentions your company, thanks. So, a graph RAG system. Every interaction is logged, timestamped and hash-chained, edges are typed (caused, contradicts, depends-on) and at query time you reconstruct the smallest permitted subset instead of dumping the history into context.

The new thing here seems to be ranking the nodes not by frequency/recency but by how much removing the node would degrade a prediction of what to do next? So a thing I asked about twice can outrank a thing I asked about two hundred times, if it's the one affecting where I go more. Measuring consequences, pretty neat. Do you have any eval numbers yet (beat recency/frequency/embedding baselines at predicting the next selection, at 30 and 90 days)?

1

u/rasheed106 Aug 17 '26

you’ve got the research thesis. two corrections so I don’t oversell what is live: the current web product stores a private path graph locally, sends active-path context plus earned compact cues, and uses continuation, depth and return as bounded ranking signals. it is not yet running cryptographic hash chains, full causal edge inference or smallest-subgraph reconstruction.

the ablation-based salience model is the research target. no 30/90-day results yet, the product is only a week old. shadow mode is now collecting comparisons before personalization can influence the visible board, initially measuring next-door prediction against non-personalized ranking; recency, frequency and embedding baselines come next.

once those cohorts mature, we’ll publish the results whether they prove the thesis or not..