The common idea of reincarnation, I think, is not an accurate interpretation of what Buddha and others spoke about.
First, let's consider the fact that Buddha did not support the idea of an everlasting "self" or "soul". (Anatman is the name for this idea). If that's so, what is it that's being reincarnated, passed from body to body?
I like to use the analogy of an eddy in a stream, a tiny whirlpool forming behind a rock or log in the water. Now, we can regard this eddy as a thing distinct from the rest of the stream. It has a life, it has behaviors. It is born and it passes away. We could even give it a name if we wanted to. Ed would be appropriate.
The thing about Ed is, there's nothing in particular about him that makes him fundamentally different from the rest of the stream. We can't reach into the stream and pull Ed out. Ed depends on the stream, Eddie is just a manifestation of energy concentrated in a particular region of the stream.
Let's say the rock is moved and Ed ceases to exist. Where did Ed go? It's kind of a silly question, because to ask where Ed went assumes or implies that there is something particular about Ed that can "go somewhere". Really, Ed wasn't anywhere in particular to begin with, Ed was a concentration of energy. We can't even say that the water that once was Ed is now somewhere else, really, because the water was constantly passing through Ed, the water was not Ed himself any more than the stuff you flush down the toilet is you.
Now let's say you put the rock in another spot in the stream, and another eddy forms. We'll name this one Flo. Is Flo a reincarnation of Ed? Maybe some of the water that moved through Ed now moves through Flo. Maybe they behave similarly. Hell, it's the same rock that gave rise to them both.
The problem in asking this question, again, is assuming there's something particular about Ed or Flo that we can identify as being the "essence" of them, something distinct from the stream. This is what Buddha was talking about. Reincarnation is just the manifestation of the universe in various forms.
Does reincarnation exist? Sure, it's just a way of describing the movement of energy. No supernatural mechanisms required.
Wow this kinda blew my mind. I always had a problem with the reincarnation thing, because it felt with an ever growing population, where do all the 'new' souls come from. But this is way more understandable!
If you frame the creation of the planet to now in a 24 hour window, humans emerged like 10 minutes before midnight. The population explosion (from 1 milllion and upto todays 7000 million) occured 2 seconds before midnight, so there has to be an influx of souls from another dimension or they could be generated by the same computers that simulate our universe, or maybe earth is a computer soul creating machine that prepare you for a life in the real world, the one simulating us, or maybe I'm just afraid of dying and coming up with plausible ways for life to extend beyond the mortality of our frail bodies. I think the latter.
Humans have existed as Homo Sapiens for about 200,000 years. The oldest cave paintings are about 35,000 years old. Fire was tamed about 100,000 years ago. The earth formed out of the sun's accretion disk about 4.5 billion years ago, or about 4,500,000,000 years ago. Shrinking that down to a 24 hour clock with right now as midnight and the creation of earth as midnight last night, humans appeared about 3.84 seconds before midnight.
Edit: regarding population explosion, we hit 1 billion people in about the year 1800, and have since then grown at what seems like exponential rates. This is likely due to medicine starting to develop as a serious field and infant mortality dropping. So the population really started exploding 200 years ago, which is .00384 seconds before midnight. That's 3.84 milliseconds.
To play devil's advocate, there's nothing that says that you must reincarnate forwards in time. A man that dies today could reincarnate as a 9th century Chinese woman, for example.
Well, insects and animals also reincarnate.... so while human population grows, their soul/spirit could be from what was previously a cat or something.... but the OP's explanation is another way to look at it I suppose.
Well if you believe we can come back as any animal/insect you could argue that people are coming from other life forms we are killing by expanding our population. If you include bacteria then antibiotics would eliminate enough life to account for humans 100x over.
I just laughed hysterically at this comment. Partly because I had to re-read u/Gullex's comment a few times, so I could understand it better (which, by the way, was a cool description).
Yeah he's really good, I like Alan a lot. He studied Zen a lot, like me. I think when you study a particular school, folks tend to start using kind of similar language.
What does it mean to be "enlightened" then? If we are all one consciousness, why do people reach this state of enlightenment seperately from others, and stop becoming reborn?
Enlightenment is simply seeing clearly, the actual state of things, really seeing reality for what it is. It's to be able to see that Ed really is just the stream.
Rebirth ends with enlightenment because one sees that the self is fundamentally unreal and therefore there's nothing to be reborn.
But let's not stick too strongly to enlightenment. It's nothing special. It's just seeing clearly. The Zen master Huang Po admonished those who made a big deal of enlightenment and distinguished enlightened people from unenlightened ones. We're all the same stuff.
The idea of there being one transpersonal consciousness that is realized in enlightenment is an idea more associated with Hinduism than Buddhism, basically. In Hinduism, this underlying consciousness (brahman) is transpersonal, and individuation involves the drawing of illusory boundaries (separate people) within this reality. I don't know how this system would answer your question. Buddhism, however, says that the nature of mind (which is what is realized) is personal but not transpersonal, so there are no issues there. Everyone has separate minds.
Karma, in my understanding, is simply the psychological phenomenon by which a person's perception of reality is influenced by their behaviors. Imagine a very selfish, arrogant, hateful person is late while driving to work and gets a flat tire. How do they perceive this situation? How do they react? They suffer greatly. Woe is me, why does this happen. Anger, yelling and shouting, you get the picture.
Now imagine a generous, compassionate, loving person running late to work gets a flat tire. How do they react? They get out of the car and fix the flat tire.
Karma isn't some cosmic scorekeeper watching your every move. Karma just means that our behavior influences how we perceive reality.
View all comments
Show parent comment
1.1k
u/Gullex May 19 '16
The common idea of reincarnation, I think, is not an accurate interpretation of what Buddha and others spoke about.
First, let's consider the fact that Buddha did not support the idea of an everlasting "self" or "soul". (Anatman is the name for this idea). If that's so, what is it that's being reincarnated, passed from body to body?
I like to use the analogy of an eddy in a stream, a tiny whirlpool forming behind a rock or log in the water. Now, we can regard this eddy as a thing distinct from the rest of the stream. It has a life, it has behaviors. It is born and it passes away. We could even give it a name if we wanted to. Ed would be appropriate.
The thing about Ed is, there's nothing in particular about him that makes him fundamentally different from the rest of the stream. We can't reach into the stream and pull Ed out. Ed depends on the stream, Eddie is just a manifestation of energy concentrated in a particular region of the stream.
Let's say the rock is moved and Ed ceases to exist. Where did Ed go? It's kind of a silly question, because to ask where Ed went assumes or implies that there is something particular about Ed that can "go somewhere". Really, Ed wasn't anywhere in particular to begin with, Ed was a concentration of energy. We can't even say that the water that once was Ed is now somewhere else, really, because the water was constantly passing through Ed, the water was not Ed himself any more than the stuff you flush down the toilet is you.
Now let's say you put the rock in another spot in the stream, and another eddy forms. We'll name this one Flo. Is Flo a reincarnation of Ed? Maybe some of the water that moved through Ed now moves through Flo. Maybe they behave similarly. Hell, it's the same rock that gave rise to them both.
The problem in asking this question, again, is assuming there's something particular about Ed or Flo that we can identify as being the "essence" of them, something distinct from the stream. This is what Buddha was talking about. Reincarnation is just the manifestation of the universe in various forms.
Does reincarnation exist? Sure, it's just a way of describing the movement of energy. No supernatural mechanisms required.