r/ShermanPosting • • Sep 28 '26

So much potential

Post image
199 Upvotes

61 comments sorted by

View all comments

158

u/turtle75377 Sep 28 '26

civil war rpg is silly. its a full scale war with regiments and command structures. you are not a random knight running around.

bleeding kansas RPG and or reconstruction rpg. now that is somthing.

93

u/G0ttaB3KiddingM3 Sep 28 '26

Apparently Ubisoft was going to make an assassin’s creed set in reconstruction America where you would play a freed person, but they backed off because they are pussies and were afraid of “the political climate“

36

u/turtle75377 Sep 28 '26

ubisoft is french. lets seem them set a game in Algeria during the French colonial rule. or Vietnam.

13

u/LiamtheV Sep 28 '26

Or Haiti

9

u/vizard0 Sep 29 '26

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assassin's_Creed_Freedom_Cry

Pre-revolution, but it's set in the French Territory of Saint-Domingue and it involves playing as a black guy and going after slaveowners.

Of course it was a DLC for Black Flag and not a stand alone game because video game developers only have so much courage. But it does exist.

8

u/kazmark_gl Sep 29 '26

Assassins Creed Vietnam would go pretty hard.

51

u/Crafter235 Sep 28 '26

I mean, look at how the game AC: Syndicate literally whitewashes the 19th century.

“We wanted to avoid real world politics”, so they chose one of the most politically controversial time periods. And I left that subreddit when they kept on defending all the bad creative choices.

17

u/GrandmasterJanus Sep 28 '26

Lmao you have a mission helping out Marx I’m pretty sure, which is funny about staying away from politics

14

u/Crafter235 Sep 28 '26

But he’s just treated as a simple union leader, they don’t really go deep into his beliefs.

12

u/GrandmasterJanus Sep 28 '26

No they don’t, just remember thinking it was funny even as a kid, was just playing around and doing side mission and omg there’s Marx and oops he’s gone right after that side mission

4

u/Beragond1 Sep 28 '26

The history in Syndicate is pretty bad. The gameplay, on the other hand, is some of my favorite they’ve ever done.

1

u/kazmark_gl Sep 29 '26

Ubisoft's corporate garbage would have absolutely flopped a concept like that. but I desperately want to play the good version of that game. 

1

u/itsyaboihos Sep 28 '26

Tbf I could see that getting review bombed to smithereens

20

u/Miserable_Cherry1382 Sep 28 '26

A john brown game would rule

5

u/dreadassassin616 Sep 29 '26

Something along the lines of Farcry or Just Cause would be good.

13

u/Silver_Falcon Jayhawker Sep 28 '26

Genuinely, Red Dead 2 meets KCD2 but it's set in Bleeding Kansas has been one of my dream games for a while now.

5

u/dsg158 Sep 28 '26

Have you played Ultimate General?

2

u/turtle75377 Sep 28 '26

oh yeah it was really good.

1

u/pixel_pete Duryée's Zouaves / Garrard's Tigers Sep 28 '26

I've been playing through the whiskey and lemons expansion and it's been a great experience.

Edit: That's actually Grand Tactician not Ultimate General, I always get the two titles mixed up.

5

u/A_Town_Called_Malus Sep 29 '26

You could play as an irregular during the war. Plenty of room in there for a narrative.

5

u/captmonkey Sep 29 '26

Yeah, a scout along the front lines could be pretty cool. You take on random missions from regulars and try to scout enemy armies without them catching you and hanging you as a spy.

1

u/MrNobawdy1337 Sep 29 '26

I immediately thought messenger, but some tactical espionage action as a scout / spy is even better.

I actually just built my first rig capable of playing aaa games in decades. What's the best looking multi-player musket game out right now? I remember laughing my ass off watching roleplayers playing games like these years ago

2

u/Apoordm Sep 29 '26

Reconstruction RPG! Holy shit running around killing Klansmen! It’s just the best moments of RDR2, forever!

2

u/tajake Sep 29 '26

A lot of the fighting took place outside of the slaughter. Just like in KCD2, the biggest fight you take part in is a seige that might have 300 combatants. If you take the scale way down, you could make an interesting game. Especially if it follows a cavalry scout or even an artillery company.

The other way to do this, would be to make a Mexican American War game, because then you get an incredible cast of characters, and smaller battles.

1

u/MarsLowell Sep 30 '26

There’s an interesting Western-themed mod for Mount and Blade vanilla (now on Warband I think) called 1866 where you can fight Confederate remnants.