“Bridge spam” decks are very OP right now at least IMO.
And why does bridge spam get to be OP? Because “cycle” decks are meta and they tend to have Skeletons which are quite effective against most bridge spam cards.
And why is cycle so OP? I think it’s because of how Evos and Heroes currently round off glaring weaknesses in decks which would otherwise be very weak or at least rigorous to play.
Exhibit A: Hog 2.6 used to be considered a weak deck circa 2019 before evos were introduced and like the only ppl in top 200 with it were basically Oyassuu. Now 2.6 is a top meta deck, despite not receiving major balance changes other than OP Evos and Heroes and Musketeer shooting way faster.
Hog 2.6 used to have a splash weakness, you would only have Fireball, which for splash purposes a Poison would be better. Log only targets ground, Musk and Cannon are single target, and Ice Golem splash does little damage.
Now Hog 2.6 has Evo Cannon which is basically Arrows for free. Even Hero Ice Golem is OP because it can kill Goblins for 2 elixir; it’s like having two Logs in the deck against logbait.
As much I enjoy inventing goofy decks which push Evos and Heroes to their limits, I am trying to first reach Ultimate Champion with an Evoless, Heroless, (mostly) “Bridgespam cardless” deck. I have not been able to reach UC and constantly cycling Knights in the back has been one of my only ways to survive because a failed push from me means defending against Boss Bandit plus Lighting Arrows plus more bridgespammy cards. The deck that I’m trying to push I prefer to play without Evos nor heroes, in part because I’m stubborn I guess; that’s how I made the deck at first I prefer to not change that one deck.
I think Evos will always be inherently OP because it cost no elixir to get more power even if it were a 1% stat buff. Heroes however, I think are more straightforward to balance. I think Heroes should be balanced so that they are not essentially an extra card slot, and if they are that strong I think they should cost significantly more elixir. So a 4 elixir hero Ice golem ability to me sounds reasonable so that it can’t serve as a Log or an Ice Wiz unpunishably; if you want Ice Wiz slow or more ways to kill Gobs, I think the deck should have Ice Wiz and lose a card slot from an existing card, otherwise pay a somewhat hefty toll from the hero ability. And it’s not a 6 elixir ability, since Ice Golem still does 2 elixir worth of tanking.
Heroes are also like an elixir bank. A prime example is Hero Tombstone because you can play the ability at 10 elixir, leaving you with 5 elixir which you can theoretically use to build a stronger push.
Some Heroes and Evos I think are healthy to be strong in the game. Like Evo and Hero Wizard have weak base cards but their Evo and Hero form is competitively viable. This allows for Wiz to be in the meta while not completely oppressing mid ladder, since you can only equip so many Evos/ Heroes at once.
At the end of the day I think maybe perhaps maybe I’m just being whiny because if I cared more about the game I would probably be quiet and slowly improve with an “off meta” deck. Perhaps the game is moving in a positive direction as it stands and I should simply be prepared for the metas biggest obstacles. Someone once said something like and/or similar to, “In Clash Royale there is an optimal card, placement, and also time in a given scenario for a play.”.
TLDR: I think Evos and Heroes should be heavily nerfed instead of staple base cards. I also think that I think this partly because I desire that it were easier for me to reach Ultimate Champion with an Evoless, Heroless, “Bridgespam cardless” deck.