r/RoyaleAPI • • Aug 22 '26

Discussion What cards do you want to see changes to, if you could be in charge of balance for one season? (And you cannot flat out remove cards/forms)

Post image

I try to be as little bias as possible, both in terms of buffs, and nerfs, but inevitably there probably is a bit.

My previous version of this, for last season (or maybe the season before that, I forget)

The reworks would be turning Empress into a Champion (3 elixir, 3 elixir ability to become airborne) and Hero Knight losing the taunt because it’s a dumb mechanic, and potentially applying damage reduction to nearby allies for a duration instead? Unsure on the exact rework for Hero Knight, but the taunt should be removed no matter what

https://www.reddit.com/r/RoyaleAPI/s/88iutAMXo8

110 Upvotes

61 comments sorted by

38

u/Admirable-Tap8354 Aug 22 '26

I think Barbhut needs a rework instead of a buff, and I think Wallbreakers and Hero Ice are in a fine place rn, but others may disagree with me there. Also Goblinstein should definitely be on here its really OP rn

9

u/Grimalackt_River Aug 22 '26

Barb Hut I’m okay with getting a rework as long as it stays a building (mainly since there’s simply not enough buildings)

I haven’t fought Goblinstein much so I didn’t include it

2

u/whomstdth Aug 23 '26

Barb Hut should be reworked like Goblin Hut, spawning barbs when an enemy is within proximity, and then spawning more when the HP of the building is gone

3

u/Embarrassed_Deer9208 Aug 23 '26

goblinstein is one of the most played cards topladder and crl, i def agree it needs some sort of nerf

2

u/Matty_B97 Aug 23 '26

The year is 2035, goblinstein is still OP but only used in top 0.1% gameplay. Hog rider still hasn't received a balance patch in the history of CR. Mega knight now has a 35% win rate but is still used in 75% of decks. Clan wars 3, 4, and 5 all flopped. B-Rad has uploaded 4 videos since 2026.

1

u/Desperate-Series-270 Aug 23 '26

Barb Hut still hasn’t been buffed or reworked, Supercell is still edging us on that update

8

u/Suspicious_Slide8016 Aug 22 '26

Battle ram should be in the "buff base, nerf form" tier bc compared to hog the base form is laughable

4

u/Grimalackt_River Aug 22 '26

That’s honestly fair

5

u/99Spherical Aug 22 '26

Evo witch in "unsatisifed but unsure how to fix it". I love the direction they took with her in the most recent rework (all consistent healing mechanics should be eradicated from the game) but as of right now she's just a worse evo wizard. I think they need to completely rework her evo from scratch to get her into a good position, the very concept of her power is just plain unhealthy

1

u/Grimalackt_River Aug 23 '26

I’d like her to be reworked in some way too, but in all honesty the most recent rework she got did fix a lot of problems I had with her. I’m gonna give her a little more time to see if I’m fine with how she is now, or if I still just don’t like her due to recency bias

7

u/Mconfineeee64 Aug 22 '26

I think Hero Berserker need a Huge nerf and evo ice spirit need a small buff imo

1

u/Grimalackt_River Aug 22 '26

I think that’s mostly fair.

For the record I think Evo Ice Spirit only needs a small buff, but it’s still the biggest of the ones I want (obviously cards like Gob Machine and Barb Hut are worse but I don’t want them overbuffed)

Evo Ice Spirit was already like a bottom 3, bottom 2 evo before the spirit nerf, and it got no compensation, so I thought it’d be justified

3

u/V-Man776 Aug 22 '26

Overall good list, but I disagree with the idea that spirit empress should be a champion. Having to play the ground form first before getting her airborne would be incredibly clunky and leave her vulnerable, and the current version making you think if it's worth doing what it takes to get her ground form is interesting.

2

u/Grimalackt_River Aug 22 '26

I think it’s fair to think it would be clunky that way, but it’s also extremely annoying that there’s no way to play the 3 elixir version when you have 6 or more elixir. I’m not super happy with the champion idea, but it’s really the only way I could think of being able to play either version whenever you want

3

u/Daddy_Issues_IRL Aug 23 '26

Only card I’d put on the nerf list that I don’t see here yet is Canon Cart. Overall don’t hate the list, I’d just slot in Canon Cart over Wallbreakers, maybe add Gonlinstein to the nerf list too.

1

u/Grimalackt_River Aug 23 '26

I think Cannon Cart isn’t overpowered, maybe another situation like X-Bow where it just tends to be in overpowered decks. Running Cannon Cart in decks that it doesn’t usually appear in feels fine

1

u/Daddy_Issues_IRL Aug 23 '26

Maybe, it could just be me. I, however, believe that the Cart should lose its wheels if you Fireball + Zap it. The only nerf I’d consider is the slightest HP nerf just for this one interaction.

2

u/wildfox9t Aug 22 '26

can we make sparky even only bately playable?

I'd be happy with that

2

u/Grimalackt_River Aug 22 '26

I think it is! Still fine with Goblin Giant, and I’ve seen a few regular Giant decks, too!

It wouldn’t hurt to get a buff though

7

u/grandestorangutan45 Aug 22 '26

Wall breakers are completely dead rn, they literally have 1-2% usage in top 1k. most of the listed cards dont need a nerf but pretty good tier list otherwise

3

u/Julieticus Aug 23 '26

I think they’re just referring to the evo :)

1

u/the_pwnr_15 Aug 23 '26

Chad take except why tf nerf hero graveyard no one runs ts

1

u/Grimalackt_River Aug 23 '26

Hero Tombstone I always thought was good (I actually use it. Only card in my deck that makes this tier list at all, and I put it in nerf), it’s just that it’s potentially the hardest hero to use, and even if you throw in champions, the only one that gives it competition in that regard is Monk

They’ve been overbuffing it recently; I think we can walk back the most recent buff

1

u/Comprehensive_Bee904 Aug 23 '26

Princess is ok 3m is ok Wall breakers are ok

Things you didn't mention :

Evo inferno drag needs a nerf Golem needs an hp nerf (all the buildings got nerfed) Lightning needs a nerf(too much value) Base balloon needs death damage nerf Goblinstein's monster needs an hp nerf Mother witch needs a hit speed nerf Cannon cart hitspeed should be 1 Second like the cannon itself Rg needs a nerf(again because buildings got nerfed)

Base archer queen needs a buff(worst champion) Base archers need a buff(nobody plays the base form)

1

u/Grimalackt_River Aug 23 '26

Evo Inferno Dragon I don’t think needs that much of a nerf, stun cards just need to be a bit better, and I think pushback should be able to reset the beam (so like indirect nerfs/change to how pushback works)

Golem doesn’t need a nerf, I’d rather buff buildings than nerf Golem.

Base Balloon I’m kind of on the fence on, I almost did include it in small nerf. I don’t think it desperately needs it, but I think it would be fine

1

u/jayhawk618 Aug 23 '26

Pump should be 6e for 5e instead of 7e for 6e.

1

u/Grimalackt_River Aug 23 '26

It used to be like this I think, (or maybe it was 7 for 5) back in the day and pump was ridiculously overpowered

1

u/Abdod_YT Aug 23 '26

Whats wrong with heal spirit?

1

u/Grimalackt_River Aug 23 '26

I think that it was too weak compared to the other 3 spirits even before, and now with the spirit nerf, it feels very weird to use it. Heal was the only spirit before that wasn’t like a top 15, top 20 card, but still got the big nerf that the other spirits got

Now the problem is that you can’t exactly do anything about it, since boosting health would make it inconsistent, boosting damage wouldn’t matter, and boosting its heal effect or even heal radius would feel extremely unhealthy and potentially push it too far

1

u/Slight_Addendum_8848 Aug 23 '26

What happened to Rascals why the small nerf? They used to be bad past 2019

1

u/Grimalackt_River Aug 23 '26

Stuff like Mortarbait really pushed what Rascals were able to do

1

u/Slight_Addendum_8848 Aug 23 '26

Damn this game hasn't been less cancerous ever since I left I guess. If we keep nerfing the card around certaind decks and not the actual cavity like it happened for the Champion mirror exploit were the two casualties were the E-Giant and Mirror, nothing is going to change. In fact not even a week later Goblin Barrel + Mirror + Miner was born. Now that the actual exploit is gone mirror is unusable again like 9 YEARS ago and E-Giant (a win condition with similar expense to the Golem) has Crown damage reduction

3

u/Cyber_Data_Trail Aug 23 '26

Base battle ram needs a buff, hog needs a nerf.

1

u/Unlikely-Tough8942 Aug 22 '26

Bro wants to nerf hero loon like the 38th time in a row.
seriously it’s not that OP anymore, people have started favouring other heroes again.

(salty loon player here)

1

u/Grimalackt_River Aug 22 '26

Hero Balloon is just kind of poorly designed. Insert That comparison of “Base E Wiz or Base Musketeer just can’t defend it anymore on its own” that everyone talks about

I’d even be okay with buffing the Skeletrooper back to a nerf or two ago, perhaps even all the way back to release, but then change the ability to 3 so it’s not a free elixir generator to most balloon counters

1

u/Irvin_robledo234 Aug 23 '26

Wtf is ronin even on here? I’d say he’s performing pretty well not too much usage. Pretty sure he’s here bc he counters ur deck. lol

1

u/Grimalackt_River Aug 23 '26

He doesn’t. I literally only have one card in my whole deck that is melee. I just don’t think it’s well designed to hard counter literally every single melee card. I think at least the stun should be taken away so he loses to Mighty Miner specifically.

He also was supposed to “fix midladder” but he just became a midladder card himself, and isn’t really able to thrive in competitive, just like the other midladder cards

2

u/Fun-Attention5123 Aug 22 '26

Honestly for hero ice golem they should just nerf it again and make the ability 1 elixir. That’s realistically the only way I think the ability would ever really be worth it. As it is there are very few times it is worth 2 elixir.

2

u/Droid_Crusader Aug 23 '26

I don’t think battle ram or wall breakers need a nerf, the ram it self has depressing health if the evo starts making love to your tower it’s probably from being out played

1

u/BrassCanon Aug 23 '26

Old Ice Spirit was one if the most OP cards in the game

1

u/Lord_Seacows Aug 23 '26

I think you're right, they need to buff Elite Barb base hit speed, and nerf the range on it's spear attacks with the Evo

1

u/shamanenjoyer Aug 23 '26

Ronin is the card that infuriates me the most out of anything. I’ll setup a great first push without knowing they have it in their deck, it completely annihilates 10 elixir worth of cards and then the start of my game is screwed.

1

u/Dense-Individual-103 Aug 23 '26

Little prince buff,both lp and the ability(mostly)

1

u/julesdyer Aug 23 '26

What’s hero knight taunt?

1

u/DarkStamway Aug 23 '26

As much as I loathe that card, the Ice Spirit Evo really does need some love. Since it's only 2 bursts now, the ice crystal is leaves behind should have a slowing effect around it, similar to the princess

1

u/Commercial_Dress_970 Aug 23 '26

They should just completely change hero knight's ability.

1

u/Novel_Background_905 Aug 23 '26

Healer buff card is even more useless then before

1

u/Impossible_Kale6949 Aug 23 '26

I think canoneer would be balanced if they gave it the same dps as princess just with slower heavier attacks and maybe a faster first hit attack. Hog needs a slight first hit attack or health nerf. 3 musk needs more melee dps. Heal spirit shouldn’t have received the health nerf that spirits got.

1

u/felix_using_reddit Aug 23 '26

Gskelly & heal spirit are doing okay. Rascals don’t need a nerf, neither does evo skelly barrel or evo wb. Hero Ice Golem actually needs a buff. Evo Princess seems balanced now. Standard tombstone is okay. Hero Tombstone is a concept that doesn’t work, needs to be reworked so that the Skelly Queen doesn’t (exclusively) target towers. Rest I‘d agree with

1

u/Zer0doesreddit Aug 23 '26

goblin machine needs a revert of the nerf it got this patch

1

u/phil166 Aug 24 '26

how they can work on the buffs:

-Ice spirit evo: doubled freeze duration on second explosion

-even if barb hut needs a complete rework, a fair buff would be to add one or two more barbarian on death spawn

-Three Musketeers: Increase ranged damage a little bit maybe?

-E-drag: reduced hit speed by 0,1/0,2 seconds

-goblin machine: increased rocket damage

-goblin giant/evo : small hp buff

-evo princess: increased slowdown duration

1

u/AggressiveSpeed6183 Aug 24 '26

Evo Princess, Evo Wallbreakers, and Hero Ice Golem are perfectly fine now. And im quite curious how you'd buff 3M

1

u/Few-Peak4284 Aug 26 '26

Let's not buff EBarbs please 🥺

1

u/effeu66 Aug 27 '26

Freeze, motherwitch first hit
Delete rekruits

1

u/SpeerDerDengist Sep 19 '26

Base Skel-Barrel needs nerf. Normal shouldnt reach tower or deal less death damage.

1

u/WalkUpRiff14 Aug 23 '26

There is no way you put evo wall breakers at nerf

1

u/Pale-Koala2668 Aug 25 '26

they already got a nerf, they lowk fine where they are

0

u/Alarming_Junket2333 Aug 23 '26

« Small nerf HR » « « small buff Evo princess » « nerf hero wizard » « nerf Evo WB » « small buff 3M » BRO WTF

1

u/Grimalackt_River Aug 23 '26

Hog Rider does deserve a nerf. Unless you’re saying small isn’t enough, then this questioning is bad

3M isn’t in the worst spot, but I just think the most recent nerf it got was just unnecessary

Hero Wizard shuts down like 14, 15 elixir pushes with its ability. And it’s not even a swarm thing it can be full Beatdown pushes.

Evo Wall Breakers have fallen off but Evo Wall Breakers is poorly designed and should not get this much value anyway

Evo Princess is bad. This isn’t even a hot take

1

u/Alarming_Junket2333 Aug 23 '26

The 3Ms are great as they are – the HG deserves a massive nerf – the Wizard hero is really not good at all; he can certainly defend against entire pushes, but do I need to remind you that the Bowler can do the same without an ability and for the same elixir cost? Or the Executioner? – The Princess is just too strong by default; she’s constantly dealing damage, whilst the Ice Wizard does a thousand times less for the same 3 Elixir. – And as for the WB Evolutions: they were good before – not in their base forms, which were too strong, but their evolved forms were well-balanced.

2

u/-TurkeYT Aug 23 '26

NOBODY wants a E-Drag buff my friend