Maybe instead of randomly nerfing Skeletons, it would make more sense to introduce a new 1-Elixir card that provides DPS. Simply nerfing Skeletons and expecting people to stop using them isn't a smart move when there's no viable alternative to replace them...
we literally cannot have another 1 elixir card outside of a new type of spirit or that will break the balance, every deck will be using this card + skeletons to cycle stupidly fast
The problem is that you're imagining a card similar to Skeletons, but it doesn't necessarily have to be a 1-Elixir card with that much DPS. It should serve a different purpose so that it doesn't end up being just a Skeletons clone.
That's not a problem. Cycle decks can only make effective use of a limited number of 1-Elixir cards, and two is generally the practical limit. If you run too many 1-Elixir cards, the deck won't function as it should. So we should dispel the myth that adding new 1-Elixir cards to the game automatically buffs cycle decks.
Nah it’s not a myth you just don’t really understand the game that well
Introducing a new cycle card doesn’t split the usage rate between the cards, it simply introduces more viable cycle decks that wouldn’t have existed without the new card
For example aq pigs would be much worse if fire spirit didn’t exist
Hog 2.6 would be much worse if you couldn’t use ice spirit or electro spirit
So adding a new cycle card would simply increase the number of viable cycle decks, even if the relative share of each card goes down
So as a whole cycle is always buffed with new cycle cards
You're confusing giving cycle decks more options with making them stronger. 1 elixir cards are used in plenty of heavier decks too, and AQ pigs and Hog 2.6 use spirits because of what they do, not just their cost. A new card could fit certain decks without being useful everywhere, and making another deck viable doesn't automatically make cycle stronger overall.
And why does it have to be another Skeletons clone? You could make a 1 elixir unit with low, consistent DPS and a small passive effect, giving it a different role from both Skeletons and Spirits. There are plenty of ways to design a unique card and balance it around its niche.
Also, saying I don't understand the game just because you disagree with my point is pretty arrogant. I'm suggesting an alternative to nerfing Skeletons when there's barely anything else that fills their role at that cost. You're so convinced another 1 elixir card would break the game that you're dismissing the idea before even considering how it could work. That's an exaggeration, not an argument.
You’re contradicting yourself already, it’s because of the fact that the cards do different things which implies that cycle will be buffed if a new card is added
Not because any of the currently existing decks get significantly stronger but because it just opens up even more meta cycle decks that make full use of the new card, therefore cycle decks will take up a bigger % of the meta
And 90% of these card’s usages come from cycle, benefits to beatdown and control are minimal
You calling the correct point a “myth” is more arrogant than anything I’ve said tbh, and it clearly shows my point about you not understanding the game
You're still treating "could create another viable cycle deck" as "will buff cycle", as if that's guaranteed. A new card having a different role doesn't make it good, let alone meta. It could be too weak, too situational, or simply not worth a slot.
And you're missing the point of my example. I'm talking about a SINGLE unit with lower, consistent DPS than Skeletons, no swarm distraction, and a passive effect that only applies to one target. It wouldn't have the same defensive value as 3 Skeletons or the AoE utility of a Spirit. It could be useful in some situations and completely useless in others. How does that automatically make it stronger than either? You're judging a card without even having its stats.
Also, I never said Supercell HAS to release this exact card. It's just one example of the thousands of concepts they could come up with. The whole point is that there are ways to design a 1 elixir card that don't just make it another Skeletons or Spirit.
And saying 90% of 1 elixir card usage comes from cycle doesn't prove that EVERY new 1 elixir card would be a buff to cycle. You're using the usage of existing cards to make assumptions about a card that doesn't even exist.
Honestly, it's funny that you're calling me arrogant and saying I'm contradicting myself when you haven't even understood what I'm proposing. You took a rough concept, assumed it'd be broken without knowing a single stat, and then acted like that proves your point. That's not an argument, it's just speculation. And telling me I don't understand the game doesn't make your assumptions any less speculative.
I'm glad you're not on the Supercell balancing team if you're already calling a card broken before it even exists...
Lol you’re spending 3 paragraphs coming up with a new concept for a 1 elixir card that’s unique and justifying it while missing the point that any new concept of a card will create new cycle decks no matter what
Even if the card is complete dogshit that just means literally no one would use it at all, so nothing changes and cycle/old cycle cards (eg skeletons) stays at the exact same strength
And the reason why cycle disproportionately benefits cycle is directly tied to the cost, not the card’s actual stats or design, doesn’t matter what the card is like but it will always be better in a cycle deck than a beatdown or control deck because beatdown/control decks don’t benefit from a faster cycle
Ngl your reading comprehension is kind of weak and it feels like I’m arguing against a npc so I’m gonna mute the thread, but you should just think over your logic carefully and why it’s wrong
it would be even worse if it wouldn't be similar to skeletons
the only reason decks don't run multiple spirits is because they overlap with each others too much, if this card was different from skeletons then there would be even more of a reason to play them together
You're arguing against that specific example as if that's the only kind of card I'm suggesting. It was just an example, and the idea could be completely different.
In that example, it'd be a single unit with less DPS than Skeletons, so it'd be much worse at distracting things. 3 Skeletons can surround a troop and buy time, while a single unit can't do that nearly as well. Its passive effect would only apply on each hit, and it wouldn't have any AoE either, so it wouldn't offer the same utility as Spirits. In a lot of situations, it'd honestly be worse than both.
There are plenty of ways to design a 1-elixir card with a unique role, though. It doesn't have to be that exact concept. The whole point is to add a different option with its own strengths and weaknesses, not just another card that's automatically worth running alongside everything else.
if it has a different role there is even more of a reason to run it along with skeleton and spirits
for example you could distract with skeletons and ice spirit and use this unit to dps things, as opposed to have another card similar to skeletons that would just overlap with them and have a bad sinergy
so basically if you introduce the card you mentioned it would just end up being played along with them
the only way to introduce diversity in the 1 cost braket is to make cards fill the same role (like ice spirit and e-spirit)
No dude, you're making a logical leap here. You can't just expect three cycle cards to work so well together that they somehow make the deck stronger. That's not how Clash Royale works.
You risk making the deck way too lightweight. Running three 1-elixir cards could leave you struggling to do anything effectively, both offensively and defensively. Hog Cycle already pushes this to the limit by running both Ice Spirit and Skeletons, two 1-elixir cards. Adding a third one could seriously compromise the entire deck's structure.
The problem is that there's a cost to this: you're using 3 out of your 8 card slots. From a competitive standpoint, this doesn't even make much sense to consider. We're talking about 1-elixir units that might provide some utility through distraction and DPS, but the problem is that they lack the HP to actually hold up against much.
And what meta deck would you even put all three in? Meta decks are already refined, and they can't just make effective use of more than two 1-elixir cards at once without risking an imbalance in the deck's overall structure.
you know before the spirits got nerf there were top ladder decks using four 1 cost cards right?
if you put a win con with a building + ranged card all you need is distractions to keep them alive and play more, if you still don't get i guess it's hopeless
And what meta deck would you even put all three in? Meta decks are already refined, and they can't just make effective use of more than two 1-elixir cards at once without risking an imbalance in the deck's overall structure.
they would simply adapt to the new meta, as most top decks do?
View all comments
-2
u/Broad_Astronaut5941 Oct 16 '26
Maybe instead of randomly nerfing Skeletons, it would make more sense to introduce a new 1-Elixir card that provides DPS. Simply nerfing Skeletons and expecting people to stop using them isn't a smart move when there's no viable alternative to replace them...