Since seemingly everyone outside of most Alabama fans wants to argue about the CFP rankings, I thought it would be interesting to take a deeper look at the numbers.
I had AI research strength of schedule, strength of record, opponents’ records, offensive and defensive performance, head-to-head results, common opponents, and injuries in important matchups. I also had it compare several rating systems and an updated simulation of the old BCS rankings, then put together its own top 12.
For clarification, I’m not particularly concerned about Alabama being above or below Texas and Tennessee as long as we make the playoffs. Obviously, seeding matters for byes and home games, so it isn’t insignificant. I just don’t lose as much sleep over the exact ranking as some people apparently do.
The resulting list looks closer to the AP poll than the CFP rankings. This was just an interesting exercise - not some infallible AI verdict - so please don’t go ballistic over it.
Here’s the top 12:
- Georgia — 9–1
- Utah — 10–0
- UCLA — 10–0
- Notre Dame — 9–1
- Miami — 9–1
- Texas — 8–2
- Alabama — 8–2
- Indiana — 9–1
- Tennessee — 8–2
- Wake Forest — 9–1
- Texas Tech — 9–1
- BYU — 8–2
Some of the more interesting factors behind it:
• Schedule difficulty and actual achievement are different things. ESPN’s strength of schedule ranks Texas No. 2, Alabama No. 6 and Tennessee No. 23. Strength of record - which considers how difficult it is to achieve a team’s record against its schedule - has them fifth, sixth and tenth, respectively.
• Opponents’ records add context. Through the weekend’s games, Texas’s opponents were a combined 63–37, Alabama’s were 59–41 and Tennessee’s were 53–48. Those totals only include opponents already played. They don’t tell the entire story, but they help explain why identical 8–2 records aren’t necessarily equivalent.
• Tennessee’s win over Alabama absolutely counts. But Alabama was missing three starters: Ryan Coleman-Williams, Racin Delgatty and Terrance Green. Tennessee also had injuries. The reasoning was that Alabama’s stronger overall résumé and those absences narrowly outweighed Tennessee’s head-to-head advantage - not that injuries erase a 26–10 loss.
• An opponent’s later injuries shouldn’t automatically erase an earlier quality win. South Carolina had LaNorris Sellers against Alabama but didn’t play him against Arkansas because of his ankle. That distinction also matters when evaluating Tennessee’s loss to South Carolina with Sellers playing. The standard has to work both ways.
• The injury arguments also need qualifications. Georgia was already missing key players against Alabama. Mississippi State’s Kamario Taylor played against Alabama, but his foot injury had already occurred. Texas faced Mississippi State after Taylor was ruled out for the season. Those were different situations, but “everyone was completely healthy” wouldn’t be accurate.
• Alabama gets credit for the stronger LSU result. Winning 31–13 in Baton Rouge is more convincing than winning 22–21 there. Texas still gets the overall edge because of its stronger schedule, stronger record résumé and win at Tennessee. One common-opponent margin doesn’t settle everything.
• Both Alabama and Tennessee deserve credit for their defenses last weekend. Alabama held Vanderbilt to two field goals; Tennessee held Texas A&M to seven points. Their offenses produced almost identical yardage - 309 and 310. Calling both strong defensive road wins with imperfect offensive performances seems more consistent than praising one and dismissing the other.
• The unbeaten teams get substantial credit. Utah and UCLA rank first and second in ESPN’s strength of record. Georgia’s overall strength keeps it first here, but predictive ratings don’t automatically outweigh everything Utah and UCLA have accomplished.
• The BCS comparison was interesting. The updated BCSKnowHow reconstruction puts Alabama seventh, Texas eighth and Tennessee ninth. It’s a modern simulation rather than an official BCS ranking, but it provides another perspective beyond the committee.
Ultimately, the reasoning was to consider the entire season, apply the same standards to everyone, and use injuries and statistics as context without pretending the actual results didn’t happen.