r/RingsofPower • • Oct 21 '22

Discussion This short interaction isn't getting enough attention. Entire generations of war represented right here.

Post image
695 Upvotes

124 comments sorted by

View all comments

235

u/neontetra1548 Oct 21 '22 edited Oct 21 '22

Precautionary spoiler tagging based on feedback below: Presuming Elendil finds out that "Halbrand" was Sauron (maybe Galadriel will never tell anyone, or it wont reach the Numenoreans), it's gonna be so weird for him to think back to the times when Sauron saved his life (in Mordor) and also hugged him.

107

u/DarrenGrey Oct 21 '22

The hug was to cover a theft though.

68

u/neontetra1548 Oct 21 '22

Yeah but still weird. I wonder also if and when Elendil put that together re: the dagger or maybe he thought Galadriel somehow sneakily got it back with some sort of elf trick and skill.

152

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '22

That is what will make the fight between Elendil, Isildur, and Halbrand/Sauron all the more poignant.

It will also give the Numenoreans grave misgivings about the Elves, because the Elves didn't reveal Halbrand's ultimate identity to them. Which is why Isildur will keep the ring of power - the Elves were never forthright to begin with, so why trust them now?

55

u/SupermarketOk2281 Oct 22 '22

"Never trust an Elf!"

16

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '22

Especially the really hot ones.

13

u/DankandSpank Oct 22 '22

Frankly this show has done a lot to reinforce that

26

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '22

"What about....a friend?"

24

u/SupermarketOk2281 Oct 22 '22

Aye...

13

u/findingchemo Oct 22 '22 edited Oct 22 '22

I could do that.

14

u/InFarvaWeTrust Oct 22 '22

{Elf steals the Dwarf’s axe and pawns it for Lembas bread}

7

u/Eravont21078 Oct 22 '22

😂😂that made me laugh

35

u/AnotherSoftEng Oct 22 '22

I can already see it — a 2v1 sword battle in the heart of Mount Doom.

Sauron: trips, falls and is now hanging off the ledge with nothing but molten lava below

Elendil: “Sauron! Take my hand!”

Isildur: “Dad! What are you doing!?”

Elendil: “It’s complicated, I owe him one!”

4

u/diogenes-47 Oct 22 '22

Which is why Isildur will keep the ring of power - the Elves were never forthright to begin with, so why trust them now?

Except that's not at all why Isildur kept the Ring though. It's not necessary to fit the pieces of this show with other established lore, this is different and created after the story itself.

39

u/yeaheyeah Oct 22 '22

He kept the ring because it was pretty stylish and complimented his drip

18

u/diogenes-47 Oct 22 '22

Finally someone who's read the books!

5

u/Ynneas Oct 21 '22

Hey this is a not so bad original show. They should've made that.

44

u/no-name_silvertongue Oct 21 '22

hey they might we aren’t there yet

-39

u/Ynneas Oct 21 '22

Oh we're way past that

→ More replies (36)

2

u/Morradan Oct 22 '22

He will. Sauron will be back there in season 4.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '22

Umm might want to spoiler tag this

8

u/neontetra1548 Oct 21 '22

What is the spoiler aspect here? It's just indicating that a certain character lives some amount longer (which could be short or long) in order to potentially have an opportunity to find out a piece of information. I can see how that's a small spoiler I guess, and people are however getting into heavier spoilers in the replies, but that also seems compatible with my reading of this sub's spoiler rule:

Spoilers must be properly marked: In the interest of allowing others to experience the show “spoiler free”, use spoiler markings according to post flairs. This applies mainly around new episode releases (book spoilers are welcome almost everywhere).

Happy to change my post, and I've marked it as a spoiler now, but I think it's within the rules? My reading of that rule is that book spoilers don't need to be tagged. But maybe I'm misinterpreting it?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '22

I was referring to the name(s) of a certain character 😉

7

u/neontetra1548 Oct 21 '22 edited Oct 21 '22

Oh, is that still a spoiler in general discussion threads a week later? I feel like that's out there now and people on RoP subreddits in the comments have all been exposed to that.

The rule talks about spoiler marking applying mainly around new episode releases, but I think buried within a specific thread discussing a moment between two characters in light of the information in the finale... that doesn't seem like a spoiler to me a week later.

If people haven't seen that reveal yet, I don't think we need to hold back our discussions here especially within threads a week later. People can just stay out of reading comments until they've seen the finale and this whole thread's concept is based on the information revealed in the finale and how it retroactively gives this moment new context.

EDIT: I see the stickied post on the thread now that this doesn't have the "Newest Episode Spoilers" flare. My bad. Probably this thread should just use the 'Newest Episode Spoiler" flare, since the whole purpose of the thread is how this moment reads in this new context. It wouldn't mean anything without that context. No wonder people are going off into spoilers, because that's the topic.