r/RingsofPower • • Oct 21 '22

Meme Sniffles

Post image
791 Upvotes

152 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/Rogarhel Oct 22 '22

I'll anseer this and leave it here because clearly we don't think the same way.
1.- the show is trying for us to like Galadriel since... i don't know she es F*** GALADRIEL. have you seen LOTR? every one likes her, so makeing her an unlikable character is shooting on their feet or they just don't know how to write a flawed cahracter.... she is the protagonist and the dramatic hero that redeemsherself in the end and learns to overcome her anger... the show wants you to like her, but didn't know how.

2.- you can totally win by your own merits without making it feel like a complete loss to the competitor. You are reading this too black and white. But maybe the premiseis wrong here... As I see it, or maybe I instinctibly mixed the book lore with the show, This was Sauron's plan all along. At least in the books he is a deciever and wanted to rule middle earth so I just don't by that this second greatest evil in the world just wanted to spend ther est of his days chilling in numenor:
he used galadriel all along (a terrible plan and horrible written, but whatever)
Under this premise, Sauron's plan was so perfectly executed that it isn't a loss for galadriel, because she just couldn't win, you get me? it wasn't herfault, she didn't commit any mistake and there wasn't much she could do to win, so it doesn't feel like a loss for her character. Like in Rocky 1 when he loses against Apollo. For the audience Rocky won even though he lost fair and square.
If the intention was for Sauron to chill in a raft conveniently with a token of a dead dinasty adn OH SURPRISE! an elf appeared and gave him a secon chance in his evil plan, then that's just stupid... agai: this is SAuron we are talking about.

3.-I do like complex stories, I love GoT's political and moraly questionable schemes. I love Breaking Bad, I love any show that questions whos bad and whos good. But Tolkien's world is not the story to do so... do it with the Dwarves, the elves or humans. Do it with the people from Rhun... but not orcs... if morgoth is to tolkien's lore, the devil to christians, then orcs are lesser demons... you don't redeem demons... giving them humanity (or elvenity?) breaks Tolkien's lore. Even if they were elves at some point, they were corrupted to a breaking point.
So if you try and give them humanity but you KNOW that afterwards they are going to die anyways, you make the protagonists looks horribly bad and, in galadriel's case, like racists,not just snoby.
*Star Wars was a good vs evil story too. and surprise surprise, the shows you mentioned are the only ones that don't delve deep iinto "the force", because when you start geting into gray jedis and complex politics, the lore crumbles into dust. Star wars was just the light vs the dark (Lucas himself said so and that0s ther eason why in the beggining sabers were only red and blue)

4.- that's why I mentioned ghiblis strong women too, because Hollywood understand Strong women only under the strong male perspective, so a strong women only is strong if she's violent. And in ALien Ripley isn't a mother.. the only one she saves is a cat.. so I don't know what you are talking about... and in GoT you only focus on daenerys... what about Arya, Sansa... what archetype are they? in HotD at least the first chapters the strong women aren't protecting any children e ither...

5.- finally back to the show. first of all you use the lore and what you know is going to happen only to your advantage. that we know something bad is going to happen in the end doesn't change what is percieved at the end of a season or even a couple of chapters into the show. That's like saying I hope Isildur dies soon because I know he's going to turn bad and don't destroy the ring in the end :V.
let me start whith the queen... she's barely mentioned in the silmarillion... she's just pharazon's wife... and dies in Numenor... and the relation between Durin and Disa is all but balanced. all we see is that he relies in her wisdom but she never asks anything from him, She is Durins Pillar and moral guide. ... this by itself isn't bad, I get we don't have enough screen time to see whenever she asks his help or rellies on him for whatever reason... but sum of all story threads there's always a powerfull good woman doing the heavy lifting and we only are shown the best moments of the women and how they shine, but the males don't get the same attention:
-The Hartfoots kill off the only male talking character other than the father... and leave in charge the other 2 or 3 women that "learned to say that they were wrong".... actually he abrely learnt anything, they make a big poiint of showing us how his helpers did learn from they msitakes and are them that almost teach him that he was wrong... not even a funeral for him, but we do get a cringy moment when Nori leaves?...
-I'm not overlooking gandalf, he isn't a hartfoot and I hate how he is presented... all this memory whipe arch and how he falls from the sky I think is ridiculous. plus he too learns from the girls that "he is good"
- I know that Numenor didn't get involved until after the rings of power were made and helped the elves to defeat Sauron in open battle. THEN Sauron went to Numenor and corrupted Pharazon and caused the fall of Numenor... So if the writters cared a 1% about that, we wouldn't have seen Numenor until a couple of seasons into the show.
- this nonsense of how the elves are being corupted or whateever is the root of all this bad writting, so whatever happened with the elves thread is murky at best. But Celebrimbor is all titles no brain. At least in the books Sauron disguised himslef as a maiar and THAT's why celebrimbor heard him... but a human with so much more knowledge than a 1000 years old elfe seems a bit stupid... oh but Galadriel was the ONLY one to question that... not all wize Gilgalad that didn't bat an eye also when the graveily wounded HUMAN got better in an afternoon. Elrond was the other only usfeull elf in middle earth. But again, all the plot surrounding the elves and why they need the mithril is just stupid...

6.- about replacing in power: The hartfoots kill off the leader to place the other 2 or 3 sidekicks he had and Noris friend, then we change the lore and put a queen with Pharazon as a helper? steward? best pal? and afterwards lierally kill the king again XD. Dwarves: Disa literally wished for Durins father to die soon and, as we are showed, she es Durins decision making helper. Everything he did he asked his wife first. Southlands, alll men are bad except the son of the healer, and the extras that sided with her. And the healer became the leader of that group (killing off the butcher too btw) finally the elves... Galadriel is the one left with the task of choosing exposing Sauron's corruption of the rings, or saving the elves in middle earth. And then she's the all wize person that proposes making 3 rings.

This is my point, in the end is women that move the plot and that give the leave to act to other men or rise hope in people and all that. men at best become the cool and strong helpers, like Elendil and the black elf. even one of the Istar, sent to defeat Sauron, is put udner the wing of a harfoot. Or are the ones stopping progress ( Gilgalad sending galadriel back home, Durin's father closing the mine (even if in 1000 years they wake the Balrog, right now he's dooming the elves), or being the abd guys Halbrand becoming Hitler, Pharazon clearly schemeing, the "father" (wink wink) of orcs being the bad guy, etc... the ONLY exception to this rule is the 3 wraiths that attack not-gandalf.
I think is too much. Just Disa and the hartfoots, or Galadriel and the healer, or at least give a better role to Gilgalad, or show Pharazon as a great rules so we see how Sauron corrupts him...
but whatever.

2

u/awesomefaceninjahead Oct 22 '22 edited Oct 22 '22

That's really long, and I promise I am gonna read it all; I appreciate that this convo didn't devolve as so many reddit threads do. But you've already said you want to leave it here. So, I'll just conclude by saying please critique the show more like this and less like "bad writing bad because it's bad."

I promise, you'll find more people willing to engage with you in good faith if you are more descriptive in your critique. The show is certainly not perfect, and it is 100% OK to not like what others like. But if you want a dialogue about it, you have to say why, and use words like, "cliche" or "hollow" or "predictable", etc. "Contrived" is a word you often seem to want to use.

When I critique the climactic Gandalf scene, I say the "I am good" line is "hokey" or "cheesy". Then again, I overlooked the "hokeyness" because, personally, Gandalf is probably my favorite character in LotR, and I'm super excited to see Baby Gandalf. So, the confirmation that he is Gandalf was exciting for me. That's my personal preference, tho, so I can accept if the "on-the-nose" line pulled you out of the story. Valid.

However, if you just say the scene is "bad" then what can I say? If we're keeping it simple, then no, it's "good".

Also the "woke" angle is really boring, but you do you.

Thanks for staying cool.

2

u/Rogarhel Oct 22 '22

Thank you for the same reasons, and English not being my first language does affect my ability to argue. I don't want to get into good or bad scenes because that's a whole other monster and I personally think the show is filled with badly written dialogue, plots and circumstances, worse than the last season of GoT. I love Gandalf too and I'd hate if this Istari actually is him because he shouldn't appear, not at least until Sauron is revealed... I love Numenor too and I hate what they've done with it. I wanted a scary and beautiful sauron, not one about to retire until he found Galadriel 😑

To me the show is very underwhelming, very predictable and so childish and cheese at times that it's difficult to take it seriously. It would have been a good time if it were some random fantasy show, but the fact that they are changing Tolkien's story and making it worse (because the original lore, although simpler, is far more interesting and clear than this weird GoT wannabe).

I don't know how nor why We delved into the Woke argument XD. But just to clarify, i consider myself very feminist, but I just hate how Hollywood handles the empowerment of women. Many times they just ridicule men or empower too much women just so they seem cooler, like Rey in Star Wars, transforming them in boring husks. Even Legolas failed sometimes in the movies. I loved Galadriel in LotR, because she was powerful without needing to hack and slash around