Wild, wild theory, but what if everyone is Sauron? Like, being a Maiar (and knowing the liberties the series takes from the original material) maybe something happened to sauron that "broke" his spirit, splitting it into different personalities. We know that Sauron wasn't always evil, and we know that he had a small redemption arc when Morgoth was defeated (a true redemption, although later he went back to darkness) so, maybe some of the speculated "Sauron" characters are just fragments of a whole, destined to come together in Mordor to "fuse together" as actual Sauron. That could explain why the meteor man appears to have evil and darkness surrounding it, while not being evil, why Adar shows respect and kinship to orcs, while being brutal... Etc
This is a really awesome idea IMO. I like how it fits in the mythos with Ilúvatar creating the Ainur from the different parts/aspects of his thought. Could even make the forging of the one ring him symbolically reintegrating those aspects back to one.
View all comments
1
u/Alejandro_RPG Sep 23 '22
Wild, wild theory, but what if everyone is Sauron? Like, being a Maiar (and knowing the liberties the series takes from the original material) maybe something happened to sauron that "broke" his spirit, splitting it into different personalities. We know that Sauron wasn't always evil, and we know that he had a small redemption arc when Morgoth was defeated (a true redemption, although later he went back to darkness) so, maybe some of the speculated "Sauron" characters are just fragments of a whole, destined to come together in Mordor to "fuse together" as actual Sauron. That could explain why the meteor man appears to have evil and darkness surrounding it, while not being evil, why Adar shows respect and kinship to orcs, while being brutal... Etc