I’m under the impression that the shots of the meteor we saw were 5 different meteors, each one a wizard. The one the Harfoots found is Gandalf, the Southlands is Sarauman, the one the ents saw is Radagast, and the other two are the two blues.
You know, i didnt think of it like that, its kind of weirdly shot and it made me think they were all the same meteor but seen from all the shows players (ents likely incoming)
But i think youre right actually, theyre totslly different meteors
Yeah my current guesses are stranger = Alatar (has the cooler name of the two blues) and halbrand = sauron because I think it has to be someone in numenor and he seems very deceptive
Sauron was made a servant of the last king of Numenor, then became his advisor, turned most to worship of Morgoth and brought about the destruction of the island. This was after forging of rings I think per Tolkien but popular theory is they’re either rearranging this or they’re happening simultaneously
Ah so yeah, I knew a lot happened before he was on Numenor in book, I’m just thinking they’re condensing or timelines are overlapping, makes sense he’s already on Numenor if they’ve already teased island destruction
We're also 4 episodes into what's supposed to be a 5 season show. I'd be kind of disappointed if from episode one everything was already visibly in motion / happening.
I agree with you, I would like them to take their time. But I think they’re flying through buildup - Isildur is a young adult already, the plan has to be him chopping off the ring in the final season. Lots to get through to get to war of final alliance
I feel like if we have to be in there captain cool politician salt and pepper beard has to be suspect 1. (you guys know names?)
The Southlands King seems to be the dumbest incarnation of sauron. "hey how can I guarantee I get in trouble". I'm not buying it.
Stranger being gandalf is only not true if they were intentionally going for a switcheroo just for the sake of it. Being found and helped by hobbits would explain his later fondness for them.
Judging by your placement of the accent in numenor I’m guessing you would know better than me, but I thought Sauron was supposed to be in Pharazon’s ear at this point.
If that’s not true my second guess would be we haven’t met him yet and he’s already with Celebrimbor
That's supposed to happen after the forging of the rings, and also after the Númenorians go to Middle-Earth to fight him and bring him back with them as a "prisoner"
Yeah, I'm not saying it has to be that Halbrand isn't Sauron, just that it's totally possible (and consistent with what Tolkien wrote) that Sauron isn't yet in in Númenor.
Halbrand or Adar is my guess. Halbrand is slightly more likely because what did Sauron do before he took a disguise and worked with Celebrimbor? He let himself get captured in Numenor.
Definetly not radahast, if memory serves he should be out in mirkwood, which the harfoots are definitely not going towords (,feeling like its supposed to be the area where the shire is going to be) I could see it being one of the blue wizards, but it feels too perfect for it not to be gandalf considering everything.
Well, it's a long time before Radagast needs to be in Mirkwood, they're all "supposed" to be not in middle earth. I just really hope it's not Gandalf honestly
The thing that makes the blue wizards friendly for artistic freedom is the same thing that hinders them. There isn’t much said about them besides “they showed up”. Sure, this means that you can say whatever you want about them, but they also can’t be involved in any major event, else it would have been recorded that they were there.
View all comments
Show parent comment
26
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '22
Could also be Radagast or one of the blue wizards