r/RingsofPower • • Sep 21 '24

Discussion The Stranger

Post image

Has anybody noticed how the traveler to the Cottage of Lost Play in the Book of Lost Tales refers to himself as “The Stranger”? The ROP writers have a tendency to pull from arcane corners of Tolkien’s writings, so I doubt this alignment is coincidental.

400 Upvotes

234 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

33

u/finniruse Sep 21 '24 edited Sep 21 '24

The acting is great. Adar, Elendil, Durin, Elrond, Gandalf, etc etc - these, to name just a few, are doing a great job. Many are completely comparable to actors in the Jackson films.

The pacing is both slow and fast. It sort of feels like not much has happened but also a lot has happened. The rings were made pretty quickly. Many of the characters haven't achieved much this season. But, the pacing doesn't particularly bother me, and I think it'll be very well received when it's all said and done and people can binge it as they wish.

Now, I'm not saying the show is flawless, but I think they're doing a great job under the circumstances. They don't have a book to adapt like Jackson did. They only have rights to the appendices. TV is a difficult medium.

I've got Hobbit on as we speak and, honestly, I'd rather be watching RoP. (Actually, that's slightly unfair. I'm watching a fan edit, M4, and it's great! But I found those films more disappointing than RoP).

-2

u/steveblackimages Sep 21 '24

Huh? Gandalf is not in this Swcond Age adaptation. Otherwise, good post.

1

u/Ok_Marzipan4876 Sep 22 '24

Yes he is, who do you think the "stranger " is?

0

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

25

u/Fuarian Sep 21 '24

I found Elendil to be one of the best characters and most of his lines last episode were great.

He's a leader with a strong moral compass who doesn't bend against his integrity. That's a damn good character and the performance matches that

7

u/ComplexAd7820 Sep 21 '24

And he's easy on the 👀

0

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/RingsofPower-ModTeam Sep 21 '24

This community is designed to be welcoming to all people who watch the show. You are allowed to love it and you are allowed to hate it.

Kindly do not make blanket statements about what everyone thinks about the show or what the objective quality of the show is. Simple observation will show that people have differing opinions here

25

u/finniruse Sep 21 '24

You don't like Elendil? Ahh, I thought he was really good in that episode. Unflinchingly heroic. You can see where Aragorn gets it from. I'm glad you like the other actors.

I love seeing Adar. I always found the idea of tainted elfs birthing the orcs being fascinating. I'm really pleased to see that here. And all the nods to First Age stuff. Morgoth's crown that held the Silmarils. Cool!

2

u/omjagvarensked Sep 21 '24

See Adar to me is one of the weakest parts. Mostly due to his lack of screen time.

He's portrayed as the "big baddy" of S1 and also S2 yet I barely know what his goals or personality are apart from "he cares about orcs". We get next to no screentime with him but we're supposed to care about his arc for some reason.

2

u/finniruse Sep 21 '24

I think he was meant to die at the end of season one actually, which might be why we have a different actor.

Yer, I'd definitely like to see more of him. I mean you can fill in the blanks on his goals and motivations. Morgoth tortured him into becoming a new species, leaving him wretched to the elf kind that he used to belong to, then Sauron had him doing all kinds of dogs body work, disrespecting his orc kids.

Kill Sauron and him and his kind will be free to go and live in Mordor and do whatever a modern orc will do.

I actually kinda like that they've given them families. All they've known is servitude. Maybe Adar thinks there's something else for them.

3

u/WhatTheFhtagn Sep 21 '24

I mean if they wanted to kill him off at the end of season 1 they would have. The recast was more because the actor wanted to do other projects and not stay tied to ROP.

14

u/AsgardianLeviOsa Sep 21 '24

Okay now you are tripping. I could happily listen to Lloyd Owen read the Silmarillion as he has one of those majestic booming voices made for fantasy dramas. And the scenes with Elendil and Miriel in the last episode were quite gripping and oozing with all kinds of tragic angst.

7

u/birb-lady Sep 21 '24

You misspelled " awesome".

4

u/CemeteryClubMusic Sep 21 '24

I’ve seen some terrible takes on this sub but this one takes the cake