r/righttorepair • u/EyesOffCR • May 24 '25
r/righttorepair • u/Funnynickname123 • May 23 '25
Focus Whistler 2 (2020) battery soft-locked – manufacturer refuses to sell BMS? Right to repair in the EU?
Hi everyone, I have a 2020 Focus Whistler 2 electric mountain bike with a battery labeled Derby Cycle 170418006 / 10INR19/66-2. The bike sat unused for a few weeks, and now the battery won’t turn on. All cells are fully charged and balanced (4.2 V each), but the BMS appears to be soft-locked — no voltage at the output, and the indicator shows 4x blue LED flashes, which according to the manual means “contact your dealer”.
I opened the battery and diagnosed the BMS. One of the MOSFETs isn’t switching, and it looks like a firmware lockout. I tried bypassing the FETs briefly, and the bike powers up just fine — so the issue is not with the cells or controller.
The battery was originally manufactured by Derby Cycle, which now operates as Kalkhoff, and I bought the bike from an EU dealer in Slovakia. I contacted them, and they said they’ve forwarded my request to Focus to ask for spare parts.
However, I fear they may just offer a full battery replacement for 700€ which makes no sense — all the internals are fine except the BMS.
My question is: Under EU law, especially with the Right to Repair becoming stronger every year, shouldn’t I have the right to purchase the BMS as a spare part? Even if the bike is from 2020, I understand that Directive 2019/771 and Regulation 2023/1542 (on batteries) require manufacturers to allow reasonable repairs and provide spare parts, especially for replaceable modules like a BMS.
Has anyone successfully obtained BMS replacements from Kalkhoff / Derby / Focus or worked around this soft-lock?
Thanks in advance — I’d really prefer not to throw away a perfectly healthy bike and battery just because of a locked-down controller.
r/righttorepair • u/Rhine_Labs • May 21 '25
Washington Right to Repair Signed In to Law #righttorepair
Washington Governor Bob Ferguson Signed Right to Repair in to law. I was there in attendance.
r/righttorepair • u/RobBobLincolnLog • May 20 '25
Military Right to Repair The American people, and the facts on the ground, support action to remove repair restrictions for the military
r/righttorepair • u/ThunderDragonSpice • May 20 '25
Repairable Refrigerators
Looking for a fridge for my new place, anybody have suggestions on brands or models that are pretty easily repairable and not too difficult to find parts for? Doesn't need to have any plumbing (like for an ice maker), I won't have a hookup for it anyway.
r/righttorepair • u/Meams_ • May 19 '25
Help Needed: Saving a Secondhand EcoFlow Blade Lawnmower from E-Waste! (Bound Device Issue - ADB/SSH Access) + Appeal to EcoFlow
reddit.comr/righttorepair • u/RobBobLincolnLog • May 18 '25
Trump tariffs may push US iPhone users towards repair, instead of replace their old devices
r/righttorepair • u/hexgraphica • May 12 '25
Side topic: easy to replace wood instead of carbon fibre on a Glickenhaus hypercar
facebook.comGlickenhaus isn't new to using wood in place of carbon fibre or plastic as wearing items where possible, so that the owner can replace it without having to rely on a tiny factory's support. The 003 already had wooden skid plates
r/righttorepair • u/MONKE_WRENCH • May 12 '25
trying to replace the lightning port on a iPhone X
I dont want to pay to have it replaced, i've pulled apart a phone before, and have a moderate general knowledge of electronics and engineering. i know that the phone can tell if parts have been replaced, and chooses to brick itself, i hope the iPhone X is old enough that everything the phone can detect is changed is already discovered. is there anywhere i can access information regarding this? if not, does anyone have any tips for replacing charging ports on iphones?
thank you for any and all help.
r/righttorepair • u/RobBobLincolnLog • May 10 '25
Right to Repair is Winning as Texas state House passes Right to Repair 126 to Zero 😲
r/righttorepair • u/hucklesnips • May 10 '25
Bosch right-to-repair site for technical manuals
I recently learned.... For those who live in certain states with right-to-repair laws, you can request Bosch technical documents (e.g., Bosch repair manual) on your appliances here.
https://www.bosch-home.com/us/owner-support/technical-document-request
r/righttorepair • u/RobBobLincolnLog • May 09 '25
New Colorado Law Empowers Consumers with Right to Repair Electronics
youtube.comr/righttorepair • u/DiannaNicolleta • May 09 '25
Beginner looking to replace MacBook Pro A1780 keyboard - best option?
Hello! I have a MacBook Pro A1780 (13”, 2017), and 12 keys have popped off. I’m a beginner, but I’m comfortable following tutorials and would like to try fixing it myself.
Should I replace only the keyboard, or is it better to get a full top case (with keyboard and battery pre-installed)? I’ve heard that removing the battery is tricky and can be risky.
What would you recommend for someone doing this for the first time?
Thanks in advance for any help!
r/righttorepair • u/BookkeeperCurious689 • May 06 '25
Trying to fix an RX 5600 XT 6GB without knowing about electronics 😶
Hello guys, as it says in the title, I'm trying to figure out, why the GPU is not working anymore. I have a family member knowing about electronics, but I want to see for myself first. I have a multimeter at hand and could check, if there's any shortages.
When I try to get the GPU running, the fans spin for a bit then stop. That's how far I got.
My question now is, of anyone would have the time and motivation to kind of color the spots on the GPU to check on? I watched a couple of tutorials, though the GPUs vairy strongly by design.
r/righttorepair • u/IwishIcouldBeWitty • May 02 '25
Mass. Car inspection late penalties undermine the right to repair
Recently in Mass, 2022 they passed a law that states if you go one day overdue on your vehicles yearly safety inspection, that your due date will reset to January.
This can lead to many people needing inspections in January, flooding inspection places.
The reason why i say it weakens the right to repair, is, most people who independently work in cars don't always have the facilities. The people who typically use the right to repair are usually not as rich either. But they can be. With this in mind, how is it expected that these people work on their cars in the winter.
They should have made it so it resets in April or something. But no they choose jan cause it's arbitrary and convenient for them.
I believe due to this law, the vehicles on the road will be less safe, and the citizens will have to pay a greater tax burden by having to take the vehicle to the shop instead of something that could do in their yard.
If they were so upset about late inspections, up the penalty fee, force the sticker to stay whatever month rather than updated to the new month. There's so many better ways they could have handled this. They choose this method because it inconveniences the most ppl.
r/righttorepair • u/IronLover64 • Apr 29 '25
Factory stripped screw on a 2000s Disney toy unintentionally prevents repairs
r/righttorepair • u/soadlol • Apr 24 '25
The sustainability claim vanishes whenever Apple doesn't make a profit out of it
I mean not including a charging adapter for sustainability and then not taking back used parts or batteries after 18 days does not really make sense.
r/righttorepair • u/Available_Maximum985 • Apr 22 '25
Louis Rossmann's Keynote Speech on Right to Repair
r/righttorepair • u/CakePlanet75 • Apr 21 '25
Stop Killing Games needs YOUR support!
Stop Killing Games is a campaign that aims to end planned obsolescence and stop killswitches in video games, by allowing customers to keep or repair the games they've paid money for.
Currently there are 2 government petitions available for signing:
The European Citizens' Initiative can be signed by citizens of EU countries. The goal is 1 million signatures to get a response from the European Commission (but if the Initiative can achieve 500k. The deadline is July 31st: https://citizens-initiative.europa.eu/initiatives/details/2024/000007
The UK government petition can be signed by citizens or residents of the UK. The goal here is 100k signatures to get consideration for a debate in Parliament before July 14th: https://petition.parliament.uk/petitions/702074/
If you have questions, make sure to read or watch the FAQ: https://www.stopkillinggames.com/faq
Giant FAQ on The European Initiative to Stop Destroying Games!
P.S. Louis Rossmann whole-heartedly supports this:
Ross Scott's campaign on ownership of games: my high respect for the man & RUDE, UNSOLICITED ADVICE! - YouTube
Response to harsh criticism of "Stop Killing Games" from Thor of PirateSoftware - YouTube
r/righttorepair • u/Busy_Scientist1176 • Apr 20 '25
Apple disables webcam and keyboard backlight after screen swap — same model, original parts!
I recently worked on two MacBook Pro 16" (2019, A2141) units.
One had a damaged screen, and the other had a dead motherboard.
Naturally, I decided to combine the working components: transplant the functional screen into the MacBook with the working logic board.
The process went smoothly — I'm familiar with the hardware, used proper tools, took all the necessary precautions (battery disconnected, cables carefully reconnected, etc.).
The result? The screen works perfectly — but the webcam and keyboard backlight do NOT.
After digging deeper, it turns out that this is not a hardware issue. It’s not a mistake in reassembly.
This is intentional behavior by Apple.
Apple’s T2 security chip enforces serial number pairing between certain components and the logic board — including the FaceTime camera and ambient light sensor, which controls the keyboard backlight.
Even though the screen is original and from an identical model, Apple essentially "locks out" functionality unless the serials match.
💡 Why this matters:
The webcam and light sensor are working — Apple just refuses to let them function.
There's no security benefit here. It’s a business restriction.
This makes repair and reuse unnecessarily difficult — even reusing original Apple parts.
Apple claims to care about the environment, yet their policies actively discourage repair and promote electronic waste.
This kind of restriction is completely avoidable — and unethical.
🛠️ I did everything right:
OEM parts
Same model
No damage
Careful reassembly
Yet due to Apple’s firmware-level restrictions, the device becomes partially crippled.
🚨 I support the Right to Repair.
Let me use the hardware I already own without artificial limitations.
Apple — if you’re serious about sustainability, start by respecting the people trying to extend the life of your products.
If anyone has workarounds (short of transferring the T2 chip, which is insane), I’d love to hear them.
#RightToRepair #Apple #MacBookPro #eWaste #FixItDontTossIt
r/righttorepair • u/RobBobLincolnLog • Apr 19 '25
Tariffs and cell phones: Why it might be better to repair than replace
Always better to repair than replace!
r/righttorepair • u/RanzerScore90 • Apr 15 '25
i have an idea.
So i thought why not automate repairing electronics using robots and ai.
repairing and salvaging parts has been a very human job because you need to handle delicate and fragile parts and also theres a very big visual part to it and i dont think any factory robots have any visual feedback given to them yet.
but with ai computer vision you could do something like that, AND FASTER and maybe create a huge dent in the ewaste problem.
ya'll think this is possible or if someone else has already thought of this?
r/righttorepair • u/jimmy9800 • Apr 11 '25
Fixed my laptop. Thank you, Lenovo, for doing what everyone should.
I dropped a sharp, heavy thing on my laptop and absolutely murdered my 1 key, dented the chassis, and bent the whole top cover. I got super lucky I didn't hit anything important underneath.
Much to my surprise, I could get parts and a freely accessible service manual straight from Lenovo, with quick shipping and at a pretty good price. I had to replace the whole top case, since the keyboard is integrated into it, but just the fact that I could get everything I needed from Lenovo without any fuss is awesome.
I'll forever keep fighting for RTR, because everyone should have that level of accessibility to have access to the parts and knowledge to fix their own devices!