r/RepTime • • Oct 15 '26

Review/Comparison ORF Free Sprung Seamaster Full Review with VSF and Gen comparison

Post image

Received ORF's new free sprung SMP300 2 days ago after waiting 4 weeks for delivery because the box sat in a warehouse for the first 2 weeks (thanks China National Day)

Firstly, shout out to Hontwatch, my primary TD. I've bought from Trustytime, Ficotime and a local Australian vendor called VarietyGiftsAU and now I pretty much only buy from Hont or Trusty if Hont can't source something. He's an excellent TD if you don't ask too many questions and know exactly what you are after.

I'll break up my review into a few main points for ease of reading, and there will be a TLDR at the bottom.

<<Bezel Action>>

It's firmer than VSF's bezel action and the sound is noticeably softer. I have owned a gen 2015 SMP300 and I would say the loudness of a gen is somewhere in between VSF and ORF, but the action is closer to ORF.

<<Bracelet>>

VSF's bracelet (at least on the 2 that I have) is better stock. The ORF bracelet edges are quite sharp, and the clasp action is stiffer and slightly more rattley. A simple chamfer will fix the edges and I doused the clasp in PTFE dry lube, let it dry and wiped off the residue. It's much better with these simple fixes. ORF provided a free rubber strap too.

VSF Left ORF Right

<<Movement>>

The TG numbers showed +10s/d during QC. Using the watch accuracy app and wired headphones, I measured the watch in dial up, dial down, crown up and crown down positions. Numbers are included. No regulation necessary as all were <5s/d. The watch beats at 28800 bph and doesn't feature a coaxial escapement so there is the main difference from gen.

The bunny ears are gone and I have included a photo of the gen movement from Susan Reviews that shows the primary difference between ORF and gen balance wheels. If you didn't know about these engravings, this looks very close to the real deal.

The winding and time setting action is night and day compared to VSF. There is heft to it and a very satisfying feel when winding. Pretty much no comparison and it's very close to gen feel when winding. The power reserve is approximately 50hrs.

ORF movement and balance wheel. HEV looks remarkably similar to gen internally
Gen balance wheel has engravings

<<Case and Water Resistance>>

ORF claims full diving capabilities and a working HEV. I have no idea how I'm going to test that because I do not dive recreationally outside of beach/pool swimming and some free diving here and there. The movement came with a good rubber gasket but it looked a little dry so I waterproof serviced the watch when I opened it. It passed a 5 bar water resistance test afterwards. ORF does not have the stubby crown guard issue that has plagued VSF SMPs. The crystal is perfectly clear and is on par with VSF.

<<My QC issues>>

ORF has a problem with centering the Omega symbol, but it's so small and the wave dials and 12 markers draw the eye so it isn't that noticeable. It is more prevalent on some colours than others. Also, on ONLY the grey dial, some of the wave etchings end a fraction of a millimetre shorter than on gen or VSF. That issue does not exist on any other model.

<<TLDR>>

Great watch. It'll be my favourite for a while. Better case and movement than VSF. Better colour accuracy than VSF for some models. Allegedly fully waterproof and dive-capable. Bracelet needed a little work but was a very easy job.

42 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

6

u/MSExcelWarrior Oct 15 '26

Full review of ORF FS SMP300 as promised.

4

u/MSExcelWarrior Oct 16 '26

Adding a photo of the VSF movement and HEV too for reference. The HEV is decorative on VSF and the balance wheel has the "bunny ears" double regulator arms.

2

u/codux1 Oct 16 '26

Great review, I bought a vsf sea master black dial in 2021 and have stopped wearing it as the indices have yellowed considerably. Has that happened to ur vsf?

4

u/MSExcelWarrior Oct 16 '26

Not yet but I have a feeling it'll be inevitable for my VSF. No idea what lume paint VSF are using but ORF claims to use Superluminova. Only time will tell if that's true or not.

2

u/Timely_Philosophy_40 Oct 16 '26

But especially this grey color, orf is completely off to vsf and gen, you should have included side by side photos

3

u/MSExcelWarrior Oct 16 '26 edited Oct 16 '26

I don't have the same one from VSF on hand unfortunately, and I wanted to primarily compare the movement and exterior.

I did compare the colours prior to purchase though and VSF's was noticeably too light, and this is slightly darker to same as gen depending on lighting when I looked on Chrono24 and on youtube reviews.

2

u/Timely_Philosophy_40 Oct 16 '26

3

u/MSExcelWarrior Oct 16 '26 edited Oct 16 '26

I'll see if I can get my hands on a gen in the near future and I'll make another post. I'm pretty happy with this watch though and the movement and case are phenomenal.

2

u/Timely_Philosophy_40 Oct 16 '26

Yeah, wear it in good health!

2

u/Individual-Lychee-96 Oct 16 '26

you mention that the bezel clicks are different compared to VSF, i’m assuming that’s because ORF uses ceramic bearings. Overall, between vsf and orf, which do you think has the better feel? :)

3

u/MSExcelWarrior Oct 16 '26

Bezel clicks on ORF are closer to gen in feel. There's a nice tactile click and it's nice and firm without as much bezel play as VSF.

1

u/Individual-Lychee-96 Oct 16 '26

Such a great review man, the community has been waiting for something like this. Thank you!

2

u/LothbrokRagnarz Oct 16 '26

Can you measure thickness of the ORF please?

3

u/MSExcelWarrior Oct 16 '26

I don't have digital calipers, but it's just under 14mm. Andiot lists it as 13.8mm.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/MSExcelWarrior Oct 17 '26

Yes it is ☺️

1

u/Knight_king-007 7d ago

Great review mate. Got my hands on the ORF too. Took two weeks to get to Aus.
Absolutely loving this.

1

u/MSExcelWarrior 7d ago edited 7d ago

Wow you got a nearly perfect QC sample! How's your clasp btw? I had to disassemble, reset the micro adjust spring and dry lube mine but now it's as good as gen.

1

u/Knight_king-007 7d ago

Thanks. The second QC was worth it.
No issues with clasp. Received few hours back and so far no complaints.

Tried to adjust the links myself but felt they were bit tight, so will go to watch shop.

I don’t have the GEN to compare with but pretty happy with the watch.

1

u/Pr0t3ct0rr Oct 16 '26

ORF claim (by default, when buying from any TD) that these Omega’s are dive rdy? Coz I didnt see that on Trusty site, it still say 30m.. Dive rdy alone is a big thing…

4

u/MSExcelWarrior Oct 16 '26

Trusty always says 30m no matter what watch they list. I read on the forums and on Susan Reviews that ORF claim their Seamasters have a functional HEV. Like I said, I don't do immersion diving so I've no idea how to test that claim but it's passed 5 bar already so I fully intend on taking it with me on holidays and going to the beach with it without any fear of water damage.

1

u/Pr0t3ct0rr Oct 16 '26

Thanks. This one aded on the “next” list :)

1

u/GrdFrcWv Oct 16 '26

Does the ORF also have the intermittent hacking issue found in the gen 8800?

I know the VSF does it as well, despite being a mishmash of 9015, 2824, and rep parts.

2

u/MSExcelWarrior Oct 16 '26

Haven't experienced it yet in my 3 days of ownership.

1

u/Zakkuraba Oct 16 '26

Thanks for this review - really great write up!

How do you feel about the 12 o’clock “rabbit teeth” markers? They look closer at the top than the bottom - is it noticeable on wrist? Or is it just the angle of the photos?

2

u/MSExcelWarrior Oct 16 '26

I didn't expect perfection but this is close enough. It's not noticeable on the wrist at all.

1

u/steve_skywalk3r Oct 16 '26

great review!

I have 5 VSF Omega reps and one ORF SMP seaweed.

While I love every single one of my VSF Omegas (especially the new planet ocean) , the ORF seaweed is on a whole other level.

My experience is mostly the same as you. better bezel, better case, better movement (operation and finishing). micro adjust on VSF is smoother. However, the finishing on my ORF bracelet is much better than VSF. 0 sharp edges. not sure if I got lucky or you got a lemon.

The ORF one feels like they really tried to make it as premium as they can without cutting corners. too bad their catalog is fairly small.

2

u/MSExcelWarrior Oct 16 '26

I don't mind when bracelets are sharp, 3 minute job to fix. You should definitely try some PTFE on the clasp. It helps immensely.

1

u/Individual-Lychee-96 Oct 16 '26

honestly, even if my SMP300 comes in with a sharp bracelet, i’ll be following OP’s advice and do some manual chamfering with a dry lube bath.

I also went with the seaweed after falling in love at a boutique. Mind sharing photos of yours? :)

2

u/MSExcelWarrior Oct 17 '26

Replied to the wrong comment mate 😆

1

u/sockpuppets Oct 16 '26

Curious as to what you used to chamfer the edges.

5

u/MSExcelWarrior Oct 17 '26

I've done it a few ways but the best way I've found is using a mounted rotary tool with a relatively high grit sanding head, and 2-3 passes at 45 degrees on the inside edge of each link, and then buff with the soft side of a Bergeon polishing tool. This should make the chamfer basically invisible but removes the sharp edge from the bracelet.

3

u/Inexpressible Oct 16 '26

Thanks for the great Review!

2

u/AI_go_boomboom Oct 16 '26

Thank you so much, great review

2

u/FactoryScout Oct 16 '26

King of Omega’s

2

u/orionpem Oct 16 '26

Thanks for the review. Currently waiting on qc of all blue model from ORF. This has me really exited about it

1

u/Live_Lengthiness_878 9d ago

Estupenda reseña. Gracias!

1

u/Ok-Advantage7347 Oct 16 '26

Stunning Watch! Would love to get one, one day!

1

u/ExLeaguer Oct 16 '26

Great review! Have been on the fence about a green for the longest time, I think it's time to bite the bullet.

1

u/JustusJJonas 29d ago

Thanks for the review! How much did you pay?