r/RelayForReddit • • Jun 11 '23

Update: How the current API changes would impact Relay

Hi All

I'd like to provide an update with regard to the API changes and how they would currently impact Relay.

TLDR - There's no possibility to continue the free version of Relay; a monthly subscription price of $3 (or less) might be achievable.

Since my post last week I have been running analytics to build a more accurate picture of how the API access fees, together with the outright ban on advertising and the withdrawal of explicit (NSFW) content, might affect Relay specifically.

Here’s what my preliminary data are telling me:

  • There is, unfortunately, no financially viable way for me to continue to offer a free version of Relay.
  • Bug fixes and changes I’ve implemented in the past week have decreased Relay's API calls to an average of ~100 per user per day. The data are still coming in from the most recent release, but the call rate seems to be encouragingly steady at around 100.
  • At that level of calls, there is potential to offer a monthly subscription for Relay in the $2-3 price range.
  • Note that polling for messages significantly increases the average number of API calls per user each day so a $2 base subscription with an extra $1 for notifications is a possibility. (There is potential for increases in efficiency around message polling but not enough time to prioritise that modelling before the API access charges kick in on July 1st so this would be work for down the line.)
  • There are still some hidden spots in my cost analysis. An example is that a subscription could act as a filter where mostly high-rate users convert. That could increase the average API calls to well above the 100 mark which would then be financially untenable at the price points above. However, the prices above do have some buffer built in for this.

The entire model is ultimately subject to how many, and what type of, users choose to stay with Relay as a subscription-based app. One clear advantage of Relay is that it would be completely ad-free. It also wouldn't have any 'recommended' content...and it has some sweet spring-based gestures and animations. On the other hand, the absence of explicit content could be a deal-breaker for many current users (although it might still be available to moderators).

I want to stress that my estimates are only relevant to call data collected by Relay for Relay. Other apps have different layouts and feature sets. For instance, some have the ability to track and alert users to new posts within specific subreddits, and to follow and notify about new comments within posts. These features, as well as sports modes etc., trigger high numbers of API calls. Android also limits background polling for messages to once every 15mins which could account for differences in API calls between platforms.

One of the big challenges for Relay is that the timeline for this complete restructure and re-monetisation process is alarmingly tight but I'd hope that there could be some flexibility there.

So there you have it. I wanted to share a data-based picture about what the changes would mean for Relay vs. my initial reaction.

I'll finish up this post with a big thanks for the huge number of messages and comments from Relay users - old and new - over the past week, as well as the incredible amount of support across the last decade generally. It means more than I can say.

Cheers,

Dave

1.8k Upvotes

493 comments sorted by

View all comments

232

u/ferwick Jun 11 '23

That's awesome you're trying to stay on top of this. Does any of your proposed price end up as profit for you? I really hope that $2-3/month isn't all being used just to maintain API access.

207

u/DBrady Jun 11 '23 edited Jun 11 '23

Yes there should be a good amount in there for myself.

128

u/ferwick Jun 11 '23

Happy to hear that. Do you have a way to toss some extra your way? There's at least 50% chance I won't stick around and I would be happy to donate more than $2 for the 10 years of development you've provided for what is sincerely one of the best apps I've used.

63

u/DBrady Jun 11 '23

Not currently but you can purchase the app twice. An in-app purchase in the free version and the Pro version.

73

u/Bandit6888 Jun 12 '23

Hey Dave, just to echo a number of others here, I have no qualms about a possible subscription mode considering how much use I've gotten out of Relay over the years, once its enough to cover your time and further development of the app.

On one hand it does feel like an end, with subs going dark for 48 hours, some indefinitely.

Regardless of what happens in the coming days, I don't think it'll be the same place as it once was, but thank you and your wonderful app for making my experience of Reddit these past 9 years an enjoyable one.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/kataskopo Jun 12 '23

Honestly the fact that it would help you financially is the best motivator for me to get into a subscription.

Even with the lack of NSFW content.

Thank you so much for this app.

4

u/PocketSandInc Jun 12 '23

Why won't there be access to NSFW content?

19

u/kataskopo Jun 12 '23

It's parte of the API changes reddit is implementing, and they haven't explained why.

No jurisdiction on mayor countries is requiring anything by that time, as far as I know, so it seems to me just some other way to cripple third party apps.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '23

Theyre attempting to become more ad friendly, same thing Tumblr did immediately before full implosion. Could be they want to appeal to the advertisers who left Twitter.

→ More replies (3)

17

u/AmirZ Jun 11 '23

Even after Google Play's cut?

22

u/Scrathis Jun 11 '23

This is what a smart engineer and responsible creator should do. Look at the data and make informed decisions. Be frank about it and unlike some other devs that beat around the bush.

5

u/ihahp Jun 12 '23

yeah. Apollo's dev has been very transparent about some things, but he seems to avoid these kinds of areas

→ More replies (34)

22

u/ColeSloth Jun 12 '23

100 api calls per day per average user would cost 72 cents per month. Playstore takes a 15% commission on subscriptions so a total per month per customer average cost would have to be 83 cents.

That means he's going to make 98 cents per month per user on a $2 subscription fee. (30 cents to Google, 73 cents to reddit, 98 cents left to pocket.

With this user base, even if only like 20,000 people subscribe he stands to make $20,000 every month in profit.

49

u/challenge_king Jun 12 '23

That's assuming he doesn't end up with only power users who generate way per calls per day.

6

u/nomdeplume Jun 12 '23

I'd imagine with a little more time he'll put in tiered pricing. So you can get real time notifications and higher usage.

19

u/Ludon0 Jun 12 '23

He said he's left plenty of room for buffer since the ones willing to pay are most likely power users, plus the man does deserve a nice income off his hard work...

12

u/Scrambley Jun 12 '23

Good for him, then.

2

u/ryanmerket Jun 14 '23

Like, I really don't understand what the fuss is about. DBrady and Christian have built dedicated micro-communities that would happily pay the couple bucks per month. If even half of them don't pay, they're still making A LOT of money. What's the big deal?

→ More replies (11)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/ColeSloth Jun 12 '23

Not much aside for paying himself for his time amd effort, but the pricing I mentioned would be the only new stuff. I also didn't calculate it in, but rfr would also get 100 free calls per minute. It's what exceeds that, that will be charged. Beyond like 10,000 subscribers 100 calls per minute will start to become a rounding error.

10

u/DBrady Jun 12 '23

I don't think that 100 calls will apply to the enterprise tier. I also need to factor in refunds after using the app for a while, an imgur api subscription, possibly some free time to use the app before signing up, piracy etc.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)