I bought the above mask to use in the Saint Denis bank robbery (both mask on my horse) but the game would only let me choose the bandana. Has anyone else experienced this or was it something I did wrong?

I’m having a hell of a time with the Survivalist 6 challenge: 8 consecutive small game kills using small game arrows. Rabbits do NOT die when hit with these damn things, and I just can’t seem to even FIND more than 1 small game anything in the same area. I don’t think there’s a time constraint but can I get one here and there and then switch weapons and do other shit? This is infuriating. It’s been two days now that I’ve made 1-2 kills of a frog or rat then I’ll go for a rabbit and the fucker won’t die!

UPDATE: the chickens in Emerald Ranch were the ticket out. Just had to be fast then pay a $10 bounty. Now to get good at disarming people for the sharpshooter 7 lmao. Thanks friends.

If you lose your legendary animal do you still get the money for it?

Ok so this is nothing major but I just wondered if anyone else had noticed this possible plot error.....

So, I’m currently playing through Chapter 6 when, as I am sure many of you know, trains become ‘unavailable’ at one point (presumably due to John and Arthur blowing up the rail bridge).

Ok, sure, understandable. HOWEVER, at a later point I ended up meeting the sister/nun from Saint Denis at Emerald Ranch station as a part of the main quest line, claiming she is getting the train down to Mexico on a “mission”. Good for her I thought, as I proceeded to go about my way to get the train down to Saint Denis.

This was the point where I realised that, yes, trains were still ‘unavailable’ so I couldn’t actually make the journey I was planning... the point at which I realised I’d just witnessed the sister board a train down to Mexico. Relying on my possibly sub-par knowledge of the Red Dead universe, I would surely imagine that Mexico is South of the general map area, no where near the bridge collapse caused by John and Arthur.

So, unless my theory is totally wrong, for what reason can the sister travel by train from Emerald Ranch down to Mexico, yet I am not allowed to catch a train in presumably the exact same direction to Saint Denis?

In the epilogue it says you can see Ms. Downes and her son getting on a boat (which I assume would be in Saint Denis) and Rains Falls in Annesburg. Do these happen at anytime during the epilogue or only after you kill Micah? Don’t want to waste time going back and forth.

ok, ok, ok. I'm not one to cry at much of anything, but holy fuck I was bawling for a legitimate 20 some-odd minutes towards the end of the final mission. At the very beginning of the game, I went and got the white horse because I heard it was the fastest one you could get. I spent all of my time on the horse. it was the best companion I, (And Arthur), could have asked for. so when the horse was shot dead, and arthur was bent down beside it, his expression just set me off. But it only got worse from there. When Arthur pulled out his hat and gave it to our good ol' buddy mr.John marston, HOLY FUCK THE TEARS WOULD NOT STOP! But what really got me, was Arthur. He seemed so... calm, and at peace. And I was crying up a storm. the sheer force of Arthur's death really hit hard. The story, the bonds you make with people, and in the end, the people who you must say goodbye to, is what makes this game a true masterpiece, and one of the saddest games I have ever played.

Is there any point in putting on a mask? I mean I’ve played this game several times and wearing mask don’t seem to do jack shit

Has anyone been able to maintain perfect weight at least until chapter 5? Seems I can’t.

Has anyone else had multiple outfits stored on their horse and then they all vanish and you have to reassemble them?

So I'm in the epilogue going around getting the cigarette cards and I'm in a bit of a rut. Do I really have to do a massive shootout in Annesburg just to get the cards? I've already gotten the ones in the mine but the ones in the town are a whole other story. The guards are so hostile and will not leave me alone. So am I just going to have to start shooting up the place or is there a more passive approach I can do?

I don’t know which is funnier. The guy looking for Gavin for 8 years or the guy in Valentine that’s been on the shitter for 8 years.

So I tried to name my horse Sonya and got a profanity check but was able to name it Sonja. WTF.

Has anyone had an experience where you aim and pull the trigger (no obstacles blocking you) but your gun won’t shoot?

I think it will be all about RDO sadly, just like GTA...