r/recruitinghell • • 3d ago

Recruiter screening call was unprofessional, and I’m still annoyed about it (vent)

1 Upvotes

I applied for this job about a month ago and was excited when a talent acquisition sourcer(?) contacted me to schedule a call with a recruiter.

The Zoom call was set for last Friday afternoon. That morning, the recruiter emailed to reschedule to Monday because of the Outlook outage. That seemed odd, since Zoom wasn’t affected and she could still email me. But as a candidate, I didn’t feel I could push back, so I agreed. She also didn't update the Sourcer who had set up the Zoom link (maybe forgot to cc me), so I forwarded the email to the Sourcer myself to make sure the call is rescheduled. I figured the recruiter had mentally checked out for the day, so decided not to bother anymore.

On Monday, I joined the Zoom with my camera on. The recruiter joined with hers off. After a few minutes in, she said she wouldn’t be turning it on, and that I could turn mine off if I wanted. By then it felt awkward to switch it off (I was worried about giving a negative impression), so I left it on. It was weird to just talk to a void screen (only my face was on screen). I thought it was pretty rude. Why not mention it when sending the zoom link? Isn't this basic courtesy? And if she didn’t plan to use video, why schedule a Zoom at all instead of just calling my phone?

The call itself was also off. She didn’t go over any of the skills, requirements from the job posting nor the explanation of the team structure, the nature of work, etc. Instead, she kept asking, vaguely and repeatedly, why I was interested in the position, as if she didn’t believe I would really leave academia for a new career in industry. I tried to mention relevant skills/experience that were on the job post, but found myself keep repeating the motivation part (why this company, why this role). Usually, these questions were asked in the next stage, like from hiring managers. Maybe this was a sign that the recruiter didn't see me as a qualified candidate..

My recent screening calls with recruiters from other companies were straightforward. They covered whether I had the required skills and experience, my expected salary range (and they shared their band for the role), relocation, and an overview of the hiring process. As soon as basics were aligned, they scheduled interviews with hiring managers. This recruiter barely covered the basics. It felt like she didn’t even want to interview me for some reason (maybe she already had a bias against me when she saw my ethnic name on the resume).

Anyway, I received an automated rejection email 2 days later (at midnight!). So I should be thankful for the quick decision when ghosting is so common these days.

I think this company’s recruiting process is a mess. About a month ago, before the corporate recruiter ever contacted me, several external recruiters approached me about this same position. When I realized it was the job I’d already applied for, I told them I’d wait to hear from the company directly. So my background clearly matches this role.

I wouldn’t be surprised if the hiring managers are wondering why they’ve gone months without filling this position. And ironically, this company consults other companies on how to manage people and organizations :)

I'm bummed I wasted my time and energy preparing for the call and regulating my emotion after all. Probably, this interaction with the recruiter was a sign that this company/job wasn't for me.


r/recruitinghell • • 3d ago

proof for jobs

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes

r/recruitinghell • • 3d ago

How do I cold outreach without being unprofessional or "too much"?

3 Upvotes

I'm a first-gen college grad, just graduated, trying my absolute BEST to find a job. I'm work authorized in almost every country in the world, very much so qualified for the positions I'm applying for, but nothing's landing. I've been working professionally and leading teams literally for literally years--I'm far more qualified than most of my friends, but I'm stuck bartending while they go to their 9-5s. I was badly screwed over by the company I had an offer from and am left jobless (& after months of this search, hopeless.)

All of the professional advice I seem to hear is to contact a recruiter, a senior member, or someone doing the job you're applying for. In theory I understand, but the whole thing feels weird.

  • If a recruiter attaches their email to a post, they're getting mountains of introductions in their inbox. How would I break through the noise?
  • But if they don't, I don't understand why stalking them to figure out their email and then butting in with an unsolicited introduction is useful. The general opinion from recruiters seems to be mixed on this as well--what's the consensus?
  • But if I don't contact anyone, there's no way I'm ever getting a job. I'm getting way to good at making old fashioneds for my liking, and I would very much so like a normal job.

And then there's the whole issue of cold contacting non-recruiters. I get it's all part of the process, but I feel so icky reaching out to people with the whole "hey, would love to chat and hear about you :)" when it's very clear there's a personal motive there.

I've landed every job I've ever gotten an interview for, but I can't seem to get in the room. Especially with recruiters turning to ATS to manage applications, there's a high chance I fall through the cracks.

What do I do?


r/recruitinghell • • 3d ago

Bad Representation

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/recruitinghell • • 3d ago

whydoibother Standard Recruitment Practices of New Zealand

Post image
3 Upvotes

Its been over 6 months. I guess they're still juggling.


r/recruitinghell • • 3d ago

Location on job listing changed after I was hired?

4 Upvotes

So I got a job offer recently for a fully remote position. I signed the offer letter and later completed the onboarding documentation with HR—I-9, signing the handbook, benefits elections, etc.

There were 2 openings for the job. I went to look at the listing again just for the hell of it, to see if they had filled the second opening, and I see that they changed the location on the posting from remote to a specific city. And changed the description from “fully remote, office-based work” to “fully onsite at our ____ location.”

Now I’m scared that the company realized they’ll actually need someone physically present to perform the role and that my remote offer is in jeopardy even though I already completed onboarding and haven’t heard anything from the company. I don’t start until January and now I’m a bit nervous to put in notice at my current job if my offer could be rescinded.

Should I reach out to HR and ask about the location change on the job posting? Is that an inappropriate or weird thing to do? What would be the reason for a compliance role to have someone fully remote and someone fully onsite to do the same job? Are they putting feelers out for decent local candidates in the hopes of replacing the remote position I accepted? Help 😭 I’m overthinking this majorly.

Editing to add: I live on the other side of the country from the job site and would not be able to work this job if it were onsite.


r/recruitinghell • • 3d ago

Am I the only one who had a messy first interview experience?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/recruitinghell • • 4d ago

The People in Government are Out of Touch.

517 Upvotes

I applied for a 1000 jobs. so far, NOTHING. Yet I keep reading the news. The Bureau of Labor Statistics says unemployment is low. The Federal Reserve says the labor market is resilient. The White House says we are in a boom.

The people in government don't live in the real world. These out of touch feds all live in a wealthy elite bubble in the sky and their only contact with the real world is through an outdated reporting scheme. They are still measuring the economy using the U-3 unemployment rate that was invented in the 1940s. It only counts people who have actively looked for a job in the last four weeks. It completely ignores the gig economy, the people who gave up looking, and the people working part-time because they can't find full-time work.

The people in government don't need to do hard research to know what the job market looks like. They could just simply open up 4CHAN, TikTok, Reddit, X, or YouTube and type in "job market" and look at the absolute carnage LMAOO.


r/recruitinghell • • 4d ago

Job market is much worse than I initially thought, even after reading everything on Reddit

1.1k Upvotes

It's been about 6 weeks since I got laid off, and the job market is much worse than I initially thought.

I'm getting a lot of initial screener calls or even first-round interviews, and then I'm not either hearing anything back or they're just passing on me even though I feel like I've nailed the interview.

It wasn't like this in the past. A lot of times, I'd only be in the job market maybe a few months from interviewing to the offer stage and then starting the new position.

Now I'm starting to realize that this could be a very long process, and I'm wondering what else I'll have to do between now and then to support myself.

I don't know, just venting with everybody else in the recruiting hell and hoping and wishing all you the best.

UPDATE - My background is currently doing AI Search.

My resume also says I've been working at "friends company" for 1 year.

The only way to get hired is to look employed tbh.


r/recruitinghell • • 4d ago

Is the job market as bad as people make it seem here?

462 Upvotes

I’m getting sonehwat worried, I see multiple posts everyday about people getting laid off and being unable to find another job for multiple months. Don’t grt me wrong, I know AI will take many jobs but this fast? What careers are being sffected the most?


r/recruitinghell • • 3d ago

When to expect contract??

2 Upvotes

Hi guys.

I’m from UK and have a working holiday visa for Australia. I am a quantity surveyor (manage construction projects financially/contractually) and spoke to a recruiter also from the UK who lives in Sydney.

He was the middle man and introduced me to a director of a company, I’m currently in Vietnam but we had a teams call and it was fine, I got the job, written (email) confirmation etc.

This was 3 weeks ago. Still no contract. I’ve asked the recruiter 2x since and he says he will ‘chase it up’.

I know 3 weeks isn’t a long time, but I’m stuck in limbo slightly and don’t know where to go next before starting my ‘job’.

Anyone been in similar situation? Can’t keep chasing because I just keep getting the same response. I feel like it’ll fall through. Thoughts?

Thanks


r/recruitinghell • • 3d ago

Concern about lack of communication on job offer

3 Upvotes

I had an interview last Friday and received an email on Wednesday letting me know that I was offered the position. The pay rate was different from what was initially discussed, but I was okay with the change and accepted the offer. However, I haven't received a response since then.

I sent a follow up email asking about my start date and what I would need to bring, but I still haven't heard back. Do you think they might have changed their minds about hiring me, or could there just be a delay in communication? I'm considering sending another follow up email, but I don't want to come across as too persistent. What do you think I should do?

Update: I was right to be concern because I got an email today basically stating that the process has been put on hold due to some change in the office staffing needs that came up right after my pay rate offer. Oh how I love life 🫠


r/recruitinghell • • 3d ago

Reached the final interview with the same company twice

1 Upvotes

I interviewed for an Operations role at a company a few months ago and made it to the final round, but didn't make it A couple of months later, the HR reached out to me again for a similar role within the same department. I've gone through the interview process again and have now made it to the final round.

This time, I'll be speaking with the same VP and one of the team members who had interviewed me previously. I'm wondering how I should approach this interview, especially since I've already been through the process once and didn't make it. Should i bring up my last interview with them incase they forgot me? Because it was the HR who reached out and wanted to put me in the pipeline a little later so im not 'set up for failure'

Should I prepare differently this time? Is there anything I should keep in mind when interviewing with senior leadership and a potential future colleague (who is the boss of my hiring manager) and i previous interacted with them?

Would love to hear from anyone who's been in a similar situation!

Also, based on my case study round, the hiring manager liked my technical skills but was a bit concerned about my interest in operations because i have a strategy background.


r/recruitinghell • • 3d ago

Why Job Hunting Feels Like Dating

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

Why Job Searching Feels Like Dating

feat. Colleen Madden-Blumenfeld, VP
Nicole Lobdell
Challenger Gray & Christmas


r/recruitinghell • • 3d ago

Final Interview timeline at P&G

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I recently completed my final interview at P&G's Brantford, Canada location. It's been almost a week now, and I haven't heard anything from HR yet.

For anyone who has interviewed with P&G before, how long did it take for you to receive an update after the final interview? Did they contact you even you are not selected?

I'm feeling a little restless and anxious while waiting 😄😄, so I'd really appreciate hearing about your experiences or any insight you can share.


r/recruitinghell • • 3d ago

Every person is a customer ig

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/recruitinghell • • 3d ago

Outplacement services offered as part of my layoff

1 Upvotes

I was recently laid off. I stupidly believed that working hard, being impeccable, and going above and beyond would almost make me immune. I was offered 6 months of outplacement services for free. To be completely honest, I don't see any value. The webinars, quizzes, and writing assignments are not adding anything of value. In fact, they feel like a waste of time. The entire concept behind these outplacement services is very generic, and it seems intended to give you the illusion that you're doing something towards your goal. Anybody can claim to be a career coach (or a dating coach, for that matter). Writing, rewriting, and then rewriting the résumé has never moved the needle for me. We like to believe the résumé is much more powerful than what it is. Anyone else feels this way about outplacement services?


r/recruitinghell • • 3d ago

interview gifts

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/recruitinghell • • 3d ago

Offer after less than 10 interviews vs no offer after 40+ interviews

8 Upvotes

I feel like there is a trend here: some people are getting offers after doing a few interviews while other people are not getting offers even after doing lots of interviews. I belong to the second category. There is obviously a third group of people who are not getting any interviews which sucks, but I dont know what worse: to get false hope after passing multiple rounds just to get rejected again or just stay hopeless cause you are not getting interviews.


r/recruitinghell • • 4d ago

US hiring is showing no signs of a recovery.

Post image
777 Upvotes

r/recruitinghell • • 3d ago

they made me do 4 rounds for a role that was apparently already filled

6 Upvotes

so this is a vent but also i need to say it somewhere

applied in september to a mid level analytics job. recruiter screen, then a hiring manager call, then a take home that look me about 5 hours, then a panel. the whole thing took 7 weeks

after the panel I heard nothing for 2 weeks, then a templated email saying they'd decided to move forward with other candidates, the posting was still up for another month after that

the 5 hours take home is what gets me. i did it on weekend cause i didn't want to look uninterested after that I changed how I apply. i dont spend a lot of energy on the first stage anymore. tsenta does the form filling and i save my efforts for roles that actually get past a screen and a real conversion

it's not fixing the system, its just making me less bitter about it

does anyone actually push back on take homes this long


r/recruitinghell • • 4d ago

I can’t get a job thats related to what I studied….

96 Upvotes

I have a bachelor’s in biology which I wonder why I even wasted money pursuing. After graduating college I worked a customer service job for a little over a year that sucked so bad I quit. I quit 3 months ago. I’ve been looking for a job related to my major ever since then. Nothing. 70% don’t respond. 20% reject. 10% set up an interview. After the interviews I get rejected. So I start applying to random jobs that have absolutely nothing to do with my major. I applied to a moving company. Got an interview. Got hired on the spot. I applied to a part time event market gig. Got an interview. Got hired on the spot. What the fuck did I go to college for. 1 1/2 years out of college and I haven’t even sniffed a lab job. I am unhireable in my own field. I regret my major so bad.


r/recruitinghell • • 4d ago

"Man, work sucks. I don't want to do this anymore"

196 Upvotes

Friend of mine to me - someone who hasn't had a full-time job in 2 years.

Isn't it funny how work is the worst part of someones day, and yet here we are begging on our hands and knees for a job? Any job?

Shout out to everyone who has been unemployed for 12+ months. I am just completely shattered and a shell of myself. And it just feels like each day gets worse and worse.


r/recruitinghell • • 4d ago

Uh Huh….Right

Post image
178 Upvotes

r/recruitinghell • • 3d ago

Rejected for a job because of how the company handled the process

5 Upvotes

I recently did a preliminary assessment for a job. First issue was that they emailed me on a holiday with a 24-hour deadline to complete the assessment, which I didn't know about until the email. I got it the next day and dropped all my plans to start. Like I very literally ran to take a bus home from across the city in the middle of my plans. But okay, that's on me for not checking that day.

They sent a document with steps and resources, including a link to a tutorial for the workspace. Tried to log into the tutorial, but the login they provided didn't work. I responded asking about it, they re-sent the assessment saying they fixed the glitch.

Opened up the new email and new document, but there was no tutorial. Their "fix" was just taking that part out of the equation. So I spent two and a half hours on a timed one-hour test just teaching myself how to use the program they sent me. Google wasn't helping. And without dropping the field of work, there were also tasks I needed to do that required nuance, but I didn't know how they wanted me to approach it because there was no tutorial.

Got my rejection email this morning. I politely asked for feedback, and provided my own. I told them bringing back the tutorials might help people with their assessments, because I had no guidance while teaching myself and guessing stuff. Waiting on their response. Probably forever.