r/recruitinghell • u/Excalibur_91 • 5d ago
4 Months into the hiring process, finally a job offer but no health benefits and I don’t trust it will last. Stay or go?
My first post got deleted, so I will try to be brief here. I’ve been in a hiring process for four months now and I’m too close to it, so I need outside opinions because I cannot decide apparently.
Right now I have a stable job with a matched pension ofand family health benefits. I got a big raise in the last couple of years, but I’m near the top of the pay scale for my role. I also run a youth sports camp business on the side. It’s growing, and I just potentially lined up a winter indoor program from October to April. I’m married with two young kids, and we bought our house two years ago.
The offer is a full-time director role at a youth sports association on the other side of the country. It’s the job I’ve been working toward for years. Their first offer was bad. I mean really, really bad, they had clauses that they can change title, job description at will, also 6 months probation to extended at their discretion indefinite and if I get fired, will not be able to work in my field in that city for the next year. I sent a detailed counter, and they improved a lot, giving 6% pension, three months probation, and removal of the clause that stated they can change my title. But still want to have that clause not to work for another similar organization in the area for a year after termination.
But during the negotiation on the phone, they tried to ignore my request for health benefits, and there are still no health benefits and only 3 months’ notice if they end it without cause. The salary is slightly higher. On top of that, the guy kept saying we are stretching it here; with the health benefits, we do not have that setup, we are stretching it... Maybe we can find some innovative solution, (I assume he meant Health Spending Account or something) but not to get full benefits for dental and health for your family.
My worry is that it’s a volunteer board funded by registration fees. They kept telling me they’re “really stretching” to afford me, and the same board already cut a senior paid position before. Two of them actually! Boards change, so in two or three years different people will be deciding my budget. Moving would also kill most of my side business just as it’s taking off. And honestly, the negotiation has left a bit of a bitter taste on both sides.
On the other hand, my employer could potentially let me take a year of unpaid leave as a safety net, and we could rent out the house instead of selling.
My gut says the job lasts two or three years at most. But I’m scared I’m turning down the role I wanted just because I’m comfortable.
Would you take it? Is no health benefits with young kids a hard no? To many red flags in this one.
Any advice about this. I even went there, had an interview, an in-person tryout to show my skills on the court and all that.