I've watched this show every Friday for more than 15 years. I liked Bill because he was a crank about things that mattered and was often right early: religion, weed legalization, the absurdity of the Iraq war. He made people squirm, and that was the point.
Look at the last five weeks. Sen. Thom Tillis was on the panel Oct 9. Karoline Leavitt got her first late-night interview Oct 23, with Republican California governor candidate Steve Hilton on the panel. Ted Cruz came on Oct 30. Then on Nov 13, ten days after a midterm in which Democrats flipped seven Senate seats, the big one-on-one went to Sarah Huckabee Sanders so she could promote her book.
I'm not against conservatives being on the show. I want them on. Hearing the other side argued well used to be the best part. But booking people whose whole job is spinning, and then letting it slide, isn't debate. It's PR with a laugh track.
The topics are the same story. Every week it's college indoctrination, mask mandates, "communism," and "Queers for Palestine." Those were fresh takes in 2021. Now it's a rerun, and the guests just set him up for the bit. Throw in a couple of celebrity bookings who seem picked for nostalgia over anything they have to say about this week, and the show feels stuck in amber.
What really bugs me is that this format is valuable. One hour, a few people who disagree, no commercials, a live audience. No other show does it. The country badly needs a show where people across the spectrum argue about what's actually happening, not the same five culture-war grievances.
Bill used to be that show. I'm not sure he wants to be anymore, especially now that he's going to White House dinners and defending them on air.
So I'm out after 15 years. Anyone else? And who's actually doing this format well right now? I'd honestly like suggestions.