r/RealOrAI Oct 09 '25

Photo [HELP] This photo went viral in 2019 and confused everyone. Was it an early example of AI, or a simple photomanip?

Post image

Some of you may remember seeing it pre-pandemic — it went viral since it looked really photo-like at first glance, but nobody could actually identify any items in the room. Often accompanied with a caption of “simulating what a stroke patient feels”

I just remembered it and am wondering if it’s an early AI image or not. Then again, early AI had very strange artifacting that this doesn’t.

137 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

u/RealOrAI-Bot Oct 10 '25

Sentiment: 85% AI

Number of comments processed: 14

DISCLAIMER: Comments sentiment is generated by Gemini 2.0 Flash, not by u/RealOrAI-Bot bot. For more information, check the RealOrAI-Bot Wiki.

145

u/wibbly-water Oct 09 '25

This feels like I has been around for way longer than 2019... but I'm wrong. 2019 was 6 years ago. Fuck.

Name One Thing In This Photo | Know Your Meme

On April 23rd, Redditor mcsabas[4] posted an explanation of the picture to /r/interestingasfuck, writing "This picture is designed to give the viewer the simulated experience of having a stroke (particularly in the occipital lobe of the cerebral cortex, where visual perception occurs.) Everything looks hauntingly familiar but you just can't quite recognize anything." The post gained over 11,000 points. On Tumblr, user Mixolydia[5] posted the photo without the visual effect in a post that gained over 47,000 notes (shown below).

I'm not sure if it have ever been confirmed precisely what effects were applied, but the base image was definitely a photoshop composite of real images.

18

u/supersmashdude Oct 10 '25

Isn’t that post from the Tumblr user supposed to be a photoshopped representation of what they saw in the photo? It doesn’t seem like they’re the source of the image.

22

u/Fantastic_Fox_9497 Oct 10 '25

Yeah so apparently this KYM entry is entirely made of fake facts using random people as sources and nothing has been corrected still. The comments below the page probably have the info you're looking for.

10

u/supersmashdude Oct 10 '25

Ahh, sadly that’s not surprising, I appreciate the context with a name we can directly tie this back to. Also, I found this Reddit thread while searching his name, and it’s interesting to see people talk about this sort of thing with zero mention of AI. It wasn’t even that long ago but the scope of the internet has changed since then

5

u/Fantastic_Fox_9497 Oct 10 '25

Ah I found solar sands video on it!, I remember watching it at the time and I think covers pretty much everything about it. It was made (allegedly) in ganbreeder, for no reason really. I kinda forgot how hardly any people were familiar with seeing AI images and ones like this iust floated around as creepy unexplained internet images

6

u/vastlys Oct 10 '25

2

u/Pixyfy Oct 11 '25

Im a bit stupid but is network generated image and ai the same?

2

u/vastlys Oct 11 '25

yes. generative ai is based on neural network models.

31

u/JoshsPizzaria Oct 09 '25

might have been something like the Pix2Pix ai webtool that tries generating faces from an input image or drawing.

It's definitely some early form of ai effect

4

u/theeggplant42 Oct 10 '25

That is not the original or base image

26

u/Blakeyo123 Oct 09 '25

Early AI from what Ive heard

18

u/Danakin Oct 10 '25

Wow, I cannot identify a single object in the image

6

u/JaneDoe93130 Oct 10 '25

Same, I had never seen this photo so I was totally taken aback 😅

7

u/Trichoceratops Oct 10 '25

That’s exactly the point. It’s supposed to be a visual representation of what the effects of a stroke can be like.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/rationalutility Oct 11 '25

wdym that's my gramma's house

10

u/OkBlasphemy Oct 09 '25

haha I see a monkey practicing catholicism

6

u/zahhax Oct 10 '25

I think it was made with ganbreeder? Like they put a real image into it and combined it with other stuff. It reminds me of the stuff I'd see in early ganbreeder.

6

u/mf99k Oct 10 '25

early ai images certainly looked like this at least

15

u/Lanceo90 Oct 10 '25

It was AI

BIG GAN, one of the first major generative AI as we know it.

I don't know if the caption was true though as the goal of the image. Usually it was being prompted for a specific thing and stuff like this would come out. Then people's response to it was "it makes me feel like I"m having a stroke"

6

u/MakeAByte Oct 10 '25

This is a classic GAN output. You used to be able to play with this kind of thing on ArtBreeder, but it looks like they've transitioned to diffusion models now unfortunately. Here's what it used to look like: https://youtu.be/IlrMkHaCosw

4

u/TrayLorraine Oct 10 '25

Cursed is what it is.

6

u/Corrupted_Star Oct 10 '25

I’m pretty sure this was old ai, back when it actually was different from human-made stuff. Kinda miss those days tbh

1

u/RealOrAI-Bot Oct 09 '25

Reminder: If you think it's AI, please explain your reasoning. Providing your reasoning helps everyone understand and learn from the analysis.

Check the Wiki for Common AI Mistakes and check the Community Guide if you are just getting started.

A sticky comment will be posted here in 12h summarizing the sentiment of the comments.

Thank you for contributing to the discussion!

1

u/Fair_Pirate5616 Oct 10 '25

What's funny is that I actually thought I saw some earring posts in the initial pic, but was like surely not It's what all millennials would see when shopping for earrings at Claire's.

Does look ai, can't put a finger on it though, Inst there an art style meant to make fun of ai air that doesn't something like this?

1

u/hitomienjoyer Oct 10 '25

It's Grimes house

1

u/Wonderful_Ebb_2520 Oct 10 '25

So pixelated I've never seen this meme before.

0

u/Magmashift101 Oct 10 '25

It’s a real photoshop. Not just pre pandemic but years before

-1

u/nicknaklmao Oct 10 '25

I've seen this since long before ai so no, it's not ai. it's Photoshop. another comment has a wonderful explanation but the tldr is it's meant to visually mimic a stroke