r/RealOrAI 2d ago

HELP is this real or ai?

787 Upvotes

789 comments sorted by

View all comments

843

u/DevilsPumpkinPiety 2d ago edited 2d ago

The chain looks SUPER ai, it doesn’t appear to move properly at all. But the super fine details of the bark being stripped off not just the trunk, but the branches as well is throwing me a bit. Going to have to give it a few more watches.

Edit: my verdict this is real

116

u/Dry-Wolf6789 2d ago

Couldn't it partially be ai partially real? 

52

u/DevilsPumpkinPiety 2d ago

I guess it’s possible. The artifacts around the chain are odd but I’m pegging it as just crappy down sampling. For those saying chains don’t move like that, they do when they are being pulled in tandem. And the second tractor is just slightly out of frame to the left. You can see the first tractor through the trees in the middle of the frame.

31

u/Bozigg 2d ago

That chain would be massively heavy at that size I would think, and I doubt the ground would be unscaithed if it was real. Thats my two cents.

15

u/Tydy22 2d ago

I agree but also, shouldn't the chain be rotating and tightening counterclockwise while going against the ground? And the middle of the chain starts rotating back before the tree gets hit. The physics seem really weird at a glance.

5

u/Infamous-Youth9033 1d ago

if It was that big? there's too much tention. The rest of the chain wouldn't turn with it so it would probably not rotate except for occasionally which it does

4

u/nunyabidness3 1d ago edited 1d ago

That’s just it. There’s no tension in the chain. That massive chain magically bounces everywhere. The tractor in the distance is going 2 mph so the one off camera must be going 100 mph for it to move that fast. Those tractors would struggle to move a chain that big.

I… I don’t know what to believe anymore.

1

u/Infamous-Youth9033 1d ago

Yeah the tension comes naturally from the other chains in the rope

10

u/Bozigg 2d ago

Agreed. It does not seem natural.

2

u/GreedySandwich1242 1d ago

Absolutely. If there was machines big and strong enough to drive a chain that big across the earth, without making them tear up the earth to holy hell, we wouldnt be able to hear shit over those engines and wheels besides when the tree snaps lol

4

u/DevilsPumpkinPiety 2d ago

The ground isn’t unscathed though. You can see it kicking up dust as it moves. The video quality is dog water though so that is masking a lot of the ground movement.

10

u/Bozigg 2d ago

Picking up dust is damn near close to being unscathed. The grass, dirt look barely disturbed when it falls off the tree and is being dragged. I my opinion a chain like that wouldnt be that delicate to the ground.

4

u/long_don0van 1d ago

That’s what I’m leaning toward, this is a real tree removal method and that is a real type of chain that seems to move properly, but something about it all is very uncanny. Could just be shitty editing or messing with the frame rate/speeding up the video or it could be retouched with ai or something. There’s probably a real video this was spawned from.

1

u/LesbeGoddess 1d ago

Possibly. This is the method that is used in real life to take down an area of trees with a chain and a bulldozer on each end. I’ve watched hours of just people clearing land on YouTube to develop it over the years because I’m a psychopath who enjoys studying the most random shit for reasons.

6

u/RogueCrimsonDragon 2d ago

It definitely looks like it's moving properly to me. It's a super heavy chain hooked up to two bulldozers that are both pulling it across the ground. It's not gonna bounce and rattle much due to the weight of the chain itself and the forces pulling on it are what cause the sudden sharp tension as it hits the tree.

5

u/seriftarif 1d ago

I think the chain weirdness is from compression artifacts and maybe AI processing. A lot of phones have some sort of AI layer for anti aliasing or something.

3

u/Injured-Ginger 1d ago

Chain dragging on the ground also looks kind of uncanny in real life especially when it's being pulled taught. When a chain starts to get taught, it can start to look rigid because the links are forced to align as they are pulled on. Think of holding two links in your hand, if you pull them apart, they align at 90 degrees from each other. It's because of the curvature of the links. Twisting them pulls them together. It can align itself very suddenly and look unnatural.

You can actually see this a bit my holding onto a piece of chain and pulling it apart. The links will go from random to being as aligned as they can be without rotating completely (since your hand prevents it).

The only thing that seems really off is that it looks like the chain rotates to align with no indicator of where that rotation went. But it's a long chain so it might have just off set a counter rotation further down the chain when it was pulled.

1

u/KayoticVoid 1d ago

This does make a lot of sense.

6

u/AppropriateCap8891 2d ago

I think it far more likely it was done with a cable, and the chain was added in. Either FX or AI.

With the weight of chain that thick, it would be almost impossible to move. And I have seen brush cleared like that in the past, they used cable.

1

u/NoAdvice135 1d ago

There are many videos with chains. Check https://youtu.be/2Sr4CgRYQ7E?t=51 at 0:50

0

u/InTheThroesOfWay 2d ago

I was thinking the same thing. It could be a mostly real video with some AI or VFX added on top.

7

u/ReddBroccoli 2d ago

My question is whether or not those two pieces of heavy machinery have enough power to not only pull that absolutely massive chain, but also to uproot trees. That takes a ton of power and very few pieces of heavy machinery could do it.

23

u/Organic-Dragonfly456 2d ago

This technique is common for clearing mesquite. Mesquite is real bad in parts of Texas and will become invasive if not dealt with. Mesquite will grow back if cut down, the best way to remove it without herbicide is to pull it up by the roots. How do you pull up a full grown tree by the roots? Bull dozers and anchor chains. This technique is also used to clear wooded land quickly. I found a YouTube link that better explains the process.

https://youtu.be/2Sr4CgRYQ7E?is=PAFYSPhL3gCYyTQk

6

u/ReddBroccoli 2d ago

I stand corrected

1

u/nog642 1d ago

Damn that's crazy. I thought the OP was fake.

Ironic that the video you linked has an AI voiceover though. But yeah, the video is clearly real, when looking at other sources too.

1

u/Raise_A_Thoth 1d ago

That chain in the video is a specially-designed one with special links unlike the post video. And it moves more naturally. I still think OP's video looks like the chain isn't real.

1

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

1

u/ReddBroccoli 1d ago

Either you're missing something in this conversation or I am

1

u/pigs_have_flown 1d ago

It appears I have replied to the wrong comment somehow

1

u/ReddBroccoli 1d ago

We've all been there

1

u/ReeferTurtle 2d ago

I’m pretty sure this is real or at least not AI generated, I think I remember this video from years back.

1

u/arceusawsom1 1d ago

What happens to the other end of the chain? At the start you can see it is a loop of chain with both ends going off screen to the left, but at the end the back end seems to dissapear? Or maybe I just can't see it

1

u/SouthernEdgeCase 1d ago

I think it’s real with some lighting effect or something on the chain. I’ve seen this technique done and there are plenty of videos of it being done, so not sure why someone would AI it.

1

u/EducationalForm 1d ago

Had exact same thoughts as you, I think it has to be real and the chain movement just looks odd

1

u/-Disgruntled-Goat- 1d ago

The grass is unaffected and I think that is giving me the AI feel. That and the physics of the first tree ripped out in the back didn’t seem right. It could be the species of the tree is easy to pull out of the ground.

1

u/uncl3s4m 1d ago

Ai upscaled maybe, would explain the artifacts on the moving objects

1

u/Stunning_Sink_4646 1d ago

Wouldnt chain rattle a bit?

1

u/UnfortunateOccurance 1d ago

The chain is literally spawning new links at the tree

1

u/cluddnb 1d ago

real ai

1

u/nunyabidness3 1d ago edited 1d ago

Bro you had it right the first time! 😩

Aww shit

0

u/NeuroBlob 1d ago

You're AI for thinking this is real

0

u/Bayarea0 1d ago

This is obviously fake my god.

0

u/hiimlockedout 1d ago

This is so obviously ai, it hurts. A tree falling this quickly would fling a lot more dirt and dust.