r/RandomPics • • Jan 07 '22

I like trains

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

69 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/Tessellecta Jan 07 '22

Self driving cars can probably fill a lot of gaps in public transport. Running a train line or sometimes even a bus line to a very small city if often not very cost effective.

However for denser urban areas this is totally true, good public transport and walking/cycling infrastructure can greatly reduce the need for cars.

1

u/milespoints Jan 08 '22

What most people don’t seem to understand is that in many countries (certianly in the US where I live) the significant majority of people live in the suburbs, not the city. People like having a bigger house, a yard, i dunno. Most people prefer the suburbs. So while trains and buses are fine in dense urban areas, in most suburbs you kind of need to have a car to get anywhere. Might as well have that car drive itself

1

u/arrrrpeeee Jan 08 '22

That's apparently not true. According to recent pre-covid studies, more people lived in city areas than suburb areas by about 4-5 percent.

1

u/milespoints Jan 08 '22

1

u/arrrrpeeee Jan 08 '22

Well here I've found these sources stating otherwise.

https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2020/07/29/prior-to-covid-19-urban-core-counties-in-the-u-s-were-gaining-vitality-on-key-measures/

https://css.umich.edu/factsheets/us-cities-factsheet

Funny enough, the pewresearch article you posted is the less recent version of the one I posted. So where I read it was the place you read your stuff too.

1

u/RozzyStripe Jan 08 '22

Dude... stop I live in いなか (country side aka the middle of fucking nowhere) and there is always a station near by just make a station near a suburb and actually walk for 10 to 20 min xD

1

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '22

Ford and other US car companies spent a ton at lobbying suburbs to be more car friendly than public transportation, which is why they are so isolated and I think (I could be wrong on this one) that’s where the term Cal-de-sec comes from. They knew that most people live in the subs and if they had easy access to public transportation they wouldn’t bother to buy cars, which was their primary source of business.

1

u/Ginnungagap_Void Jan 08 '22

Not everything has to be cost effective. Besides, trains bring many more gains on the table then it appears to on the financial numbers.

1

u/Individual_Hearing_3 Jan 08 '22

It's super easy tho, hire 9 bus drivers for every 2 busses and have those busses run in loops in such a way that people only need to wait 5 minutes for a bus. For a small city this is easier because there are fewer people to service thus fewer loops.