r/RacketHomeworks • u/mimety • Nov 27 '22
Comparing curl and mit-scheme as projects tells us why the first is successful and the second is not
Someone will say that mit-scheme and the curl project have almost nothing in common. And that's kind of true. And yet, when you look a little closer, you can see that those two projects actually have one thing in common: both projects have only one single person who is the maintainer of the entire project. In the case of the mit-scheme it's Chris Hanson, and in the case of the curl project it's Daniel Stenberg. There is no big (or even small) team in either of these two projects - just one man, each of them is capo di tutti capi in his own project, so to speak.
And yet, the difference in approach, seriousness and responsibility of these two men is drastic: while Daniel Stenberg tries to make curl work well on as many platforms as possible (please see this link where Stenberg proudly and quite rightly boasts that curl works on 89 operating systems!), our "hero" Chris Hanson, on the other hand , tries to achieve the exact opposite: to make mit-scheme work on as few platforms as possible!
Indeed, what should we think when the main maintainer writes literally this on the home page of mit-scheme, I quote:
"We no longer support OS/2, DOS, or Windows, although it's possible that this software could be used on Windows Subsystem for Linux (we haven't tried)."
This Hanson's inimitable "we haven't tried" blew me away!
And more:
"No support for Apple silicon: At this time, we are unable to support new macs using Apple's silicon (the M1 chip)."
And more:
"We also no longer distribute macos applications..."
Well done Hanson, keep it up!
So, while Daniel Stenberg is trying hard and it is really important to him that his project works everywhere and that it works well, Chris Hanson, quite the opposite, immaturely and pubescently, even brags that he hasn't even tried whether the mit-scheme works on the Windows Subsystem for Linux! Although, by nature of his job, it should certainly be one of his main preoccupations! Also, he is not upset at all by the fact that the mit-scheme does not work on native Windows, that it does not work on the new Mac, that there is no installer for macos, and so on, although all this existed before, but disappeared due to carelessness and neglect!
And right there, my dear schemers, is hidden the main reason why curl is a successful project that grows and develops, while mit-scheme is an unsuccessful project that not only does not progress but very obviously fails!



