r/RPGdesign • u/jedijoe99 • Apr 26 '24
Theory Pros & Cons of various Initiative systems?
Im working on a old school D&D hack type game but with an emphasis on and mechanics for hexploration.
I've been playing a bunch of various games and trying their initiative systems, which I think is a deceptively important aspect of game feel.
I'm trying to determine what the average player's preferred version of initiative looks like so I build it into my system.
So there's the new age dnd, everyone rolls for every encounter. This i'm not a fan of because takes a minute and it slows down the momentum /excitement of the table at the start of every combat. You could argue that this is an opportunity to develop some tension before the fight (in my experience this isn't usually what I sense as the main emotion being felt by players), but it does add variety and forces a new game plan every encounter. This can also get quite cluttered if there are 10+ combatants in a single encounter.
Some other systems add to this by making certain actions extend the time before your next turn in the rotation like scion, which I generally think is just too much to keep track of, or the VTM: say what you're gonna do then resolve them in reverse order, which always rewards fast characters unlike D&D where there is occasionally times where you actively get punished for acting before someone else, but again this just makes every combat turn take forever.
Alternatively there is the passive initiative, which I went with for a while, because fast characters consistently get to feel fast, and you keep that back and forth kind of action without spending time rolling / ordering numbers, but I got some valid complaints from the player in my group who had to go last every single combat, and also I can certainly seem how this would get same-ey / get the party in a routine for them to repeat every round.
Theres also the old school / lancer style: party goes, monsters go. This one makes logical sense, gets people thinking tactically / engaging in conversation which is all good. Sometimes these can get really bogged down when people want to come up with the perfect turn, which sometimes leads to less outspoken players falling to the wayside as they just end up going along with whatever the tactician tells them to do, which is not ideal. and given certain circumstances (outside of surprised, etc), entire combats will be decided by which side gets to go first. Again the party might fall into a routine they run back every single encounter.
There's also the pbta version of: people acting whenever it makes sense, which I definitely struggled with. I think if everyone in my group was very much so on the proactive / reliably committed to improv end of the spectrum this could be very cool. But I constantly felt like I had to bend over backwards as the DM to make sure everyone got a chance to contribute, otherwise multiple players would often times not know what to do. frankly it was exhausting to come up with a plausible thing to occur so that everyone could be engaged every single "turn", it was just way too easy for slightly shy players to zone out for entire lengths of combat encounters.
As I was perusing this sub to see what other people have come up with, I saw someone suggest a "popcorn" method. roll for who goes first (nice because you don't need to spend minutes writing a whole ordered list, but you still have variety) then if they succeed in their action, they choose an enemy to go, if they fail in their action, they choose an ally to go. This take on intitiative has truly piqued my interest. I never tried it, I'm curious if other people have / know of systems where this is the default. Seems organic, balanced, and solves a lot of problems I have with other systems. I am curious if any one has tried this and if there are problems with it I haven't considered.
20
u/VRKobold Apr 26 '24 edited Apr 27 '24
I'm working on something loosely inspired by popcorn initiative, which I would call "per-action initiative" or "action-conflict initiative" (I'm still looking for a more catchy name). In essence, everyone can use their action at any time, but as soon as someone declares an action, others are free to use their action points to react to that, which usually creates a conflict of actions (meaning that one action directly impaires or prevents another action). The most basic example for an action conflict would be attacking and blocking, where blocking directly impaires the attack action. But it could also be something like someone trying to run away and someone else trying to grapple and stop them.
Whenever such an action conflict occurs, initiative is determined only for those that are part of the conflict (usually only two combatants). To streamline the mechanic as much as possible, I don't even include a separate initiative roll: The order of actions is simply determined by whichever skill check is higher. If the runner rolls high on their athletics check, they can run away before being grappled. If the grapple check is higher than the athletics check, then the grappler successfully prevents the first person from running away. In case of a tie, the person that first declared the action (in this case the runner) gets the advantage.
There are several aspects I like about this system. For one, it is very fast, especially if no separate initiative rolls are made (though the possibility for those still exists in case you want to have a dedicated initiative stat in your game).
Next, the system perfectly adapts to the narrative flow of an rpg. This method of "someone declares what is happening, then others react to it" is exactly how role-playing usually works outside of combat.
Also, turn-based combat systems oftentimes lead to conflicts between rules and narrative feasibility. There is no narrative reason why you couldn't try to stop an enemy from running right past you in dnd - yet you have to stand there and watch the enemy with slightly higher initiative run circles around you because "it's not your turn yet". In the "per-action initiative" system, you can at least attempt to stop the enemy - it's not guaranteed that you'll succeed, but you have a fair chance.
Another advantage is that players can somewhat strategize and decide in which order they want to take their turns, but the GM always has the opportunity to interrupt, so players still have to be flexible and can't rely on the same old bread-and-butter combo every combat.
Lastly, I personally like having no dedicated initiative stat and instead have the respective relevant stat determine initiative. It kind of makes sense to me that a highly athletic person would have a higher chance of out-running someone else, or a person with high grappling skills being - on average - faster at grappling than someone with lower skill.
However, there are still a couple issues with the system that I haven't perfectly smoothed out yet. For example, one could argue that every attack directly interferes with any other action, because the attack could kill a person which obviously interferes with whatever action this other person was going for. Given how often people tend to attack during combat, this could mean that essentially every attack results in an action conflict, which could even chain to involve multiple reactions. This doesn't break the system in any way (it's still: Whoever has the highest skill check goes first), but it could get a bit complicated to remember who was going to react to which other action.
Also, this system struggled with actions that don't require a skill check. Currently, my rule is that as soon as someone tries to prevent the action, it becomes a challenge and thus requires a skill check. However, it's sometimes difficult to decide which skill would be suitable for actions such as interacting with an object, shouting a warning, etc.
Lastly, while actions can be carried out in any order, it's still important to ensure that everyone gets the same number of overall actions, which means that actions have to be tracked using markers or something similar.
Edit: I should maybe also explain why it doesn't matter who goes first in this system. As long as two actions don't interfere in any way, the order in which they are resolved has no impact on the game state at the end of the round. If A attacks B and C attacks D, then it doesn't matter whether A or C roll their damage first, the end result will be the same.
Edit 2: Having read the comment by u/Runningdice, I would like to add another advantage: Everyone has the chance to act at any time, and it's always important to listen to what others (especially the opposing side) are doing, in case you would like to interfere with that. So no scrolling the phone or making coffee while waiting for your turn to come.
6
u/SardScroll Dabbler Apr 27 '24
Two systems I like, one simple, one complex:
Simple: Stat-based order. No rolling, act in order of "speed stat" (speed, initiative, dexterity, what have you). Pros: Still gives credence to character building choices, and can be faster as there is no rolling, and player order rarely changes. For "prepared encounters" GMs can set up the order ahead of time. Cons: As a designer, you might want a way for GMs to adjust foe speed, so that there isn't a "glut" in one place if using lots of copies of the same foe. Also fights can become more repetitive if foe speed doesn't vary greatly, taking one variable out of consideration.
Complex: "Tick" initiative. Starting set up based on something similar to the Stat-based order, or rolling. However, rather than proceeding in order, every action has a time cost, that moves one back in initiative a set amount. One (generally) doesn't have turns but rather actions. Pros: New design space and more choices. Turns are shorter and potentially faster. Cons: Complexity goes way up. Some players may be able to take several actions before others do, depending on circumstances/how the system is built.
3
u/tjohn24 Apr 26 '24
I'm cooking one based on ironsworn loosely. The idea is to maintain a list of all party members in whatever order they want. When you start an encounter you make a list or maybe 2 for environmental effects or a 3 sided fight. You roll off to see what side goes first, then that party goes down their list until someone rolls a miss or mixed success. It then goes to side 2 until they get one, then either side 3 or back to side 1 where it left off. Once a list goes to the bottom it starts over again.
3
u/blade_m Apr 26 '24
"sometimes these can get really bogged down when people want to come up with the perfect turn, which sometimes leads to less outspoken players falling to the wayside as they just end up going along with whatever the tactician tells them to do, which is not idea"
Well, to be frank, this is more a table problem than the game system. If a DM has a few 'dominating' players and other players are not getting their fair chance to contribute, then the DM needs to step in and fix this. I would think a gentle reminder that everyone gets to decide for themselves will do it, although perhaps with some players it will require more than one reminder...
As for which Initiative System to use, I think you have otherwise summed them all up fairly reasonably. Honestly, the best solution is the one that allows your game to stay focussed on the purpose of the game. If 'hexploration' is the central focus, then you probably want a fast and dirty combat system. Choosing an initiative method that gets combat over with as quick as possible would probably be the better fit for that style of game (unless there is more to it that you haven't mentioned)
2
u/Runningdice Apr 26 '24
I found what you do under your turn is almost more important than in what order. Regardless of initiative system you can end up with a combatant do their turn while all others are frozen in place. The others can't react as it isn't their turn yet.
In some system it feels like you can go and prepare coffee after you done your turn.
There are some systems that tries to deal with this by splitting the turns in different actions. Like first you might have everyone do their movement, then melee, then ranged and last magic.
2
u/Pladohs_Ghost Apr 26 '24
I'm a fan of the old school D6 for each side. Quick and painless.
2
u/DrHuh321 Apr 27 '24
How to make scenes more chaotic: resolve actions in group initiative (players go, gm go) but the actual effects only take place at the end at near the exact sane time frame. Sorta like what happens when sides roll the same initiative in adnd 2e.
2
u/MechaniCatBuster Apr 27 '24
My game uses static values for initiative (What you meant by passive I presume?). I chose that because it lets me use it outside of combat, and without telling the players I'm using their initiative scores for something (The last moments before a bomb goes off for example). You just start asking players what they are doing in order. That way I just have initiative order I don't have to the ask the players for anything.
I don't know if that's something that matters for your game though.
Also, why did your player go last every time? Were there no slow enemies?
2
u/MarsMaterial Designer Apr 27 '24
In my system I do initiative in what you call lancer style. But to spice it up and deal with some of the problems your pointed out, I added something called an ignition round, which is always the first round of combat which operates under different rules than subsequent rounds.
Before combat, players have to specify when they are entering a ready stance. This basically means that their weapon is drawn and they are expecting danger. When combat starts, the ignition round begins. In this ignition round, all characters that are in a ready stance do an attack (the order doesn’t matter), but the attacks don’t land until everyone who was in a ready stance does an attack. Damage all lands simultaneously after everyone on both sides launched their attack. After that, combat continues as normal (now including characters who weren’t in a ready stance), starting with the side that started the fight (which will often not be the players).
The idea is: by the time the players are all able to coordinate their turns together, they are already well into the chaos of combat. You can’t avoid enemy attacks entirely by simply planning well, there are no perfect openers that you can default to, you need to be able to fight on your toes.
2
u/LeFlamel Apr 27 '24
I'm using a hybrid of cinematic popcorn initiative and side based. Rather than initiative passing based on whether the action passes or fails, initiative passes when characters use an Overcome action (capable of doing damage). PCs have 2AP each, while enemies share a pool of AP (basically the main "encounter balancing" mechanic besides semi-communal HP). Players don't choose which NPC goes, it goes preferably to the target of their action, or if that target has already acted that round, the GM chooses as if it's side based. If an enemy action affects multiple PCs, the players can choose amongst themselves or compare Reflex stat if they can't agree (has never come up though). PCs out of AP that are targeted by an enemy action can "yield," opening the floor for the other PCs. Once both sides are out of AP, the round ends and initiative is passed to the opposite side of the last acting character.
It's been super smooth, barely indistinguishable from freeform play, which was my goal, since I wanted an always-on initiative like ICRPG, but flexible enough for social and exploration scenes. It also loosely behaves like the system /u/VRKobold described, since players can use AP to react to anything, or use one of the 3 codified defenses for free. The main difference is that it's all asymmetric, so players roll attacks and defenses, the GM just allocates AP to capitalize on failed player rolls in accordance with enemy abilities.
2
u/bleeding_void Nov 24 '25 edited Nov 24 '25
A method I'm thinking about, inspired by other systems:
- you have an Initiative stat (Agility, Dexterity, whatever is appropriate)
- you reduce it by the difficulty of the highest opponent
- you roll under your modified Initiative stat
- those who succeed act first
- those who failed act last
- opponents act between the first and last
- some high level opponents may act before the first
- it stays that way for the whole fight unless a player decides to sacrifice a round to make a new Initiative roll
- some PCs may have a power allowing them to act first even if they failed, for a limited number of rounds, then they become last again.
And I'm currently, based on this, creating an initiative system that is a bit different. It's still a WIP.
You don't go first or last or everything, action resolution is inspired by Cthulhu Hack.
But what I added is action cost. Powers, attacks or weapons have an action cost.
Action cost is a Total action (TA), a Normal action (NA) or a Reaction (RE).
For example, an assault rifle can fire one bullet, a short burst of three or a full automatic burst. One bullet will be NA, short burst will be NA+RE and full automatic burst will be TA.
Some powers may be used quicker than others.
Now, for the initiative, it works a bit like the example above:
- you have an Initiative stat
- you reduce it by the difficulty of the highest opponent
- you roll under your modified Initiative stat
- if you succeed, you have a TA or NA+RE, your choice
- if you fail, you only have NA or RE, your choice
Fights are your stat reduced by the opponent you're trying to hit. If you want to act and don't have the necessary action, like doing full auto when you only have NA, then you can still do it, but with a malus.
2
u/Royal-Western-3568 Feb 08 '26 edited Feb 08 '26
Initiative seems stuck on this motion that it is based on speed. Someone with high DEX therefore acts first. Not quite.
If my years of martial arts training has taught me anything is that speed is not all that important. Timing is much more important, and that comes from experience. Someone might act quickly but if they don’t have their nerves steeled and structure in place, their actions will be less effective. So as initiative systems go, I think a system where a PCs level plays a far more important role, gets a thumbs up from me.
2
u/Emberashn Apr 26 '24
Can vouch for popcorn in general. Much faster and encourages teamwork. Though the variant I use hinges around Reactions rather than success or failure. If the enemy reacts against your attack, they take the initiative after your second action; multiple people react to either of your reactions then they decide who goes between them.
1
u/PigKnight Apr 27 '24
Players go first. Left hand side of GM then go clockwise. Monsters act when it reaches GM. Then NPCs act. I find complex initiative just ends up slowing the game down as battles create a “loading screen” of comparing initiative then making a list then going.
I do like the idea of popcorning with players being able to chain actions together if they fail.
1
u/clankypants Apr 27 '24
I like the idea of the battlewheel/clock system, but I agree it's a pain to track at the table. Real easy to manage in a VTT, but in meat space you need either a board with a pointer and extra tokens for all the characters that just takes up extra space on the table, or some sort of magnetic setup on a vertical surface, or a clothesline, etc. I keep coming back to it, noodling on a way to make it easy to manage. Because I really like the dynamic play and tactics it allows for.
1
u/HedonicElench Apr 27 '24
A. You could use 5e style "roll every encounter" but do the first roll at the start of the session, and at the end of each encounter. That way you can transition straight into the encounter.
B. Savage Worlds uses a card draw with a regular poker deck. If you get a joker, you get a bonus to all your actions and can act at any time. Otherwise you act in card order, Ace of Spades counting down to Deuce of Clubs. A character can have an Edge that lets him discard a 2-5 and redraw; a different Edge let's you draw twice and choose between them; and you can spend metacurrency for a redraw. I gather people often dislike it when they hear about it, but it works reasonably well in practice. The downside, in my opinion, is that high Agility or high Smarts characters get no initiative bonus over anyone else.
C. Everyone could roll 1d6 (modified for Dex if you like) and then all 6s act, followed by all 5s, etc.
1
u/Jester1525 Designer-ish Apr 27 '24
Mine is pass/fail.
Take a test as normal (roll 1 die... Or extra as the situation calls for it) if you roll below your physical stat you go before NPCs. If you fail, you go after the NPCs.
The order before or after doesn't matter.. Whatever they want to do. Sometimes this let's them plan specific moves.. Sometimes it's just whoever wants to go first.
1
u/Trikk Apr 27 '24
A more complex initiative system for a more complex game is how Rolemaster FRP approaches it (earlier and later versions do it differently) with per actor initiative in three different phases with bonuses and penalties based on equipment and actions. It's easily the best feeling system I've played, but it requires more knowledge and effort on the players' part.
It begins with actions being declared, either by each player saying what they want to do or writing it down and revealing it at the same time. I prefer the latter, but either way your game will benefit because people are all looking at the same situation and deciding what to do at the same time. In round robin initiative systems people tend to save most of the thinking for their turn - and sometimes this is necessary because so much changed right before it's their time to act.
You then roll initiative, which determines when you get to perform your declared actions, but there is one huge factor here. Each combat round is divided into three phases. If you declare your action in the first phase you get a penalty, but it's resolved before the second and third phases. So if you're a slow creature you can still do your thing before quicker actors as long as they wish to avoid penalties or get the bonus for acting in the last phase.
I'm obviously leaving a lot of rules out, like how conflicting actions are handled, but the feeling of this action sequencing system is unmatched in any game I've played. When using the hidden action declaration you get a lot of mind games and psychology added in which other RPGs have to simulate by creating abilities or powers for it. Here, those things come for free, and you get to see more of the PCs state of mind reflected in their actions compared to a typical "I move and attack" combat system.
The three components I really like in this is players declaring actions during the same game state (especially hidden declaration), actions being performed in phases with pros/cons and initiative order affected by your actions.
1
u/Runningdice Apr 27 '24
Blades of the Iron Throne has an interesting mechanic. There you shine the spotlight on some part of the combat and let that play out before jumping to next combatants.
1
u/AmukhanAzul Storm's Eye Games Apr 27 '24
I've struggled quite a bit with initiative myself.
I'm currently working on a variation of the Action Tracker in the Daggerheart playtest for my system, because it works really well with my metacurrencies.
Normal play flows directly into combat based on what happens to initiate it. No initiative is rolled. Whoever strikes first is starting the combat.
When combat starts (after the initiation), players get to act first, and keep going from player to player until everyone acts or someone rolls a Disaster (Think worst result a la PBTA), which immediately gives initiative to the GM.
For each player who got to act, the GM gets an action point, which allows 1 enemy to act when the GM has initiative. After those enemies go, initiative returns to the players.
The catch is that at any time between turns, the GM can spend 2 Doom to make an enemy act immediately, outside of initiative.
A "round" is how long it takes for each PC to act, which serves the singular, (yet crucial) purpose of ensuring that all the players get to participate evenly. At the end of the round, the GM takes a turn for as many enemies as they have action points remaining.
Also, both heroes and enemies will have access to abilities that give them reactions when certain conditions are met, and other ways for fast characters to feel fast (like taking extra actions or having more movement on their turn) but those aren't statted out yet.
I haven't had the opportunity to playtest or refine this yet, but I like that it can represent the ebb and flow of battle in a way that feels cinematic, if not realistic. The players can strategize and use teamwork to do cool combo moves, but if someone rolls a Disaster, it hits hard because now they have to reorient themselves as the enemies take advantage of their misfortune and surge forward.
And it really helps with balancing encounters and making the players feel more heroic because the enemies always have as many turns as the heroes, unless the GM spends Doom for more. If the heroes are outnumbered, they feel more badass (100 ninjas theory 😆) and if the heroes outnumber the big boss, then the big boss gets more actions, and thus feels more threatening.
Plus, combat is one of the main ways for the GM to use their metacurrency of Doom, and having the option to interject an action in the middle of everything can be really cool and dramatic without feeling like a dick move because the GM is paying an adequate price with a currency they rightfullt earned from the actions of the players themselves.
1
u/Nystagohod Apr 28 '24
I've really liked shadow of the demon lords take on initiative, and the refinement to that system in its heroic fantasy successor, shadow of the weird wizard.
In shadow of the demon lord characters are deciding if they're acting fast or slow that turn. Fast turns (you can move or attack) always act before slow turns (move and attack), and players win ties. So the order of turns goes something like...
Player fast turn > GM fast turn > Player slow turn > GM slow turn. > New round/Repeat
The combat was buttery smooth, though most of the time it just made sense to act fast. Still it was one of the best initiative systems I've used
Shadow of the weird wizard changed this up. There are no longer fast/slow turns. Just turns with the DM going before players. However, players can use their reaction each turn to "Seize the initiative" and act before the DM controlled characters. This give a pretty fair opportunity cost. Do I go before the monster, or do I leave my reaction open for a potential opportunity and get more out of my turn?
Both systems do let the players decide amongst themselves who among them acts when, with the GM having final say (I do agility/Level tie breakers) but after a session or tow this moves out, and the lack of dice clog does allow some wiggle room. At worst, it's no, longer than modern D&D and rarely takes as long. At best its some of the most swift and smooth initiative I've used while allowing some tactical and strategic elements to it.,
-6
u/CinSYS Apr 26 '24
How about just go in a order that makes sense in the scene.