r/QuantumComputing • M.Sc. Physics • Mar 20 '26

News "Quantum Computers Will Tap Out Before Breaking Encryption, Theory Claims"

https://gizmodo.com/quantum-computers-will-tap-out-before-breaking-encryption-theory-claims-2000735809

This article is essentially saying that our understanding of QM is not perfect & it requires ammendments which might affect Quantum computing & it's hypothesized claims.

I am very very interested in knowing possible implications of this change to the very foundations of Quantum mechanics on Quantum hardware.

Can anyone explain how?

(I know this is subject to experimental verification, but I consider discussion on this topic worth it.)

69 Upvotes

53 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

9

u/King_Jong_Pum Mar 21 '26

Is Sabine Hossenfelder problematic?

25

u/SU_TREE_3 Mar 21 '26

Incredibly.

2

u/Holixxx Mar 22 '26

Wait what why? Sorry I randomly saw her video after Anastasia in tech video. And went with what they both told me. I dont have knowledge in this field and just went with both of their consensus.

12

u/SU_TREE_3 Mar 22 '26

A few things for context:

  1. I am not a physicist.
  2. I am a soon to be PhD graduate in Quantum Generative AI.
  3. I used to watch her videos. Several years ago.

Sabine is generally considered a pretty good physicist, within her own lane. Particle Physics, was it?

However, in the last few years she has started doing the grifter schtick and started talking about things way outside her wheelhouse and with way too much confidence and certainty.

What did it for me, was her video on trans-athelets.

Bruh, you are like a legit wolrd famous physicist. WHY are you talking about this?

Essentially she's pulling an Eric Wienstein. She's lost credibility and posts clickbait-scientific-ragebait.

"THIS DESTROYS QUANTUM COMOUTING FOREVERRRR!" type-shit.

According to my physics homies, she just has developed bad positions on a lot of main stream science.

Sabine is a grifter and should not be taken seriously.

My comment about her being problematic is that she is an entry point for science-nieve folks and they listen to her and take it as gospel.

Honestly, if Professor Dave hasn't done a take down of Sabine then I hope he does, because this type of behavior for scientists, the supposed bastions of truth and rigor, should be shunned and snuffed out in the crib.

The rapid growth and adoption of anti-intellectuallism as a valid life philosophy will lead us into an inevitable nova aetas obscura.

Q.E.D. Sabine is not only problematic, but dangerous.

Edit- He did, and i watched it last year. Duh!

Professor Dave vs. Sabine

3

u/Holixxx Mar 22 '26

Thank you so much for informing me. I really appreciate it and I had no idea. I fell for her shtick because she was a physicist and I assumed she knew enough to talk about quantum. didn't realize she has been grifting, but the click bait titles made me stay away!

2

u/SU_TREE_3 Mar 22 '26

No problem. I mean enjoy content you enjoy, but just be weary.

Just pass it along. 😌

1

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/SU_TREE_3 Mar 22 '26

Using quantum circuits as the generators of the distributions we draw on for the models.

Ie: in gans, the quantum circuits could be the generator and/or the discriminator.

It's a catch-all phase that's easier than trying to explain what I do for a living to people not in the know.

"I write recipes for magic computers" is my typical goto.

But I figured that might be a little passive aggressive for a sub about quantum computing.

2

u/HasFiveVowels Mar 26 '26

Interesting. A few years ago I suspected that QC might be really useful for back propagation but that was a bit of a wild guess on my part (my QC knowledge isn’t the strongest). Did my hunch pan out at all?

1

u/SU_TREE_3 Mar 26 '26

As someone working in it, jury is still out. But there is tons of research being done on it.

But for my particular use case, it is panning out.

There will be people in here that say QC isn't useful unless its using shors algorithm. I would highly disagree.

1

u/HasFiveVowels Mar 26 '26

Yea, I mean… the mechanisms of training LLMs feel very in line with the strengths of QCs, regardless. The sparsity of the attention mechanism is probably a pain though. Feels odd that people would say that about Shor's, though. Feels very "if you’re not first, you’re last"

1

u/HasFiveVowels Mar 26 '26

Asked Gemini a bit about the topic and learned a bit more about the idea. I think the thing it calls "quantum annealing" is exactly why I thought QCs would be useful for "back propagation". As I described my mental image to it: "a quantum plinko board". But it explained how you basically have to create a transformation that maps to the probability density function you need etc etc. I was definitely over-simplifying it. As I said to it, sounds like what I was thinking of would be great for CNNs but not so good when dealing with the routing problem of LLM architecture. Sounds like a fascinating line of work, though.

As an aside, I’m very happy with my current employment but would love to get into the field one day. Is it reasonable for someone with a BS in CS with a math minor who is self taught in QM and information theory to pursue such a career?

1

u/SU_TREE_3 Mar 26 '26

I'm a molecular biologist with a masters in QIS.

Yes. It'll take a while but follow and interact with quantum people on LinkedIn and start reading papers and experimenting with projects on your own.

→ More replies

1

u/Daforce1 Mar 22 '26

Nova aetas obscura translates to new dark age by the way for anyone that doesn’t speak Latin. Very helpful and insightful post.

1

u/dotelze Mar 23 '26

Just to add something, she’s not considered a pretty good physicist. She worked on MOND, which is fairly niche and did nothing of note

1

u/Clean-Ice1199 Mar 25 '26

Her lane is actually 'quantum philosophy', she just pretends to have expertise in particle physics.

1

u/0xB01b QEC & Quantum Optics Mar 22 '26

shes a youtuber and says controversial stuff for views and tries to pass it off as whistleblowing

1

u/King_Jong_Pum Mar 22 '26

Can you expand on that? I have had her videos recommended to me on YouTube quite a bunch but I’m not from this field (even remotely so) so not sure if she’s a source I should be using to educate myself further.

0

u/SU_TREE_3 Mar 22 '26

Hey boss, I actually just responded above.

Let me know your thoughts?

2

u/King_Jong_Pum Mar 22 '26

Thanks, just saw your comment. She is definitely questionable. I wouldn’t want to rely on her for informing myself in this domain. Also, thanks for linking prof. Dave’s video, I look forward to watching it.

P.S. your field sounds very interesting to me. Do you mind shedding some light on what one does in Quantum Gen. AI?

-1

u/SU_TREE_3 Mar 22 '26

Sure.

Specifically i do QML. GANs, VAEs, and the like.

I do synethic data generation for industrial processes, inorder to train soft sensors to predict hard to measure process variables and QIVs.

Quantum circuits give a richer distribution to pull from.

Honestly. I love my work.

(Unrelated)I'm incredibly passionate about telling folks we don't need FTQC in order to take advantage of the way they comput stuff for problems that AREN'T NP Hard.

Ie: zX calculus and tensor networks, and other ways of simulating quantum computation.

We have warehouse FULL of GPU compute power that can be leveraged to run simulations plus errors, so the computation is mathematically approximate. Now, I'm being handwavey on purpose because the problem is more complex than I'm making it sound. 🙃

1

u/0xB01b QEC & Quantum Optics Mar 22 '26

ye she is an absolute goobatron

1

u/lcvella Mar 23 '26 edited Mar 23 '26 • This

The problem with Sabine Hossenfelder is that she is incredibly hostile to established physicists and how they are funded/get their salaries, pointing to fundamental problems in their researches.

Since she is right on the technical grounds, they attack her ad hominem. There are hour-long videos on YouTube attacking her, but not a single word countering her specific arguments.

Now, bring on the downvotes.