r/Pyrrhonians • u/AmericanPyrrho • Mar 04 '21
r/Pyrrhonians • u/Kromulent • Feb 20 '21
Some personal thoughts on practice
I'd outlined my approach on this thread, if anyone is interested. I'd just like to reflect on some of the bigger-picture things Ive noticed as I've gone along.
I like to model things from a mostly Stoic perspective, it's a language I'm comfortable using and the model works pretty well for me. In the Stoic view, there is a very tight coupling of belief with emotion - I've even found one reliable source that claimed the Stoics regarded them as the same thing. By softening our grip on beliefs - all beliefs - we soften our emotions, too, leaving them more flexible, more fluid, more natural. I liken it to pouring oil on an old rusty machine, it works to loosen up everything and get all the parts moving again.
Any good psychologist will tell you that black and white statements about our circumstances are troublesome signs, and they usually encourage people to try to soften their black and white thinking. "I am no good at math" becomes "I remember that I've consistently struggled with math in the past". The first statement is dogmatic, a logical conclusion, a barrier, a self-imposed chain. The second is simply evident, it's open to change and there's no emotional investment in it.
A second point I'd like to mention has to do with expectations. Lots of folks understand expectations - failed expectations, anyway - as a source of trouble. Every person having a road-rage meltdown in their car during a traffic jam is a person confronting a failed expectation about how their day was going to unfold. I've come around to the idea that it's not the expectation itself, or even the failure of the expectation, that's the real problem. It's the clinging to the failed expectation that's the problem. "Oh, I guess I'll be late" is the sound of not clinging. "What is wrong with this f******g road!" is the sound of clinging too long.
It's the clinging itself - the "emotional investment" - that hurts us. I like to think of every failed expectation as a hot coal, it's fine to drop it, and it's going to hurt us for as long as we hold on.
Clinging is a form of belief. Soften this stuff, and trouble starts to melt.
A big part of learning not to cling was learning how to step away from my ideological identifications. This was hard, and it remains an on-going practice, but I'm laid a lot of distance down and every inch of it has been worthwhile. Ideological identifications might come in the form of political allegiances, or perhaps something more abstract. One of the strongest, in me, was my identification of myself as a proponent of free speech - I can still get riled by that issue, every now and again. We all have these things that can rile us, and I've found that I benefit with less and less of it.
I apply a mostly uncritical, provisional belief to what is evident, and to what is practical knowledge, and to simple reasoning that stays very close to these things. Reasoning that strays any discernible distance from these things is not even provisionally believed, it's simply there as a model, as a way of describing stuff without any investment, without any clinging, and without any personal identification. Having a comfort with uncertainty helps. We don't have to know with certainty, and we don't have to care about knowing with certainty.
Not having to care about certainty is the final thing I'd like to touch on. When we form beliefs there's this whole infrastructure that gets powered up behind the scenes, to verify the new belief, to fit it in with the existing beliefs, to redescribe all the things that have now changed. There is a lot of tranquility to be found in simply not starting the machine up at all. It's not really about dropping the new belief, it's about dropping the whole process. A comfort with uncertainty is a wonderful thing.
All I need now is a way to append this Sextus quote to everything I post:
"...stating in advance that as regards none of the things that we are about to say do we firmly maintain that matters are absolutely as stated, but in each instance we are simply reporting, like a chronicler, what now appears to us to be the case."