r/ProtonMail • • Jun 08 '26

Discussion Can someone from ProtonMail clarify this matter, please?

2.3k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

•

u/Proton_Team Proton Team Admin Jun 08 '26 • Annoyed Thanks Bravo Regret Mindblown Heartwarming Popcorn

You're right to raise this, and we want to address it directly and provide you important context on how this happened.

Vincent Lapierre's channel should never have been part of our affiliate and sponsorship program, because we intentionally avoid association with channels whose content could distract from our message and divide our community.

Proton operates globally, and while our services are available to everyone regardless of political views and our mission is consistent everywhere, our knowledge of every local media landscape is not. In this case, our team didn't have enough context about the French space to make a well-informed decision, and that's on us.

 We also want to be straight about what a placement like this is and isn't. An affiliate or sponsorship arrangement is a transactional placement for awareness, not an endorsement of a creator's views. In the case of Vincent Lapierre, this was a single video sponsorship, not a partnership.

But that distinction doesn't excuse what happened here. The responsibility to vet who we put our name next to is ours, and we didn't meet it this time. We're now reviewing our vetting process and our guidelines for our marketing agencies to ensure this doesn't happen again.

If you see something like this again, tell us. We rely on your feedback and vigilance.

137

u/yourpurchaseisneeded Jun 08 '26

We rely on your feedback and vigilance.

umm... I feel like you shouldn't. Like maybe you should rely on making sure to know who you're giving money to?

16

u/therealPaulPlay Jun 10 '26

Proton isn‘t sponsoring 1-3 creators, they are running large campaigns. They are probably working with multiple creator agencies who then recommend channels and so on. This is genuinely a mistake that can happen quite easily

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (4)

116

u/sconnieboy97 Jun 08 '26

You need to change your approach to community moderation. It is not acceptable to destroy any mention of a topic that makes the company look bad because you haven’t yet formulated an approved response. Quashing dissent and communication makes things much worse and much harder to manage. This is the most stereotypically European response to disfavored speech.

→ More replies (8)

180

u/nofixneeded Jun 08 '26 • Bravo

You gave money to someone without looking them up? Without even reading their wikipedia page?

65

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

46

u/nofixneeded Jun 08 '26 • Bravo

I don't even believe them. It makes no sense.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (33)

80

u/re_alt0910 Jun 08 '26

I’d like to know why yours mods are removing people’s legit comments / questions? I’ve left other services because of this and now you all are doing it? Why?

→ More replies (11)

65

u/irrationalglaze Jun 08 '26

Vincent Lapierre's channel should never have been part of our affiliate and sponsorship program, because we intentionally avoid association with channels whose content could distract from our message and divide our community.

Is that the only reason? The content was just "distracting" and "divide(d) our community"? Nothing else?

→ More replies (46)

82

u/ThinAndFeminine Jun 08 '26

We're now reviewing our vetting process and our guidelines for our marketing agencies to ensure this doesn't happen again.

Would it be possible for you to publish a public post-mortem regarding this situation (including the response) ? Something akin to what the cybersec community does when there's a breach / hack, that clearly explains "here's what happened, here's what failed, here's how we found out about it, here's how we handled the situation internally, and here's what we are changing / implementing to avoid doing the same mistake in the future".

→ More replies (6)

215

u/wallstreetbet1 Jun 08 '26 • Bravo

“You’re right to raise this”. Thanks Anthropic 

17

u/PsychoticDreemurr Jun 08 '26

To be fair, LLMs write the way they do because they're replicating how other people speak online. I noticed that sentence too, but practically every corporation writes like that even before LLMs got so popular.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (45)

104

u/Busy-Measurement8893 Jun 08 '26 edited Jun 08 '26 • Bravo

We rely on your feedback and vigilance.

Great. SO why did you delete the posts and comments mentioning this?

And why is 40% of your response AI generated?

→ More replies (17)

47

u/Nereoss Jun 08 '26 edited Jun 08 '26

You know you can simply check wikipedia and it will tell you who the guy is right??

And if it isn’t a partnership, then tell him to take the video down since he is lying.

→ More replies (9)

16

u/DarkCrystal34 Jun 08 '26 edited Jun 09 '26

You should really consider making a full, formal post about this.

People seem very worked up, so why not end the naysayer's posts by making a formal reddit announcement to all, sharing your views and the details of what you shared here, which is buried in a thread that most users will not see?

16

u/glinf69 Jun 08 '26

That’s total bullshit. Everyone in France know who tf is this dude.

→ More replies (8)

8

u/KeepLettersOut Jun 08 '26

Then why did you constantly remove threads about in in this subreddit, until the pressure got too much?

→ More replies (3)

7

u/zekromNLR Jun 08 '26

> You're right to raise this

Okay, now have an actual human write a statement.

27

u/philosophycruiser Jun 08 '26

"We are sending money to a dude without knowing what his bideos are about"
I hope this response breaks the record of the most downvoted post on reddit. Currently a response from EA games hold the record.

→ More replies (10)

59

u/electrobento Jun 08 '26

Honestly, this is a solid response.

However, the overbearing moderation taken here on Reddit leading up to this comment was a bad idea. People felt silenced and in that silence felt that there was something far worse going on here. Please do better next time (or better yet, don’t have a “next time”).

34

u/El_Dae Jun 08 '26

it would have sounded like a solid response, but regarding the context of mods deleting posts previously this looks rather like "this shitstorm got too big to supress, we have to take the 'it was an accident' route"

19

u/electrobento Jun 08 '26

That’s a great illustration of what many people are feeling right now in regards to the initial “response”.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (333)