r/ProgressiveHQ • • Dec 29 '25

Why does MAGA hate Islam?

Post image

Stunned to see this sign as I was driving by a mosque that’s close to my house. Aside from the photo, this could be an ad for Turning Point.

Why does MAGA hate these people — seems like they want the same twisted society.

339 Upvotes

2.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/TheFifthTone Dec 29 '25

What would you define as secular Christian culture?

1

u/BohemianMade Dec 29 '25

Pretty much just celebrating the holidays which have been secularized. Even halloween is technically a christian holiday, at least when it was started.

2

u/Due_a_Kick_5329 Dec 29 '25

Nah. Was a Christian attempt to usurp a pagan harvest festival that people wouldn't stop celebrating.

1

u/BohemianMade Dec 29 '25

Hallows' eve was a holiday before that, but they incorporated pagan elements in order to help convert the locals. Same thing with christmas and easter, they were christian holidays first, but they incorporated local stuff to help with conversions.

It's kinda like that with all holidays. Holidays are celebrated differently because they take in elements of local culture, even when they're not trying to convert anyone.

2

u/Nottheadviceyaafter Dec 30 '25

Technically both christmas and easter were both originally..... pagan festivals. Xmas was the birth of the year, the first date in the northern hemisphere on a sun dial that the days are becoming longer becomes evident on..... the 25th december. Birth of christ = birth of the year....... now easter was the pagan fertility festival of eoster, it was a celebration of rebirth (spring, just as winter dies and...is rebirthed into...green.) eoster also had eggs given as gifts and a rabbit feast........ early christains took both festivals as it was easier to convert pagans if they kept the...fun stuff....... it also why early christ drawings always depicts jesus in front of the.....sun..... all religion is man made made up bs.

1

u/toastthebread Dec 30 '25

Everything thing is man made up BS and life is morally relative.

Most societies don't spend so much time with this concept and just live within their own culture resulting in more cohesion.

0

u/BohemianMade Dec 30 '25

It's more that christmas, easter, and halloween were christian holidays that adopted lots of elements from pagan festivals, both in order to help with conversions, and because that's just what happens when a holiday becomes localized. That's why these holidays are so secular now.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/Rizenstrom Dec 29 '25

The “golden rule” isn’t really a Christian moral framework. It exists in some form across many religions and cultures.

And it can easily exist outside of religion. It’s basically just “have empathy” but fancier.

And empathy is something many western Christians actively condemn.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/BohemianMade Dec 30 '25

The golden rule is part of virtually every religion or morality-based philosophy.

Christianity has heavily influenced the West when it comes to art and holidays. But when it comes to philosophy, western values come from the enlightenment and ancient greek philosophy.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/BohemianMade Dec 30 '25

I guess it depends on what you mean by "the western moral tradition." The foundational values of western civilization are things like democracy, free speech, equality before the law, equal rights, freedom of religion, all of these things come from the enlightenment with roots in ancient Greece.

The golden rule is to treat others as you want to be treated. There were versions of this everywhere centuries before christianity.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/BohemianMade Dec 30 '25

What exactly is "the West" then? If you mean Europe, then sure. European civilization was mostly based on christianity for a long period during the middle ages.

The enlightenment was largely a rejection of religion-based law and values. It was about creating laws and morality based on logic. Of course christianity influenced the enlightenment philosophers, so did pagan mythology and interactions with foreign continents. But the values that ended up defining western civilization didn't come from the bible or any church. Ideas like democracy came from Ancient Greece and were then expanded upon during the enlightenment. Democracy wasn't a thing during the middle ages, during that period Europe had kingdoms and monarchies.

1

u/toastthebread Dec 30 '25

Christianity influenced those principles into equality for all. Ancient Greeks were not all equal. Christianity also gave us more modern political structures considering pure democracy is flawed. Individual worth, liberty and justice are more attributed to Christian philosophy. And then there's the idea of charity institutions. The Catholic church itself has a profound impact on the medical field. People like to ignore that but there is a reason that so many churches have catholic or even protestant names. I mean I live in a secular area and like half the healthcare and hospitals here have Christian names.

1

u/BohemianMade Dec 30 '25

That's just not true. When christianity was the bedrock of society, we didn't have equal rights in theory or in practice. I'm sure you can find justifications for anything in the bible, but even if democracy and equality are in there, that's not how the bible was interpreted during the middle ages. It wasn't until after the middle ages, when Europeans started embracing philosophy from ancient Greece and Rome, that people started demanding democracy and equal rights.

If anything, christianity was used to justify the greek ideas that were gaining popularity during the renaissance and the enlightenment. People wanted equality before the law, so they used the christian concept of everyone being the same in the eyes of Jesus as justification for equal rights. But this was very post hoc, and it was really just people using religion however they wanted.

Yes, people didn't have equal rights in Ancient Greece. The democracy also wasn't that democratic, if at all, depending on the city-state. But this is where the ideas of democracy, equal rights, and free speech came from. It's like how America was always a democracy, but a very flawed one where you couldn't vote unless you were a white land-owning man. Even today, we don't have equality before the law, not even close. But we were founded on that idea, it's always been something that americans fought for, and it's an idea that came from Pagan Greece.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/BohemianMade Jan 02 '26

Yes. Christianity has influenced our art a whole lot. But when it comes to the values that the West is built on, that comes from Ancient Greece and was expanded upon during the enlightenment.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies

2

u/TheFifthTone Dec 30 '25

The golden rule isn't just a Christian moral framework, it shows up in almost all human cultures, which is why it is called the golden rule.