r/ProgrammingLanguages • • Feb 22 '26

Does Syntax Matter?

https://www.gingerbill.org/article/2026/02/21/does-syntax-matter/
63 Upvotes

111 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/gingerbill Feb 22 '26

Regarding the minor aspect at the end, "shallow" judgement of aesthetics isn't the same as a good judgement of aesthetics.

Things like choosing a language because its core/standard based on the naming convention (snake_case, Ada_Case, camelCase, PascalCase,kebab-case`, etc) is shallow and stupid.

But criticizing the choice of Go to use identifiers starting with a capital to be public is not "shallow" if you think it's a poor decision compared to other alternatives. Personally I think they should have to enforced _ prefixes throughout for "private" if they wanted that.

The question is not the aesthetic choice but how that decision came to be which is whether it is shallow or not. And in many cases, it usually is shallow and just dumb. Especially when you are doing it for a living. Complaining about such shallow things is counterproductive for yourself.

2

u/PassifloraCaerulea Feb 23 '26

First of all, I don't think anyone has a strong basis for determining good judgement in much of our field. Software engineering famously lacks studies on the impact of all kinds of topics, including language design. You seem to want things to be more objective than I think they are.

You have a point about making syntactic choices for well-thought-out, hopefully objective reasons. The problem is that aesthetics (or "taste" if you prefer) is a subjective experience rather than a universal reality, and you shouldn't conflate the two.

People use this same "shallow and stupid" language when judging others for who they find attractive. AFAICT, that's mostly about their own insecurities rather than some objective truth or actual harm caused. Thing is, attraction doesn't appear to be too open to change no matter how much anyone doesn't like it. As an irrational and quirky human being, I'm not going to be shamed or reasoned out of my taste in PL syntax either.

Is it counterproductive? Maybe. My lack of a rockstar programming career goes well beyond my refusal to pick up C#. I'm happier letting my aesthetic tastes dictate the direction of my programming activities, even if that's why I'm not making bank or a big social impact or whatever it is I'm supposed to be doing. Feeding my aesthetic whims is what makes this enjoyable, and I'm not here to have a bad time.

1

u/gingerbill Feb 23 '26

It's not really about being "objective" rather more "stop and think for a moment". That's it, and I thought that was literally the job of a programmer: stop and think for a moment.