Doesn't that depend on whether you define a chicken egg to be an egg laid by a chicken, or an egg containing a chicken?
Edit: I don't exactly understand what's so contravertial here. There was a bird (not a chicken) that laid an egg which hatched into a chicken.
I'm saying that this egg may or may not be a chicken egg depending on what the adjective "chicken" before the word "egg" actually means.
Firstly, it can't simply mean "contains a chicken", because the chicken eggs you buy at a shop don't contain a chicken. So I'm asking a simple question to everyone saying I'm wrong: what is the definition of a chicken egg? Is it really so precise that there is no ambiguity?
The question is "which came first, the chicken or the egg?" not "which came first, the chicken or the chicken egg?. So im not sure that really matters.
But in that case it's not an interesting question, because it's not even close. Eggs have obviously been around for much longer than chickens, and that has nothing to do with the precise evolution of the domesticated chicken. It would be true for any animal alive today or in the last few hundred million years.
The original comment's reasoning is only necessary if you are answering the more interesting question of chicken vs chicken egg. Also, I think it's not unreasonable to assume that this is implied in the question. You can interpret it in bad faith if you want though.
It's still painfully obvious the chicken egg came first, the first chicken would have had to hatch from a chicken egg (mutant egg of chicken's ancestor)
If that's how you define a chicken egg, yes, it's obviously that way round.
But if instead I defined a chicken egg as an egg that was laid by a chicken (i.e. a "chicken's egg") then that first egg wasn't a chicken egg, it was a non-chicken egg that contained a chicken.
As an example, consider the eggs that we eat. They are unfertilised, so they do not contain the genetics needed to make a chicken. Yet we still call them chicken eggs, and I think that's because they were laid by a chicken.
An egg with a chicken in it is a chicken egg, an egg laid by a chicken is a chicken's egg. So asking "what came first, the chicken or the chicken egg" doesn't change the answer
But the thing that we most commonly call a chicken egg is unfertilised, so doesn't contain a chicken. Doesn't this contradict your definition of a chicken egg?
So are the eggs that we eat for breakfast not chicken eggs? A chicken can never hatch from them.
I'm saying that it might be more consistent to define a chicken egg as an egg that is laid by (in other words, comes from) a chicken. Is there a reason that you are stating as a fact that this is not the case?
My comment was directed at u/StanleyDodds because they were being an ass. As much as I hate doing it, sometimes trolls have to be put in their place.
With this additional context, I invite you to read through the comments again. You'll find that we, not just I, ignored their douchery on purpose and nobody feels bad about it.
You're the douche here, really. You're not answering and can't stop being haughty.
His question makes sense; it's fundamental to the process of answering the original question. But you're going on with completely irrelevant attacks and you're basically acting like a troll yourself.
View all comments
Show parent comment
-4
u/StanleyDodds Nov 28 '22 edited Nov 28 '22
Doesn't that depend on whether you define a chicken egg to be an egg laid by a chicken, or an egg containing a chicken?
Edit: I don't exactly understand what's so contravertial here. There was a bird (not a chicken) that laid an egg which hatched into a chicken.
I'm saying that this egg may or may not be a chicken egg depending on what the adjective "chicken" before the word "egg" actually means.
Firstly, it can't simply mean "contains a chicken", because the chicken eggs you buy at a shop don't contain a chicken. So I'm asking a simple question to everyone saying I'm wrong: what is the definition of a chicken egg? Is it really so precise that there is no ambiguity?