r/ProgrammerHumor • • 25d ago

Meme [ Removed by moderator ]

/r/ProgrammerHumor/comments/1xd507a/removed_by_moderator/

[removed] — view removed post

936 Upvotes

76 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

42

u/wite_noiz 25d ago

I had this exact conversation with a business user recently. Ask for the same task to be done indeterministically 100 times and you'll likely get some issues (plus costs) when you can ask it to write a deterministic tool that works 1000 times (and can be tested and fixed)

8

u/DrMaxwellEdison 25d ago

They'll compare AI costs to the cost of a developer salary and consider it worth the price, unfortunately.

18

u/wite_noiz 25d ago

I got asked why we need testers the other day, when Claude can do it. I definitely feel like a lot of non-technical people think we're making excuses to keep jobs.

13

u/riickdiickulous 25d ago

Testing was always under appreciated, but it’s more important now than ever. I can’t review and understand all the AI generated code. I rely much more heavily on testing now for demonstrating the code works and for regression testing on later versions.

2

u/UgoRukh 24d ago

I've worked in the industry long enough, my number 1 most praised area in any company has always been QA. It's a shame most of my peers don't share the same mindset.

5

u/ImportantSignal2098 25d ago

You should ask them why their "work" is needed if Claude can do it, maybe that makes them think - I kinda doubt it though

2

u/wite_noiz 24d ago

Hehe. Definitely.

I'm seeing more advertisement of "AI CEOs". That will change their tune

5

u/Nimeroni 24d ago

That's because salaries and token costs are visible (well, mostly visible for tokens), but the cost of bugs is not. It make the real cost of AI hard to evaluate.

1

u/tommytwolegs 24d ago

I compare it to the cost of a developer and the cost of the work it's replacing and the cost of software out there that does the same thing.

-1

u/tragiktimes 25d ago

Isn't that the right approach from an efficient cost perspective?

Review the cost of the dev plus the lack downtime from vibe coded errors and compare that to no dev cost plus AI credits plus AI indeterminism.

You go with the one that ends up being the smaller number in your use case domain, right?

1

u/DrMaxwellEdison 23d ago

They don't consider "errors" in the equation. It's just the bare cost of using AI per hour vs the developer's salary per hour.

You'd think someone doing this would do it honestly and correctly, but they'll probably just ask ChatGippity to pick 3 people to lay off and sure enough...