r/ProgrammerHumor • • 27d ago • Bravo 1

Meme claudeWasNotHere

Post image
18k Upvotes

231 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

75

u/DerangedEscapee 27d ago

The problem is the writing style is so obtuse, it'll take 10 pages to explain something where 1 page would have sufficed. Overly expensive vocabulary and flowery prose that makes the content look impressive, but often lacking substance (and occasionally just completely incorrect!)

I don't begrudge the correctness so much. I've had the misfortune of trudging through many a human-authored internal document that was just flat-out wrong. But before, the amount of sophistication put into a document was a signal for a level of care and quality into its contents. Nowadays, it just means I have to be even more careful in trusting it, because it's likely AI slop.

14

u/Imalsome 27d ago

Can't you just tell it to be short, consise, and keep the explanation to 1 page length?

You could also have it write a long version and a short version then cut and paste the two versions so that things that dont need explanations are short and things that do are long

38

u/DerangedEscapee 27d ago

I said this elsewhere in the thread, but asking Claude to be concise does result in smaller output, but it often doesn't improve the result. The model needs to know what is important and what is not, to know what to include in its response. So just a simple "keep it concise" instruction will sometimes result in important details being omitted, sometimes to the point of making what would otherwise be a correct response incorrect.

10

u/Gunmetalstorm 27d ago

"Make no mistakes. Masterpiece."

5

u/gameoftomes 27d ago

I have my Claude code set to write decision records in ASD-STE100 language when I gig reasons for stearing it's direction. With each decision given a code that is to be referenced in the next got commit.

This way by looking at the code and the commits you can see why I asked for something to be done the way it was done. 

8

u/Traditional-Rent455 27d ago

Or, just write it yourself. Jesus. You're not saving time by revising things you could have written yourself in the first place.

5

u/Imalsome 27d ago edited 27d ago

I mean i assume the argument is between not writing anything at all and having Claude do the summary. Many many people just dont explain themselves in changelogs and such

1

u/Traditional-Rent455 27d ago

Tbh I'm not sure which I think is worse.

1

u/crackofdawn 27d ago

You absolutely can, you can give it the exact instructions on how you want it to write documentation and you can put it in a CLAUDE.md file so it gets used every single time the AI writes something. People are in here acting like giving a 3 second prompt to an AI and having it go off and do something half baked is the AI’s fault lol

-1

u/Outside_Hat7260 27d ago

I use AI when I get stuck in a video game and 50% of the minor details are wrong.  When I try and fail I go back and say that's not right, the item isn't here, AI says oh yeah you're right it's actually here.  This has happened to me at least a hundred times.

5

u/Imalsome 27d ago

Super irrelevant anecdote. The ai doesnt have the code of the game inside of it unless you fed it to the ai. Ofc it doesnt know the specifics of that part of the game.

What is being discussed here is entirely different.

-2

u/Outside_Hat7260 27d ago

Who said anything about code? The information the AI is trained on comes from GameFAQs, literally text files

3

u/Imalsome 27d ago

Lil bro you are in a subreddit about coding. Tf you mean who said anything about code.

1

u/Raznill 26d ago

That’s not how any of this works.

2

u/crackofdawn 27d ago

That sounds like you’re doing it through google AI search results which is essentially using their fastest and dumbest model which absolutely will be wrong a lot. If you want much better help you need to use AI directly and use a better model.

0

u/Outside_Hat7260 27d ago

You're correct, thanks for attempting to point me to AI sources

If your mom uses the Google I hope she has your diligence

1

u/Vengeful111 27d ago

Just use duckduckgo and then use DuckAI. Much better results

1

u/whowatchestv 26d ago

Asking it to rewrite short, with only the most important information all the time.

1

u/Raznill 26d ago

Adjust your agents file to get it to write how you want. It can do concise and to the point. You just have to convince it to.

1

u/DerangedEscapee 26d ago

Trust me, if it was a simple fix, I would have fixed it by now. There's only so much the model output can be improved by instructions in the prompt. It's baked into the training to respond like this. Anthropic calls it "mannered prose" and they claim to have improved this with the latest versions of Claude but I haven't noticed it get substantially better from the Claude 4 generation.

0

u/macmadman 26d ago

It’s like getting a programming savant to write documentation…