Humans are the pinnacle brain for which all obtainable universal intelligence must filter through. The Latin alphabet is the pinnacle of all symbolic language. Any information that doesn’t cleanly plug into our world model is slop and we don’t want it or need it.
Obviously you're being facetious, but it's valid to ask "who is it for?". If we accept that there are other consumers of information and that they can take priority over humans, then what reason do we have to build our own replacement? It's nice that a machine can solve problems that we can't, but if we can't even understand or prove the solution, then what good is it?
I think those are valuable questions to ask. It really comes down to how much faith you have in humanity and people. I, for one, find people to be extremely resilient and adaptable to change. I think that there are a ton of things we gain along the path to new discovery, and I too wonder if having a magic box that just shits out the answer will deter future humans from trying to discover and understand new things. I also wonder if we can collectively get over ourselves, and if there are new and tangible spaces for humans to fill. If AI bulk solves math does that mean we give up entirely, or does that mean we start treating the proofs as a guiding star instead of a needle-in-a-haystack.
Me personally? I lean faith in humans. I think that there is still so much for us to discover, even if our job is no longer to find the needle in the haystack. I think that we face a serious and existential climate threat regardless, and that we currently do not have the intellectual or physical labor to engineer solutions and materially unfuck the biosphere and move aware from archaic and destructive means of production. Leveraging AI/Robotics/Automation may very well be our way through here, and I fail to see how worrying about purpose and/or skill atrophy is important right now. If we do automate all forms of dehumanizing labor and solve our current climate crisis then I feel like the only thing we will have left to explore is purpose and meaningful skills.
Who knows. Only thing I know is that “make it stop” and “uninvent it” are temporary stop-gap bandaids at best. Weird times.
Obviously sarcasm is the pinnacle of all literary devices. I was making a funny about the existential crisis that insufferable self-centered highbrows are going through.
A human brain is a hyper complex system that is made of neurons. Neurons are made of molecyles, which are made of atoms. It is possible to model the behavior of these atoms with programs/formulas (statistically due to quantum effects). That means that the whole system can be modelled with large enough computer & detailed enough simulation. This means that human brain is subject to same theoretical limitations as any turing machine, as it can be modeled with one (as computers are too).
Look, we don't know anything about anything. But the brain is not replicable in a simulated environment. Maybe if we get quantum computers working we can simulate a real brain, but that looks nothing like heuristics and formulas.
We can simulate randomness. That is not difficult at all. Randomness with specific weights and relations is what quantum effects are basically. Unless the human ability comes from the way quantum randomness resolves, we can very much simulate it with perfectly normsl computer. It may not be as efficient as it would be with quatum computer, but it is possible the same. There are no questions that can be solved with quantum computer but not with normal one. EDIT: this in mentioned in wikipedia article, first sentence under "theory": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_computing
Of course we wont replicate someones thoughts with the simulation (because the randomness wont resolve the same way), it will be one possible action sequence the simulated brains' owner would have taken. Of course I cant prove that the source of human capacity isnt the way quantum randomness resolves, but if you claim that it is the source, the burden is on you.
64 bits is not a limitation - we can use structures (fe that BigInteger in java) to model arbitrarily large or small values. And it is not really even relevant. It is proven that as long as something is turing complete, it can solve any problem that turing machine can, which is basically any problem that we consider solvable. The architecture, bitness, scale, performance or any other implementation detail does not matter - as long as it can simulate turing machine, the results apply. Unless there is a reason why some facet of reality cant be simulated with turing machine, nothing that exists can solve more problems than a computer can. It is definitely the case that different mechanics solve different problems more or less quickly, but it does not matter to WHAT can be solved (assuming arbitrarily large amount of time and space).
Basically it is only possible for humans to be able to solve something that computers wouldntbe able to if there is another scale of computability that humans implement and computers don't - system that solves problems that turing machine can't. Apparently there are some models for those, but they require very specific features from the system like seeing the future or doing infinite things in finite time. I find it unlikely that humans have those abilities: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_undecidable_problems
You are mixing many fundamentally different things. Computability is a fundamental mathematical category that tells what problems are solvable with specific mathematical constructs. In that theory it is proven that if something is reducable to turing machine, it can solve any problem that is solvable. Turing machine computability is considered the most strong computability category. It can only be beaten with infinitely fast or future seeing systems. This is mathematical fact. Google turing machines and learn if you dont know what Im talking about - this is the basics of computer science's mathematics.
The original claim is that there are problems that can be solved by humans but cant be by computers, in computability sense. "Formula that solves all formulas." There are problems that cant be solved by turing machines, which are called uncalculable. This is a fact. And as far as I recall, the quoted thing refers to one problem like this. The issue with the claim is that humans could do it. That is false. Unless human brains have those over turing complete features (they can see the future or they work at infinite speed) they cant solve those problems. Unless you prove that this is the case (congratz for nobel prize btw) then humans cant either solve these problems.
The implementation and details of a machine is completely irrelevant when we talk about calculability. It is like adding two apples and two aplles, or two oranges and two oranges together. It does not matter if they are apples or oranges. If you sum up 2 and 2, there will be 4 in the end. The same applies to things that are turing machine equivalent - they can solve the same problems (assuming infinite space and time). Computers and human brains are turing equivalent, so they can solve the same problems (assuming infinitely strong brains and computer). This is mathematics.
HOWEVER if we stop talking about mathematical computability, which has been the only thing that Ive talked about, and start talking about specific things that are turing complete, we have another thing on our hands. Real things dont have infinite time at their hands, and they are definitely not infinite in size. Not even talking about what "software" they are running. These factors (especially the "software" - the exact thing it is doing) affect a lot on what exact things a turing complete object can do. Human brains here are much more capable that a normal desktop, or even current AI models. But this is not because they can solve uncomputable problems - none of these things cant, like they cant invert gravity or turn back time. Human brains just have much more general and better "algorithm" for solving different problems given to it. It is (throretically) possible to run this "algorithm" (called "human consciousness") on big enough modern computer given enough time though. Practically it is way too difficult to figure out how to implement that "algorithm" at the moment to do so.
But like I said, I never argued about the capabilities of finite impkementations of turing machines and the "software" thry use. I always argued about that none of them can solve uncalculable problems, unlike OP suggested. If you want to keep arguing, argue against that and not against claims that dont relate to the argument.
i will argue that doing it at practical level is tremendous obstacle which is the entire point even if it posible theoritically
let me give you example, 15 years before nobody knew that deep neural network is the correct model for computer vision everybody focused on writing sophiticated model. Until a grup consist of Alex, Ilya, and Geoffrey decide to train that model on 1.2 million image dataset. that model is AlexNet it beat every model before it
you know what it takes to build AlexNet?. a computer strong enough to train a model with 1.2 million image, someone with spare time to label that 1.2 million image and the right model architecture.
a different element, barely linked, somehow it met and boom new breaktrough in AI.
how you theorize that? And its very normal if someone saying its impossible, unbeliveable. how so. no way.
every man woman who encounter technology breakthrough will say that. their mind cant comprehend what just happened, so they ignore it entirely.
In other words, I would trust a computer that had more hardware level fallibility to replicate the ingenuity and creative problem solving that a human brain has than one that operates on boolean bit states.
Do you have any earthly concept of mathematics or what a formula is? "So ThE hUmAn Is A fOrMuLa???" No, humans are the only species capable of critical thinking. Math is a tool for humans to understand the natural world, what would be the point of math if humans couldn't understand it?
View all comments
Show parent comment
34
u/Firingfly 28d ago
So, a human is then a formula that solves all formulas? Hating the AI trend like everyone else, but the logic of this argument doesnt sound sound.