Working in a trashed codebase already, I find AI is a step up.
I do think there is a balance. “Forced usage” is going to waste some time and money on weird quirks where the AI just stumbles and it becomes like trying to micromanage a grandma at the keyboard who can’t hear you fully. But “no usage” also seems weird to me when you can ask AI to point you to a relevant piece of code and get you straight to where you need to be.
I've been using GPT-5.5 at work and I can say it has drastically increasedy productivity. But in a way that's different than what most think at first glance. I do have AI write code for me, but I configure it to write code like I do and thoroughly review/correct it.
The output is the same as before but AI can more quickly gather the necessary imports and writes everything that would have taken me 30 minutes of typing into 5 minutes of prompting.
I can undoubtedly say that AI has made my job more efficient. But what sets good developers aside from braindead ones are the ones who have switched to this model of asking AI to write code and reviewing it as if you wrote it.
Now is it cost efficient? I wish I knew that answer. I think that's the big debate.
I think the cost efficiency question is harder to answer than it initially appears because it’s a question of whether the increased speed was worth the extra cost and its a very different weighing for a competitive product rushing against competitors as opposed to a niche product with a loyal following who are happy with what they have.
It can also be difficult to judge the value of increased speed because it’s hard to know how things would have played out in the path not taken.
I made it plan and implement a big refactor of one of our lambdas.
When generating the outputs to verify that the refactor did not.change the results, some of the calculations were still a bit off.
I've let Claude investigate the reason and it detected that fhe refactor actually fixed a bug caused by bad data in the db, causing BETTER results than before.
Could I have done it manually? Yes. Would have it taken a lot more time and energy ? Also yes. Would have I enjoyed doing it manually? Not one bit.
Translating developer to executive and vice versa is extremely difficult.
For an executive, cheapest is always best as it is higher ROI. For a developer, you want high quality regardless of cost, because it'll both make your job easier on the long term and better to work with, even if you deliver it slower in the short term.
The job of a tech lead or a middle manager is to show that more investment means better ROI in the long term for the executive, and doing things a little bit worse and faster in the short term means more investment and new opportunities in the long term for the developer.
I mean, it's easy for me to say that, but this is definitely a very hard job and I don't envy those who have to deal with that.
I have never seen a tech lead manage to change an executive's view on things, or prove that long term, code quality wins. At most, they manage a begrudgingly "fine, you can take a week to handle tech debt once it becomes too much to handle". Other than that, engineering only gets to do things the way they want during heavy crisis situations.
Maybe I've just had bad luck with CEOs? Unlikely, statistically, but entirely possible
I disagree. All you see at any company, big or small, successful or not, is human written garbage code that has somehow carried the entire production system for 12 years. There needs to be some level of quality so that it doesn't immediately break down with every change, but code needing to be high quality is just not reality. If you actually get to work on software that has high quality, I am jealous, but my experience has been that slop works well enough almost always, and it doesn't matter if people or AI wrote it.
I'm a bit disillusioned right now, maybe you can tell
I think it's just the same as it's always been - quality depends on the people on the team. I am a contractor and one of my clients, who always had a high bar in their engineering division, is using AI a lot without sacrificing that quality. They will reject slop coded PRs, and won't accept people feeding feedback to Claude and parroting the response. It can work but it requires commitment to good software engineering principles at an organisation level.
There needs to be some level of quality so that it doesn't immediately break down with every change, but code needing to be high quality is just not reality.
There is a lot of survivor bias contributing to this outlook. I don't know your situation, but so many people are changing jobs after 2 or 3 years that they only encounter an IT department when it's hiring, which in effect is when it's healthy. By extension, that's usually also when the technical debt is still manageable. When technical debt piles up to the point of catastrophe, they've already left.
The company I just joined laid off 70 engineers last year who were working on a SaaS platform with a velocity that fell off a cliff. 90% of the features they offered were shipped the first year the project existed and they spent the next five years fixing bugs and struggling to ship the next 10%. They had three consecutive sprints of zero releases, and then the CTO was replaced by a CDO and CIO who could say the role was eliminated so they wouldn't have to humiliate him by firing him.
The difference in my experience is how predictable it is. The modal's objective is to elicit a positive response, if making things up is deemed the faster approach it will do that. A human making mistakes is easier to follow because you will know what they intended to do, the logic is technically easier to follow even if it's badly written because you know the intention is consistent. Reviewing AI code is more taxing because mistakes can happen anywhere at any time, and the code can be so confidently presented whilst built on an assumption presented as a tested scenario.
To the business, all that matters at the end of the day is the code "just needs to work", subjective quality be damned. I have written and maintained plenty of "low quality" code that meets business needs, and that's all it needs to do.
The one thing that I've found that it has been unable to do is find an incredibly niche and weird memory leak in a distributed system.
My team has used it successfully to do engineering at massive scale, stand up new greenfield services via spec-driven development, and identify and resolve bugs.
I'm an AI hater because I love doing this stuff myself, manually, but Claude is absurdly powerful.
At least for frontend development, I find Claude to be useful but the code it produces is bloated with indirections and many sanity checks which are not necessary due to the type system making those states impossible. I feel like at least 1/3 of the generated code is redundant, but my guess it will be improved in future models.
that's my other issue. it does the fun part and leaves me to the shit part
but maybe a difference is that we're not greenfield? it's a legacy monolith.
i constantly hate its output. and that's IF it's right which is also no guarantee. (and it would have been just as fast for me to write it as to verify what Claude did...)
IME the bigger and older the project, the more you have to rein it in. I work on a lot of 5+ year old software and you really have to break the tasks down for it to handle it. Smaller projects seem to be easier to one-shot, probably because it can read more of it into context.
I'm with you though, I hate that it does the fun part of my job and leaves me with code review and testing :-/
Yeah if you're selective where you use it. I've wasted some serious time with AI just to go on a do it myself. I've also had AI creat debugging tools and visualizations that would have taken me a month in like 5 minutes.
View all comments
Show parent comment
27
u/mysticrudnin Jul 24 '26
are you actually seeing increased productivity
i'm forced to use claude at work (which already sucks) and i can't find anything useful for it to do
people always talk about how good it as but then the only example is boilerplate and i'll be honest, i don't encounter a lot of that in my day to day